Thomas Hartshorne interview, 04 May 2005
Abstract
Thomas Hartshorne, professor emeritus of History at Cleveland State University describes the early years of Cleveland State University's existence and its development over time, as well as reactions to the Kent State shootings on May 4th, 1970. Computationally-restored audio. Interviewer questions are not audible.
Metadata
Interview Transcript
Transcripts may contain errors.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:00:13] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:00:16] 1935.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:00:18] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:00:20] In Madison until I was 10. Then I moved to Detroit with my family, went back to the University of Wisconsin when I was 16, in the early '50s, and was pretty much a resident of Madison again from that point until I went into the army, where I wound up being stationed in Cleveland. That's 1959. Been here ever since.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:00:47] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:00:49] Yes.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:00:51] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:00:54] A better job for my dad, right at the end of World War II. He'd just gotten out of the army, and his cousin's husband got a job for him at Chrysler in Detroit, and that was better than the job he'd had in Madison. So we moved.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:01:12][inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:01:14] Yes.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:01:15] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:01:18] I miss Madison desperately, as does everybody who's ever lived there. [laughs] I missed hills, when I was growing up in Madison. It was almost literally the case that from anywhere in the city limits, you could blindfold someone, spin them around three times and push him in any given direction and within 10 minutes walk into a lake. That was not true in Detroit. And I missed that.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:01:48] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:01:53] I started out not knowing what I was going to do at all and took an American history course simply because it was a requirement and fell in love with it. Never looked back.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:02:11] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:02:12] Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:02:18] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:02:25] I had finished all of the requirements for my PhD just before I got drafted. Then as soon as I got out of the Army, I started working on my dissertation and stayed in Cleveland because my wife managed to get a job at Karamu House running the dance department there, and I could work on my dissertation just as well as here as back in Madison. So I stayed here. And then after I'd gotten far enough along on it, I got a job teaching at Kent State. Well, actually, Kent State ran extensions here in the Cleveland area, and I got a job teaching nights for them. And then when Cleveland State came into existence a few years later, they absorbed the local branches that Kent State had been running. And so I became a part of Cleveland State, almost from the very beginning. I think I was teaching for Cleveland State the second year that it offered classes. So I was here almost from the beginning.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:03:35] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:03:39] Let's see, my first year, Cleveland State would have been '66 or '67, I forget which.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:03:47] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:03:52] The first apartment. Well, I roomed with a couple of people while I was here. First, my wife was a dancer and she was in New York. And the first apartment we had together was at the corner of 107th and Carnegie. The building was no longer there, but we stayed there for many years. Let's see, when did we move? We moved in 1968, we moved to East Cleveland and then we moved to the house we're in now, which is in South Euclid.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:04:29] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:04:37] Well, basically the fact that it's no longer a residential neighborhood, when we were there, it was quite convenient. There were a lot of things going on. The corner of 105th and Euclid was still very vibrant and very alive. They had movie theaters, marvelous farmers market a little ways down 105th Street. Now, large parts of the neighborhood are, you know, big office buildings, empty lots, commercial. It really doesn't give the feeling of being a residential neighborhood anymore. Cathedral Latin High School was right across the street on 107th Street, right across from John Hay. That's gone. It was a neighborhood to live in at that point. It no longer is, really.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:05:33] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:05:39] Yeah, quite a bit because all of the big department stores were still in existence. So yeah, we did spend a lot of time downtown shopping, going to movies. The theater wasn't nearly as good as it is now because Playhouse Square was still movie theater theaters rather than stage theaters. But yeah, there was more to draw us downtown then than there is now, certainly.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:06:10] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:06:12] No, no, not at all. The last time I have- I can't remember the last time I deliberately went downtown for something. Passed through, but as a destination- Going to the library a couple of times. But that's it.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:06:32] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:06:36] Yeah, pretty much.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:06:39] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:06:41] Well, frequent forays down to Playhouse Square for theater and dance and things like that. But other than that-
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:06:52] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:07:04] Basically the campus was Fenn Tower and Stillwell Hall. [00:07:09] Shortly after that they built a whole lot of temporary buildings in the area just north of Fenn Tower where the physical education building is. Then the next big project was the Main Classroom building. Then I forget the sequence, Rhodes Tower, whether Rhodes Tower or University Center came next. I believe it was Rhodes Tower, then University Center, then the science building somewhere in there, in the physical education building. But basically it was Stillwell Hall and Fenn Tower, when CSU started.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:07:54] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:07:59] Yeah, there were classes in Fenn Tower and in Stilwell Hall both. [00:08:06] Then when all of those temporary buildings went up in the late, when was it, would have been late '60s, most of our classes, at least most of the classes in the history department were in those temporary buildings. Then as soon as the Main Classroom building was completed, most of the operations moved over there.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:08:28] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:08:43] I don't really see that there's much change in the social aspect of the campus. CSU was a commuter school from the very beginning and it's remained one. So in that respect things haven't changed much.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:09:01] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:09:02] Students, a very high proportion of students have part time jobs that hasn't changed. Average age of students is considerably above what you think of as the average age for college students. That hasn't changed. One thing that I think has changed is that at the very beginning, there were a lot of people at Cleveland State. There was, let me put it this way, there was a real, a much bigger variation in the overall quality of students at the very beginning, I think, than there is now. I don't know whether that's because of the impact of community colleges so that we get transfer students who are better prepared. But in the early years at Cleveland State, in the survey history courses, there would always be a handful of people who were just completely unprepared for college. There are some like that now, but I think fewer on the whole.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:10:13] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:10:14] I don't think, we're still an open-admissions university as we were at the very beginning, but I think people who think they might have problems with college are more likely now to start out by going to one of the community colleges so that by the time they get here, they know more about what college is supposed to be all about. They're better prepared to deal with it. That's about the only change that I can think of on hand as far as what's happening in the student body.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:10:50] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:10:56] In general, yes. Although I will say, you know, the best students that we got very, you know, in the early years of CSU would stack up against the best students that we're getting today. It's just that there, I think there was a larger proportion on the bottom end than is true now.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:11:20] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:11:27] Not really. No. No.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:11:33] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:11:42] In general, I think my perception is- And now this is pure guesswork on my part, but my perception is that most of the people who wind up getting degrees from Cleveland State stay in the Cleveland area. If you look at the people who are among the movers and shakers in this community, very high percentage of them have degrees from Marshall Law School. And that to me, says, among other things, that the people who get educated here tend to stay here rather than going someplace else. Or at least a high proportion of the people who get educated here and stay here wind up becoming leaders in the community.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:12:38] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:12:41] Yeah. One other thing about that, about students that I should mention, I think from the very beginning, and that's remained, I think, true now, is that a very large proportion of Cleveland State students are the first people in their family who have gone to higher education. That was certainly true at the beginning, and I think it's probably equally true now.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:13:13] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:13:21] Well, for one thing, because CSU is newer, it doesn't have the tradition also, because CSU really was created for the purpose of providing an opportunity at higher education for people in the Cleveland area who didn't have the means to go away to school because it would simply be more expensive. So from the beginning, the official statement of mission for Cleveland State is that we're an urban university, which means we're supposed to cater to people in the immediate surrounding. And I think from the very beginning, we've done that, and we continue to do it. That's part of what we're supposed to be doing as a university.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:14:15] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:14:25] Yeah. Yeah. That's, you know, I think CSU was created in large part to fill that educational gap, and I think we've done it.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:14:39] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:14:55] Yeah. There was one uproar on campus. At the time of the Kent State shootings, a group of Black students who were unhappy about a lot of things staged a small protest, and some damage got done to the cafeteria, which was at that time located in Stillwell Hall. And there were rallies and speeches. Oh, an attempt for the last six weeks or so that remained of the quarter to come up with some kind of alternative educational plans. You know, new courses that would be, I'll use the slang from the time or the language of the time, more directly relevant, studying contemporary issues and things like that. That lasted for the remainder of that semester and for the next year, and then it pretty much petered out.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:16:05] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:16:05] This was 1970. Yeah.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:16:13] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:16:14] Yes. I'm trying to remember you-
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:16;22] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:16:23] I'm pretty sure it was before Rhodes Tower.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:16:30] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:16:32] Yeah, he was the governor. Originally, it was called University Tower, it was not named Rhodes Tower until after a while. But I'm pretty sure that it had not been built yet. I'm not even sure that the main classroom building is in use at that point.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:16:52] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:17:06] Not a big crowd. Cleveland State was not what you would call a campus with a high degree of activism, like Kent or like Case Western Reserve. Most of the people who were here were interested in coming here, taking their courses, and going home.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:17:29] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:17:30] There were, you know, speeches that were angry about what happened at Kent State, and a lot of bitter criticisms of Rhodes for calling in the National Guard in the first place. And, you know, there was discussion of having a student strike, which was something that was going on in many other college campuses at the time. That pretty much that never really got off the ground because most students didn't want it. This alternative educational experience that I talked about was really put into place largely because there were some faculty who thought that this would be a good thing to do. Not a great deal of student involvement or student push for it though. I think most of the initiative for that came from the faculty.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:18:30] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:18:42] Quite deeply divided.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:18:47] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:18:49] A lot of people were basically supportive of the students, were appalled by what had happened at Kent State. But then you also found faculty members who were. Who, like a lot of other people at the time, thought that the National Guard had acted properly at Kent State, who thought that student disruptions on campus should be prosecuted very vigorously. And that included the one that took place here at Cleveland State. So there was a deep division among the faculty about these issues. And generally, I would say that it tended to follow disciplinary lines. People in the social studies and the humanities tended to be further toward the left politically. People in the natural sciences and business college tended to be more toward the right politically. Lots and lots of individual exceptions both ways. But in general, I say that's how the lineup broke down.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:20:06] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:20:23] There was talk of expelling them, and I think one or two were suspended for the rest of the semester, but most were readmitted on a kind of unofficial probation. In other words, if they didn't cause any more ruckus, nothing would happen to them.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:20:49] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:20:53] No, I was at Cleveland State when this happened.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:20:57] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:21:00] Yeah. No, no, I was here in Cleveland.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:21:04] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:21:08] Oh, yeah. I happened to be with one of my colleagues. We'd had prearranged date for dinner at their place, and basically we sat watching and listening to television and went out and got pizza because we just wanted to find out what was going on. And we were absolutely appalled by the fact that four people had gotten killed and a dozen or more fairly seriously wounded. My response was basically that this is just something that you don't do on a college campus. And then I became very interested in what had happened and followed up on the historical research about the actual events at Kent State. And the more I learned about what had gone on there, the more appalled I became. At first I thought, okay, this was the Guard's response to coming under attack by students. But you don't respond to people throwing rocks at you by shooting bullets at them. Then I found out that the guys who actually did the shooting were not having rocks thrown at them at the time that they shot. So later on I found out that I may have been using the word murder metaphorically to describe what happened. Later I found out that it was literally the case. The standard story at the time was that the guard was acting in self-defense. Then I found out that that's completely untrue. They were at that moment in no need whatever of trying to defend themselves.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:23:23] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:23:36] Not really, except for being a consistent voter and occasionally making contributions to political campaigns and doing things like that. But no, I've never been a great joiner of political groups.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:23:56] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:24:14] Yeah, not really. The high point of that kind of student involvement and activism was in the late '60s, early '70s. The things surrounding Kent State, a lot of African American students beginning to push for African American studies, particularly in the history department. They want a Black history course which we put into the curriculum sometime in the early '70s and fairly directly in response to student pressure. That wasn't the only factor, but that certainly was one of them. And at that time too, there was a movement to get students, student membership on some of the more important college and university commitments. But that's pretty much fallen by the wayside too. But that was the high point. And I can't really think offhand of any kind of organized student protest or involvement that reached the levels that it was at back in late '60s, early '70s.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:25:39] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:25:58] Two things, basically. The one I mentioned before, or it's a commuter school. So people come here, they take their classes, they go home, largely because a very high percentage of them have other obligations. You know, family, jobs, what have you. The other factor, and I think it's closely related to the first one, is that most students here really have a very high vocational emphasis. They see this as something that is going to improve their opportunities to get a good job, and they focus in on that. And the other aspects of college life really don't make, you know, they're not that important. As it would be for a typical freshman going to. Even as I did to a state university. The idea of finding out who you are because you're away from home for the first time in your life and you're acting to a certain extent on your own. That's an important part of college life for most people. For most people at Cleveland State, it isn't because they're not away from home.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:27:17] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:27:25] No.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:27:26] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:27:40] No. I think there's a lot of- of interaction among faculty. I was involved before I semi retired. I was involved in student university government in many different ways and on many different levels. And yeah, I would say in general that the level of interaction and cooperation here is at- at least as good as what I have heard it to be in other institutions. I don't have direct knowledge of other institutions because I've been here all my life. But from what I've heard from friends and colleagues in other places, the way in which faculty here work with each other, interact with each other is probably greater than in most other institutions.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:28:40] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:28:40] Yeah, yeah.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:28:42] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:28:44] I have no idea. I think it's either. Well, I do have a guess. And that is simply that from the beginning we were, as a fan of, conscious of the fact that we didn't have any traditions here. So we were trying to build them. We were trying to build a university culture. And because of that felt need there evolved a university culture in which there is a high degree of faculty involvement with the internal affairs of the university.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:29:27] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:29:32] I'm trying to remember. Well, one of the first things I did was get involved in that program I talked about to come up with alternative educational experiences. It was one of a three person committee that was charged with the responsibility of reviewing proposals for new alternative courses and saying, yeah, this seems sensible or that one needs work or no, this is a cockamamie idea. Forget about it altogether.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:30:06] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:30:08] I can't remember. I do know- I can remember some of the ones that actually wound up getting taught. They had to do with issues like feminism. There was one on, I remember on the Vietnam War, there was one on African American literature. One, there were a couple that had to do, do with sort of internship kind of things, dealing with political activism in the community in Cleveland. It was partly classroom learning but mostly getting involved in actual activities. As for some that got rejected, actually, I'm not sure come to think of it, that there were any that got rejected. I suspect that there were a couple or two, but I can't remember any of those that said, no.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:31:22] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:31:28] Not now because I'm retired. And one of the conditions of being retired is that you basically don't do anything but teach the classes that you're involved with.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:31:40] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:31:43] Let's see, this is the fourth year that I have been retired. No, fifth actually.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:31:53] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:31:56] Well, let's see. When I retired, which was five years ago, I had 38 years in the system and four of those, three of those were at Kent State.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:32:14] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:32:16] Well, I really wasn't at Kent State. I was teaching night classes at various high schools in the Cleveland area because Kent State ran extensions. And what I was teaching there was basic entry level survey courses, Western civilization and American history. And one of the reasons I liked coming down to Cleveland State so much the year after Cleveland State started was because I got a chance to teach upper-level courses for the first time. So I never really was on the Kent campus. I was always at Cleveland.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:33:01] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:33:03] Okay. Let's see-
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:33:10] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:33:13] Oh yeah, one thing, one of the ideas behind creating Cleveland State, I think, well, a couple of people mentioned this was the idea that Cleveland State was going to revitalize this area of Cleveland. But it hasn't really. There's been a lot of destruction in order to add land and space to the campus, but there hasn't been the upsurge in university related business that I think most people were hoping for. If anything, I think there's probably been a decline somewhat, but the immediate neighborhood isn't quite as vibrant and vital as it was when the university was created in the first place.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:34:10] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:34:19] Oh, gosh, that's so hard to say. There has been, you know, I think there has not really been much change in the immediate surroundings over the past 20, 25 years and, you know, lacking. I really have no idea. Well, one of the things that people are talking about is getting more resident students here, building more dorms and I think if that happened, that might have an impact. But on the other hand, if you look at the area around Case Western Reserve, which is predominantly a residential campus, that's not really thriving either. So. Yeah, I don't know.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:35:11] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:35:16] Not that I could think of offhand.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:35:19] [inaudible] Thomas Hartshorne [00:35:24] Okay.
Natalya Pogrebinsky [00:35:27] [inaudible] [audio compromised to end of recording]
History 304: Urban History
These course-based oral histories arose from the CSU Department of History collaboration with Greater Cleveland Regional Transit Authority, Cleveland Public Art, and WCPN/WVIZ (ideastream). Interviews in this collection were conducted by students in U.S. Urban History (HIS 304) at Cleveland State University Department of History, supervised by professors Mark Tebeau and Mark Souther. Originally intended to inform the creation of public art along the RTA’s Healthline BRT route, these interviews…