Elliot Gordon interview, 14 April 2005
Abstract
Elliot Gordon is interviewed for his thoughts on Cleveland and its development since he moved to the city for school in the 1980s. Poor sound quality.
Metadata
Participants:
Gordon, Elliot (interviewee) / Dhindsa, Dhruv (interviewer)
Collection:
History 304: Urban History
Institutional Repository:
Cleveland Regional Oral History Collection
Interview Transcript
Transcripts may contain errors.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:00:05] What is your name and where do you live?
Elliot Gordon [00:00:08] My name is Elliot Gordon and I live at 1962 East 124th Place, Cleveland, Ohio 44106.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:00:17] Have you always lived there? Were you born there or when did you move here to Cleveland?
Elliot Gordon [00:00:23] No, I moved here to Cleveland in 1980 to go to Case for engineering. I was about 30 years old at the time. So right now I'm 53. And basically between 1980 and 2005, I've spent most of my time here in Cleveland. Short stints in Finland and short stints in France.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:00:49] So basically you've been in Cleveland since 1980. Where were you before that?
Elliot Gordon [00:00:53] I was born and raised in Connecticut and was there until I was 20 years old. I went to school in Tennessee and lived in France during the 70s, and that pretty much brings us up to the 80s.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:01:12] So how was college life in the 80s in Cleveland, being at Case? What is it like? Is it the same as it is today, or was it like very different back in the '80s?
Elliot Gordon [00:01:23] I imagine it's pretty similar now because Cleveland is not known for its wildly social schools. Campus is set up very sort of a sterile social manner. The curriculum is pretty tough and, you know, there are fraternities, the usual college thing, but I imagine it's probably pretty much the same.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:01:54] Were there a lot of different ethnic groups with you when you were in college? Or essentially, was it like Caucasian? What is the essential breakup as such?
Elliot Gordon [00:02:05] There was a good mix of different ethnic groups. Well, with notable exceptions, Case was well represented, except for maybe a couple of ethnic groups. But yeah, I would say otherwise it was fairly well rounded.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:02:26] Okay, and so you lived on campus or you lived around Case. Where did you live?
Elliot Gordon [00:02:31] I lived mainly in Cleveland Heights and in Shaker Heights during the time that I was. And I spent a lot of time down in Little Italy and down in- Actually I lived on East 116th Street. So I know the Little Italy Euclid corridor area pretty well.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:02:59] So how was life back in the '80s along, say, Euclid Avenue in Little Italy? Was it like essentially like a segregated neighborhood or was it like a mixed ethnicity? What is it like?
Elliot Gordon [00:03:12] Well, the Euclid through Cleveland was pretty much a war zone. All of the mansions that had lined Euclid during the heyday of Cleveland were all falling into disrepair and or were being torn down. So the whole face of Euclid was changing. Down by the Clinic, the Clinic was buying up all that property and basically putting in, first of all, making empty lots and then looking at longer term development. So during the time that I was at Case, mainly a lot of property was falling into disrepair or was torn down. There wasn't a lot of building going on. It looks like a war zone.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:04:02] So today the situation has improved compared to what it was, or is it the same today?
Elliot Gordon [00:04:08] The situation has improved quite a bit, although there are still. Well, there are shopping centers, malls near the clinic, where really, you know, there was nothing. Euclid, down between the Clinic and downtown really hasn't changed that much, to tell you the truth. Except for where the mansions are missing. Commercially, it's pretty much the same. It's not flourishing.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:04:41] So when you used to be living here in Little Italy and along the Euclid area, did you shop in these areas or did you go out to, like, the suburbs to shop?
Elliot Gordon [00:04:52] No, there was nothing on Euclid at all. Basically. There were a couple of restaurant supply stores that I would go to, but other than that, there was nothing.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:05:03] So, like, what about stores like in the Halle building and like Sterling and May's and all these stores which used to be there in downtown? Did you ever go there to shop?
Elliot Gordon [00:05:15] Downtown, yeah, yeah, occasionally. Downtown Cleveland was and is still relatively dead. I mean, there wasn't, wasn't a lot of activities going on down there. If you wanted a really good shopping center with longer hours, it was best to go out into the suburbs.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:05:38] When you first came here to Cleveland, do you have, like, any particular memory of, like, this area, this neighborhood, Little Italy, Euclid, maybe, like, downtown? Any one particular memory which sticks out in your head?
Elliot Gordon [00:05:54] Not really, other than the fact that I didn't really particularly feel altogether that safe or comfortable in the neighborhood because it was deteriorating, and especially the race relationships were not good. So I remember distinctly going into a liquor store down on East 105th and Euclid, and it wasn't fun. I mean, I knew people were looking at me, and they weren't looking at me in a good way. Oh, there was also a billboard up on Euclid in East 105th that said, basically, you know, us Black folk know what we want. As far as we're concerned, you white folk can just stay out, keep your nose out of our business. It was not very pleasant.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:06:50] There was a lot of racial tension in the air at that point of time. Right?
Elliot Gordon [00:06:54] A lot of racial tension, yes.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:06:56] And is it the same. What do you think? Is it the same today or has it improved or gotten worse?
Elliot Gordon [00:07:02] I think, by and large, the clinic bought up that area. And so all those businesses, all of the concentration of, you know, all those people are now working for the Clinic. So I mean, yeah, it's little bit more civilized and looks a little bit more safe. I still, even though the police department is down there, I don't really particularly go walking down there. Go walking in the lagoon. It still holds its danger. And then if you go to the very far east side of Cleveland on Euclid, it hadn't really changed a whole lot. It's still not a good deal.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:07:51] So where do you think, I mean, Gordon, you. Where do you think the problem lies as to which- Where does this crime stem from? Is it one particular cause or are there numerous causes?
Elliot Gordon [00:08:03] Yeah, basically the crime is the same. It's not a mystery that Cleveland is. It's the poorest city in the United States with a population of over 250,000. There's a lot of drugs, there's a lot of crime due to the fact that people just don't have anything. There are haves and have nots. Basically, it's not all, it's not any different. It's not any different at all. In fact, if you go a little far, farther east, in the East Cleveland, that city has deteriorated extensively. It's a total mess.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:08:45] So Gordon, you like, what do you see as the mainstay of the economy here? I mean, if everybody is moving towards crime, I mean, what's keeping this place alive? What's keeping the city alive?
Elliot Gordon [00:08:59] Well, that's a really good question. I don't. That's really hard to answer. Obviously, down here in this neck of the wood, the restaurants in Little Italy kind of keep things afloat. UH, and the Clinic are major institutions. They employ a lot of people. A lot of people in the area work here. And the Clinic is downsized probably from about 12 to 13,000 when I first came to Cleveland in 1980 to about 7 or 8,000 now. And it's obviously just a lot less jobs. So generally speaking, the employment situation in Cleveland has not been getting better, it's gotten worse.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:09:51] So that leads to all the crime, which is there. I mean, if there were. Okay, if there were three things to be done to improve the situation of the city, to improve the economy, the neighborhoods and everything, what are the three things that you would do? I mean, if you were given a chance?
Elliot Gordon [00:10:09] Well, in this part of Cleveland, job opportunities are badly needed. When I got out of college in 1985, as an engineer, I could get a job anywhere. And in Cleveland or elsewhere. Today, there's nothing there. Our research and development in mechanical engineering is virtually non existent in Cleveland, it's very, very difficult to find good technical positions. And there's a big brain drain. Most of the people from Case go someplace else to work. So basically. And that covers professional people. That doesn't even cover the issue of your uneducated and basically unskilled blue-collar labor force. There, the situation is pretty bad. It's about the same as it's always been. There are very few jobs for them here in this area. So you either work at UH, or you work at the clinic, or you might work in one of the little stores here or supermarket. That's it. It's nothing else.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:11:26] So, okay, moving on from the economy. Like when you were in college, where did you essentially like which was the hangout place per se, while you were in college?
Elliot Gordon [00:11:38] When I was in college, I hung out quite a bit in Little Italy. I hung out in Cleveland Heights. Mainly in Cleveland Heights and mainly in the burbs.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:11:51] Okay, what about you said you hung out in Little Italy. Now what about Little Italy, which, like, fascinated you? Why did you start hanging out in Little Italy of all places?
Elliot Gordon [00:12:02] Well, Little Italy was the closest, the closest community that had restaurants to Case. There were a lot of pizza places. And, you know, everybody knows that students thrive on pizza. So, you know, mainly had to do with food. So we'd go down to the donut shop in the early hours of the morning to get donuts and coffee during the day, get pizza at Mama Santa's or one of the other restaurants. Otherwise there wasn't much of a reason to hang out in Little Italy. And in fact, it was known as being a pretty dangerous place. You could get jumped, you could get mugged for no reason at all.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:12:48] Little Italy being a dangerous place?
Elliot Gordon [00:12:52] Yeah, back in the '80s it was a very dangerous place. And Case boycotted it for a number of years because one of their students was critically beaten.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:13:03] And do you feel the situation today has improved because the neighborhood seems anything but run down here?
Elliot Gordon [00:13:11] Yeah, the neighborhood has definitely improved. The crime problem is not quite as bad as was before. There's still crime that happens as a result of people who live in Little Italy who just, you know, rob their neighbors. They don't seem to have learned anything over the years, but certainly it's a safer place. There's less of a risk of being physically abused or assaulted because you've got roving bands of 12 and 13 year olds with hammers and baseball bats like in the '80s.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:13:51] So, I mean, the situation in Little Italy has improved since the '80s over the last 20 years. Now, is there any particular reason as to why it's improved? Or is it because of Case or because of the clinics? Or is it just, like, because Little Italy has become a tourist attraction and everybody comes here?
Elliot Gordon [00:14:09] No, no, just- In fact, Little Italy had to change because of a negative response triggered by the beating of a Case student. Case instructed all of its students that they would have no insurance Case insurance whatsoever if they ventured into Little Italy. And so Case formally boycotted Little Italy. And especially if you had a pizza restaurant, probably overnight, you were looking at a loss of 25 to 40% of your business. So that really hit home very hard.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:14:44] So the economy of Little Italy was basically dependent on Case per se?
Elliot Gordon [00:14:49] Yeah, a good part of the economy. Little Italy was very dependent on Case. And the Case boycott resulted in Little Italy residents coming to grips with the fact that it had to be a safe place for people to want to come in to eat and spend time.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:15:12] So basically, based on what you just said, it's safe to assume that Case, the University Hospitals here, and the Cleveland Clinic are essentially like the soul of the city. They're like, keeping the city alive economically?
Elliot Gordon [00:15:28] Yeah, you know, basically, that triangle is the core of this part of Cleveland, definitely. The other issue, I think, in Cleveland is that the Fifth Precinct, which is down on Chester, between Chester and Euclid, has always been understaffed, and they cannot respond to all of the problems that occur in this neighborhood. They do not have the resources. They're stressed, they're overstretched, and that's that. It's never changed. It's worse today than it was then.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:16:11] Okay, you said you're from Connecticut now. Is there any particular thing that over the years, you've come to identify would here in Cleveland, I mean, something you can associate with, or is everything very alien to you here?
Elliot Gordon [00:16:34] Well, after I graduated from Case, the employment opportunities were pretty good, and I had no reason to go anywhere else. And so I made a good living here in Cleveland. I earned good money and led a pretty good life. Real estate values were good, bought a couple of houses. And so in that regard, you can lead a pretty good and stable life. The point of view of finding a residence, bringing up a family, and working. So that's pretty much what I attribute to the most positive thing in my experience here in Cleveland.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:17:26] So as long as there's a job, you have a job, and you have a basic income coming in, a decent income coming in. Cleveland's a good place to live. Though on the whole, you'd say?
Elliot Gordon [00:17:39] Well, yeah, I wouldn't stretch it that far. I think that a lot of- I've lived in a lot of other places in the country, and Cleveland doesn't have the level of restaurants, it doesn't have the level of entertainment that you would find in other cities, especially downtown. Now, I ended up spending a lot of time in Cleveland Heights, Shaker Heights, University Heights, for entertainment, for restaurants and so on. Not in Little Italy, but certainly beyond that, not a whole lot.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:18:19] So, I mean, besides entertainment, which is a necessity for, like, life, besides entertainment, what about something like, let's say, education? We've covered entertainment and we've covered work and economy, but how about, like, let's say education? What do you think is the level of education? Is it good, is it bad? It needs, like, God needs to, like, stick his hand and like, do something about it.
Elliot Gordon [00:18:41] Of Cleveland people?
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:18:44] That's right.
Elliot Gordon [00:18:45] Well, as I said before, there are the haves and the haves, have nots, and Cleveland itself is a poor city. I don't think people can afford a relatively good education. Number two, they're not even focused on it. They're focused more on survival, staying alive, staying out of the way of gangs and hostile people. There's a lot of violence, and people are not focused on higher education. So in the suburbs, there's a very high level of education, a lot of white collar people. And in Cleveland itself, in that particular area, in the particular area that we're talking about, there are a lot of have nots. They'll never have the opportunity to be educated or to enjoy a clean standard of living. There are people down here who do a very violent life, who drive around in Caddies and Lexuses and Mercedes. They didn't derive that for the college education.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:20:01] So the suburbs, life in the suburbs is better than life in the city. I mean, why do you feel this migration or this difference is there, that life in the suburbs is better than life, let's say, in downtown Cleveland or the east side of Cleveland?
Elliot Gordon [00:20:17] Well, unfortunately, I think it's a segregation issue. It's not a whole lot more than that. It's just that people with the ways and the means who come to the burbs are not people who come from the east side of Cleveland. These are professionals who moved here from other cities, people who were born and raised in those municipalities. And there's not a lot of movement between the two. So the people who are born and raised in Cleveland kind of live and die here or move to Detroit, Chicago, whatever. But the opportunity to just suddenly relocate from East 116th to Shaker Boulevard, Shaker is highly unlikely.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:21:14] So the migration happens from city center to city center rather than from city center to suburb?
Elliot Gordon [00:21:21] Yeah, I don't think the poor people have the kind of mobility that the richer people of the burbs do. So there's very little movement with them. And there's basic mobility freedom with the people who live in Cleveland Heights, Shaker Heights, most of the people, University Heights and so on.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:21:44] Okay, you mentioned earlier that Euclid Avenue is like millionaires row with all the mansions and everything. And today it's like decrepit and run down and everything. When do you think this change happened? When was it that it started going downhill?
Elliot Gordon [00:22:02] Well, you know, I guess the, although I wasn't here, my best assumption is that during the Depression and World War II, things began to change dramatically in Cleveland. A lot of people went out of business, a lot of things were stirred up. And I think after, especially after World War II, the demographics in Cleveland started to change dramatically. People just left, moved out of their mansions and they began to fall into disrepair and just the infrastructure to support the wealth that had been in Cleveland just fell apart. So basically I think that if you look at the '40s and the '50s, you see the beginnings of pretty massive deterioration in that part of the city.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:23:14] That is despite the fact that Cleveland was once compared with like Chicago. And even though this, like you said, it was a blue collar city all through and through. And after World War II, with all the industry and everything, I mean there's no depression, Depression as such. Consumerism was on the rise and everything. Goods are being manufactured on the house. I mean with blue collar city, did the factories just go out of business or was it to do with the taxes or the economy just nose dived?
Elliot Gordon [00:23:43] Well, when you look at the mansions on Euclid, obviously those are not blue collar people. I think that during the Depression And World War II, some of these people just took their companies and their business elsewhere. And certainly the heyday of Cleveland was not during the '40s and the '50s. It was during the turn of the century, the '20s and the early '30s when it was called the Forest City. It was beautiful, everything was nice. You did not see a whole lot of poverty. So I think that's the big issue. Cleveland was still an important manufacturing center well into the 70s.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:24:28] Okay, like you said in the '20s and the '30s, what is like the ethnic breakup of the city? Do you have any idea as to like, was it essentially Caucasian or was it like mixed race? And is it the same today compared to what it was then?
Elliot Gordon [00:24:47] Well, I think- I think that- I don't- I'm assuming that during the Depression and during World War II and after World War II, there was a lot of migration from the South of workers looking for factory jobs, and so it all increased.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:25:08] Okay, now, do you- have you spent any time in the [Cultural] Gardens and stuff in Cleveland, like, in this area? Like, there are a number of gardens here, like, especially along. Like, the parks along MLK and all these places. You've never spent any time in the Gardens?
Elliot Gordon [00:25:24] No, no. You know, Martin Luther King is still pretty much where you drive, and I've seen some pretty nasty things happen in that area. So, you know, I just kind of, like. I'm not, I don't feel secure there.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:25:39] What about places like the Wade Oval?
Elliot Gordon [00:25:43] Yeah, during the day, it's fine. At night, again, unless you're with a large group of people, not so healthy.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:25:53] But do you think it's, like, a lot of people whenever you've driven past that place or when you've been there, have there been a lot of people there or is it just, like, a handful of people?
Elliot Gordon [00:26:03] No, there are not a lot of people there. There's not a lot of crowds of people there, especially, which is one of the reasons why it's not particularly that safe.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:26:13] So would it. But do you think. Should that park be left there the way it is, or should they, like, build something over it? What do you think?
Elliot Gordon [00:26:26] That's a difficult question. It's in the museum district, and potentially more people would go there. I don't think it needs any more attraction to draw people. It's just that people don't go there because they don't necessarily one see the need to go there or want to put their own safety at risk.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:26:46] So it basically boils down to crime. At the end of the day, it's the crime. That's the fear of crime, that's why people don't go there?
Elliot Gordon [00:26:54] Yeah. Later in the evening. Yeah, when the museums are closed. But during the day, I think there are usually quite a few people down at the lagoon.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:27:07] So what, according to you, should be done to revitalize the gardens and the parks in the city? I mean, there are quite a few, because even with the Metro parks and everything, I mean, what can be done to get the people out into the parks, meet each other, develop the neighborhood?
Elliot Gordon [00:27:25] Well, you know, again, that's an issue of the viability and the health of the neighborhoods and whether there's a lot of rundown houses and crime and so on or not. If you're talking about the Euclid-Chester corridor, you know, down by the clinic. It's not good. You know, you got your big houses having chain link fences around them to keep people out. It's just still the sign of the time. So do people feel safe down there? No, of course not.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:28:00] Which brings me to my next topic. This construction company has developed housing along near East 79, near the marketplace at Church Square, between Chester and Euclid Avenue. Now, this is more upper middle class housing. And are you familiar with the place? It's called Beacon Place.
Elliot Gordon [00:28:22] Yeah, I drive by there all the time. So I see it, I look at it. As far as I'm concerned, the large houses on Chester and that housing development that you're referring to as Beacon seemed to me just to be appearance. It's not substantial. It's a start, but it's done along major corridors to make people feel like this is a nice community. You go a couple blocks off and you're just something entirely different. [inaudible] not good.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:28:59] So this is just a start. Is it a step in the right direction? Do you think that if they develop more communities like this or more neighborhoods like the way they develop in the Beacon Place, do you think it'll help revitalize the city of Cleveland, the eastern parts of Cleveland, let's say, between East 55th and East 105th?
Elliot Gordon [00:29:22] Yeah, I'm not so sure about that because I think a lot of Americans think that if you put a housing development in a shopping center nearby, it's nirvana. To me, it's not. Number one, people have to feel safe in their community. Number two, there has to be entertainment. There has to be things that they can do right in their community. And if you look closely, what's there to do? Yeah, they can go to the theater, there are a couple of museums in the area. But by and large, it's an area that's been torn down and under development. So you end up at the end of the day, having to give people major concessions and tax concessions and abatements to get them to move in there. So would I say it's a step in the right direction? No, not necessarily. Because housing developments and shopping centers are not the answer to a fulfilling life.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:30:20] Yeah, but if the population increases in the neighborhood, if people have more money to sell spend, if a higher income bracket segment moves into the neighborhood, do you think that will promote opening up of entertainment centers like more theaters or pubs and nightclubs and things like that in the neighborhood?
Elliot Gordon [00:30:42] Yeah, certainly. I mean, certainly if you get a foothold going and you get a lot of people in that area. Are you going to have a Little Italy? No, probably not. It's not as close geographically, as protected as Little Italy is. But, you know, I think very global issues in that community have to be addressed for any sort of a plan to take a foothold.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:31:09] You mentioned global issues. Global issues. Such as. Global issues. What kind of global issues?
Elliot Gordon [00:31:17] The basic issues that have to be addressed for a community to really grow in this area of Cleveland is that you're going to have to take care of the have nots. More jobs are going to have to be provided and just gentrification or moving in of higher income people is, you know, it could work. Sure, it could work. But where are the have nots going to go, where do they go? I think this is an endemic problem in Cleveland that they're more and more put into ghettos or closed communities where they're not seen. And until that issue is addressed, Cleveland will probably continue to be the poorest city in the nation with a population of over 250,000. The other thing is that it's important in planning a community to have basics from the beginning and not put them out or project them out to when you have enough people to pay for because you're in a Catch-22 situation and you need some basic planning needs to be done there. I don't think developments and shopping centers are enough to really draw people to a place.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:32:34] You also mentioned a racial divide within the people. I mean, is it particularly bad or is it particularly different from other cities in the United States? Is there like major segregation in Cleveland or is it just like, is it something that the people have just created in their own minds?
Elliot Gordon [00:32:56] No, it's not. It's not in their own minds. It certainly is real. But there are two types of segregation. One is simply black and white, and the other is have and have not. So it runs along economic lines, which is colorblind, and then it runs along racial lines which are really prejudice oriented. So those two together create very powerful influences that cause problems really developing the city of Cleveland. These are long standing, deeply rooted problems that have not been addressed because they exist today.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:33:37] So do you feel that if we were to address, let's say, the economic situation, improve the economic situation of the people in the city, the have nots per se, would that make life better along both lines? Would that reduce the amount of segregation there is between people? Like, will people still be like, will there be segregation still? Will segregation still be there, a kind of color, or would it, like go down?
Elliot Gordon [00:34:04] No, I think when people have an opportunity and they're not as frustrated with their lives and they're not as disenfranchised, there's more of an opportunity for them to meet on an equal basis with other people, whether they're rich or whether they're middle income or what. So yeah, it dramatically improves the opportunity.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:34:27] Side A coming to an end. Flipping to side B continues on second side. Mention how the economy of the city is affecting the life of the people out here, how the lack of entertainment is affecting the life of the people out here. What about things like politics? I mean, like, you know, the elections, like the state government or the city government. How has that affected the life of the people out here, let's say in the past 20-odd years?
Elliot Gordon [00:35:32] I think politics obviously plays a big part in the planning phase of the things. And again, I don't see that there's been a lot of planning done until the politicians address that issue and until they include the people in the community in the process of developing their own communities, which is another big shortfall. There's usually a lot of heavy handedness here going behind the back of the people in the community. And it's mainly run by politicians and developers, the two parties who seem to be making the money. So by and large, planning is needed and participation of all of the people in the community is needed. And again, you know, just housing and shopping malls are not going to make a community.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:36:23] When you say people need to develop their own communities, could you be a little more specific as to what exactly you mean by developing?
Elliot Gordon [00:36:30] Well, people need to be involved in the decision making process. If they're not, then they're disenfranchised and a lot of things happen which are disadvantageous for them.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:36:45] So the politicians and the developers are doing their own thing just because the citizens of the city are not involved as to what's going on in the city?
Elliot Gordon [00:36:54] Well, yeah, the two go hand in hand. Because if you want to run through a project which, you know, the residents of an area are not going to like, you really don't make it public, keep it as secretive as possible, and especially where they're not really benefiting from the quote unquote enhancements to the community, then that's a real problem.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:37:18] Okay, and what about something education? Like it's pretty obvious that the schools in, let's say downtown and East Cleveland cannot be compared with schools in the suburbs of, let's say Strongsville or Parma. I mean, where does the problem lie? Why is it that there's such a difference between the two education systems in the city of Cleveland and the cities around Cleveland?
Elliot Gordon [00:37:45] Well, obviously the priorities of state, local and federal government in Cleveland have not been the right priorities. Consequently, education and the infrastructure for education has suffered greatly. And by and large, until that's corrected, you're not going to get a mass influx of people to Cleveland. That's been substantiated by the fact that population in Cleveland has dropped every year since World War II or consistently. So maybe not every year, but again, you're not going to get middle income, upper income people into the city unless they can actually put their kids through the schools. So that's a big problem.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:38:30] So if the school situation improves, the level of education in the city improves, then automatically everything else improves.
Elliot Gordon [00:38:37] Yeah, absolutely.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:38:39] Okay, and my last question is, you said you've been on the road, you travel a lot and everything, you're from Connecticut, you're not from Cleveland, you moved here like 20, 25 years ago. What brings you back to Cleveland again and again?
Elliot Gordon [00:38:57] Friends and friends and family, basically. Friends and family. I've always, since for the past 10 years, I haven't really been career based in Cleveland. I've had to go elsewhere to get work and to do work. And so even though I've lived in Cleveland, I've consulted and been part of organizations that were based elsewhere, so had to consequently do a lot of traveling. But mainly the things that have returned me to Cleveland are friends and family.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:39:34] So Cleveland is home at the end of the day.
Elliot Gordon [00:39:37] Yeah, exactly.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:39:39] And if there was one thing that you said, if you were asked the one thing that stands out the most about Cleveland, which you like the most about Cleveland, what would it be?
Elliot Gordon [00:40:00] That's a good question. Basically, it's the friends and the acquaintances that I've made over the years here that's been the most important thing. Also ties to organizations like, or institutions like Case and the Clinic. I know a lot of people in those organizations and you know, that brings me back to Cleveland. But it's mainly on a personal basis. It's not an organizational or business level.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:40:40] And the one thing that you dislike completely about this city, which you wish if you could change right now, you know, snap as a thing that you change that right now.
Elliot Gordon [00:40:54] Well, again, I think it's the commercial and consumer idea that people are going to have a great life if they just have a shopping mall nearby, 2,500-square-foot house and two point three cars in the garage and whatever. I think that people need more than that. And I think this town is certainly evidence of that. Perhaps maybe most major cities in the country are also evidence, but more so Cleveland because of the long standing problems the city has had.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:41:30] But isn't that the American dream as to have a big house, couple of cars, shop?
Elliot Gordon [00:41:37] Yeah, it's the American dream, but without education, it's going to be very hard to get to. So it's more like a carrot on the end of a stick than a reality. For people who've got the means, it's a reality for people who don't have the means, it's not. So saying that the American dream only exists for half or less of the population United States would make the American dream insignificant and unsubstantial.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:42:07] And finally, do you have any particular, like favorite spot in the city where, I mean, if you just wanted to maybe just hang out or chill or just be with yourself, connect with your inner self like a park or a neighborhood or any particular place which is like favorite location in the city?
Elliot Gordon [00:42:29] Yeah, Little Italy and in particular Murray Hill in Little Italy. Those are really the places that I gravitate to because I've worked here, I've been based here for quite some time and I consequently have a lot of friends here. And also Cleveland Heights, I gravitate towards that area because I know a lot of people in that town.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:42:56] Thanks a lot for the time and your interview. Appreciate it.
Elliot Gordon [00:00:08] My name is Elliot Gordon and I live at 1962 East 124th Place, Cleveland, Ohio 44106.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:00:17] Have you always lived there? Were you born there or when did you move here to Cleveland?
Elliot Gordon [00:00:23] No, I moved here to Cleveland in 1980 to go to Case for engineering. I was about 30 years old at the time. So right now I'm 53. And basically between 1980 and 2005, I've spent most of my time here in Cleveland. Short stints in Finland and short stints in France.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:00:49] So basically you've been in Cleveland since 1980. Where were you before that?
Elliot Gordon [00:00:53] I was born and raised in Connecticut and was there until I was 20 years old. I went to school in Tennessee and lived in France during the 70s, and that pretty much brings us up to the 80s.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:01:12] So how was college life in the 80s in Cleveland, being at Case? What is it like? Is it the same as it is today, or was it like very different back in the '80s?
Elliot Gordon [00:01:23] I imagine it's pretty similar now because Cleveland is not known for its wildly social schools. Campus is set up very sort of a sterile social manner. The curriculum is pretty tough and, you know, there are fraternities, the usual college thing, but I imagine it's probably pretty much the same.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:01:54] Were there a lot of different ethnic groups with you when you were in college? Or essentially, was it like Caucasian? What is the essential breakup as such?
Elliot Gordon [00:02:05] There was a good mix of different ethnic groups. Well, with notable exceptions, Case was well represented, except for maybe a couple of ethnic groups. But yeah, I would say otherwise it was fairly well rounded.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:02:26] Okay, and so you lived on campus or you lived around Case. Where did you live?
Elliot Gordon [00:02:31] I lived mainly in Cleveland Heights and in Shaker Heights during the time that I was. And I spent a lot of time down in Little Italy and down in- Actually I lived on East 116th Street. So I know the Little Italy Euclid corridor area pretty well.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:02:59] So how was life back in the '80s along, say, Euclid Avenue in Little Italy? Was it like essentially like a segregated neighborhood or was it like a mixed ethnicity? What is it like?
Elliot Gordon [00:03:12] Well, the Euclid through Cleveland was pretty much a war zone. All of the mansions that had lined Euclid during the heyday of Cleveland were all falling into disrepair and or were being torn down. So the whole face of Euclid was changing. Down by the Clinic, the Clinic was buying up all that property and basically putting in, first of all, making empty lots and then looking at longer term development. So during the time that I was at Case, mainly a lot of property was falling into disrepair or was torn down. There wasn't a lot of building going on. It looks like a war zone.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:04:02] So today the situation has improved compared to what it was, or is it the same today?
Elliot Gordon [00:04:08] The situation has improved quite a bit, although there are still. Well, there are shopping centers, malls near the clinic, where really, you know, there was nothing. Euclid, down between the Clinic and downtown really hasn't changed that much, to tell you the truth. Except for where the mansions are missing. Commercially, it's pretty much the same. It's not flourishing.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:04:41] So when you used to be living here in Little Italy and along the Euclid area, did you shop in these areas or did you go out to, like, the suburbs to shop?
Elliot Gordon [00:04:52] No, there was nothing on Euclid at all. Basically. There were a couple of restaurant supply stores that I would go to, but other than that, there was nothing.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:05:03] So, like, what about stores like in the Halle building and like Sterling and May's and all these stores which used to be there in downtown? Did you ever go there to shop?
Elliot Gordon [00:05:15] Downtown, yeah, yeah, occasionally. Downtown Cleveland was and is still relatively dead. I mean, there wasn't, wasn't a lot of activities going on down there. If you wanted a really good shopping center with longer hours, it was best to go out into the suburbs.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:05:38] When you first came here to Cleveland, do you have, like, any particular memory of, like, this area, this neighborhood, Little Italy, Euclid, maybe, like, downtown? Any one particular memory which sticks out in your head?
Elliot Gordon [00:05:54] Not really, other than the fact that I didn't really particularly feel altogether that safe or comfortable in the neighborhood because it was deteriorating, and especially the race relationships were not good. So I remember distinctly going into a liquor store down on East 105th and Euclid, and it wasn't fun. I mean, I knew people were looking at me, and they weren't looking at me in a good way. Oh, there was also a billboard up on Euclid in East 105th that said, basically, you know, us Black folk know what we want. As far as we're concerned, you white folk can just stay out, keep your nose out of our business. It was not very pleasant.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:06:50] There was a lot of racial tension in the air at that point of time. Right?
Elliot Gordon [00:06:54] A lot of racial tension, yes.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:06:56] And is it the same. What do you think? Is it the same today or has it improved or gotten worse?
Elliot Gordon [00:07:02] I think, by and large, the clinic bought up that area. And so all those businesses, all of the concentration of, you know, all those people are now working for the Clinic. So I mean, yeah, it's little bit more civilized and looks a little bit more safe. I still, even though the police department is down there, I don't really particularly go walking down there. Go walking in the lagoon. It still holds its danger. And then if you go to the very far east side of Cleveland on Euclid, it hadn't really changed a whole lot. It's still not a good deal.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:07:51] So where do you think, I mean, Gordon, you. Where do you think the problem lies as to which- Where does this crime stem from? Is it one particular cause or are there numerous causes?
Elliot Gordon [00:08:03] Yeah, basically the crime is the same. It's not a mystery that Cleveland is. It's the poorest city in the United States with a population of over 250,000. There's a lot of drugs, there's a lot of crime due to the fact that people just don't have anything. There are haves and have nots. Basically, it's not all, it's not any different. It's not any different at all. In fact, if you go a little far, farther east, in the East Cleveland, that city has deteriorated extensively. It's a total mess.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:08:45] So Gordon, you like, what do you see as the mainstay of the economy here? I mean, if everybody is moving towards crime, I mean, what's keeping this place alive? What's keeping the city alive?
Elliot Gordon [00:08:59] Well, that's a really good question. I don't. That's really hard to answer. Obviously, down here in this neck of the wood, the restaurants in Little Italy kind of keep things afloat. UH, and the Clinic are major institutions. They employ a lot of people. A lot of people in the area work here. And the Clinic is downsized probably from about 12 to 13,000 when I first came to Cleveland in 1980 to about 7 or 8,000 now. And it's obviously just a lot less jobs. So generally speaking, the employment situation in Cleveland has not been getting better, it's gotten worse.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:09:51] So that leads to all the crime, which is there. I mean, if there were. Okay, if there were three things to be done to improve the situation of the city, to improve the economy, the neighborhoods and everything, what are the three things that you would do? I mean, if you were given a chance?
Elliot Gordon [00:10:09] Well, in this part of Cleveland, job opportunities are badly needed. When I got out of college in 1985, as an engineer, I could get a job anywhere. And in Cleveland or elsewhere. Today, there's nothing there. Our research and development in mechanical engineering is virtually non existent in Cleveland, it's very, very difficult to find good technical positions. And there's a big brain drain. Most of the people from Case go someplace else to work. So basically. And that covers professional people. That doesn't even cover the issue of your uneducated and basically unskilled blue-collar labor force. There, the situation is pretty bad. It's about the same as it's always been. There are very few jobs for them here in this area. So you either work at UH, or you work at the clinic, or you might work in one of the little stores here or supermarket. That's it. It's nothing else.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:11:26] So, okay, moving on from the economy. Like when you were in college, where did you essentially like which was the hangout place per se, while you were in college?
Elliot Gordon [00:11:38] When I was in college, I hung out quite a bit in Little Italy. I hung out in Cleveland Heights. Mainly in Cleveland Heights and mainly in the burbs.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:11:51] Okay, what about you said you hung out in Little Italy. Now what about Little Italy, which, like, fascinated you? Why did you start hanging out in Little Italy of all places?
Elliot Gordon [00:12:02] Well, Little Italy was the closest, the closest community that had restaurants to Case. There were a lot of pizza places. And, you know, everybody knows that students thrive on pizza. So, you know, mainly had to do with food. So we'd go down to the donut shop in the early hours of the morning to get donuts and coffee during the day, get pizza at Mama Santa's or one of the other restaurants. Otherwise there wasn't much of a reason to hang out in Little Italy. And in fact, it was known as being a pretty dangerous place. You could get jumped, you could get mugged for no reason at all.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:12:48] Little Italy being a dangerous place?
Elliot Gordon [00:12:52] Yeah, back in the '80s it was a very dangerous place. And Case boycotted it for a number of years because one of their students was critically beaten.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:13:03] And do you feel the situation today has improved because the neighborhood seems anything but run down here?
Elliot Gordon [00:13:11] Yeah, the neighborhood has definitely improved. The crime problem is not quite as bad as was before. There's still crime that happens as a result of people who live in Little Italy who just, you know, rob their neighbors. They don't seem to have learned anything over the years, but certainly it's a safer place. There's less of a risk of being physically abused or assaulted because you've got roving bands of 12 and 13 year olds with hammers and baseball bats like in the '80s.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:13:51] So, I mean, the situation in Little Italy has improved since the '80s over the last 20 years. Now, is there any particular reason as to why it's improved? Or is it because of Case or because of the clinics? Or is it just, like, because Little Italy has become a tourist attraction and everybody comes here?
Elliot Gordon [00:14:09] No, no, just- In fact, Little Italy had to change because of a negative response triggered by the beating of a Case student. Case instructed all of its students that they would have no insurance Case insurance whatsoever if they ventured into Little Italy. And so Case formally boycotted Little Italy. And especially if you had a pizza restaurant, probably overnight, you were looking at a loss of 25 to 40% of your business. So that really hit home very hard.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:14:44] So the economy of Little Italy was basically dependent on Case per se?
Elliot Gordon [00:14:49] Yeah, a good part of the economy. Little Italy was very dependent on Case. And the Case boycott resulted in Little Italy residents coming to grips with the fact that it had to be a safe place for people to want to come in to eat and spend time.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:15:12] So basically, based on what you just said, it's safe to assume that Case, the University Hospitals here, and the Cleveland Clinic are essentially like the soul of the city. They're like, keeping the city alive economically?
Elliot Gordon [00:15:28] Yeah, you know, basically, that triangle is the core of this part of Cleveland, definitely. The other issue, I think, in Cleveland is that the Fifth Precinct, which is down on Chester, between Chester and Euclid, has always been understaffed, and they cannot respond to all of the problems that occur in this neighborhood. They do not have the resources. They're stressed, they're overstretched, and that's that. It's never changed. It's worse today than it was then.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:16:11] Okay, you said you're from Connecticut now. Is there any particular thing that over the years, you've come to identify would here in Cleveland, I mean, something you can associate with, or is everything very alien to you here?
Elliot Gordon [00:16:34] Well, after I graduated from Case, the employment opportunities were pretty good, and I had no reason to go anywhere else. And so I made a good living here in Cleveland. I earned good money and led a pretty good life. Real estate values were good, bought a couple of houses. And so in that regard, you can lead a pretty good and stable life. The point of view of finding a residence, bringing up a family, and working. So that's pretty much what I attribute to the most positive thing in my experience here in Cleveland.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:17:26] So as long as there's a job, you have a job, and you have a basic income coming in, a decent income coming in. Cleveland's a good place to live. Though on the whole, you'd say?
Elliot Gordon [00:17:39] Well, yeah, I wouldn't stretch it that far. I think that a lot of- I've lived in a lot of other places in the country, and Cleveland doesn't have the level of restaurants, it doesn't have the level of entertainment that you would find in other cities, especially downtown. Now, I ended up spending a lot of time in Cleveland Heights, Shaker Heights, University Heights, for entertainment, for restaurants and so on. Not in Little Italy, but certainly beyond that, not a whole lot.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:18:19] So, I mean, besides entertainment, which is a necessity for, like, life, besides entertainment, what about something like, let's say, education? We've covered entertainment and we've covered work and economy, but how about, like, let's say education? What do you think is the level of education? Is it good, is it bad? It needs, like, God needs to, like, stick his hand and like, do something about it.
Elliot Gordon [00:18:41] Of Cleveland people?
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:18:44] That's right.
Elliot Gordon [00:18:45] Well, as I said before, there are the haves and the haves, have nots, and Cleveland itself is a poor city. I don't think people can afford a relatively good education. Number two, they're not even focused on it. They're focused more on survival, staying alive, staying out of the way of gangs and hostile people. There's a lot of violence, and people are not focused on higher education. So in the suburbs, there's a very high level of education, a lot of white collar people. And in Cleveland itself, in that particular area, in the particular area that we're talking about, there are a lot of have nots. They'll never have the opportunity to be educated or to enjoy a clean standard of living. There are people down here who do a very violent life, who drive around in Caddies and Lexuses and Mercedes. They didn't derive that for the college education.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:20:01] So the suburbs, life in the suburbs is better than life in the city. I mean, why do you feel this migration or this difference is there, that life in the suburbs is better than life, let's say, in downtown Cleveland or the east side of Cleveland?
Elliot Gordon [00:20:17] Well, unfortunately, I think it's a segregation issue. It's not a whole lot more than that. It's just that people with the ways and the means who come to the burbs are not people who come from the east side of Cleveland. These are professionals who moved here from other cities, people who were born and raised in those municipalities. And there's not a lot of movement between the two. So the people who are born and raised in Cleveland kind of live and die here or move to Detroit, Chicago, whatever. But the opportunity to just suddenly relocate from East 116th to Shaker Boulevard, Shaker is highly unlikely.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:21:14] So the migration happens from city center to city center rather than from city center to suburb?
Elliot Gordon [00:21:21] Yeah, I don't think the poor people have the kind of mobility that the richer people of the burbs do. So there's very little movement with them. And there's basic mobility freedom with the people who live in Cleveland Heights, Shaker Heights, most of the people, University Heights and so on.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:21:44] Okay, you mentioned earlier that Euclid Avenue is like millionaires row with all the mansions and everything. And today it's like decrepit and run down and everything. When do you think this change happened? When was it that it started going downhill?
Elliot Gordon [00:22:02] Well, you know, I guess the, although I wasn't here, my best assumption is that during the Depression and World War II, things began to change dramatically in Cleveland. A lot of people went out of business, a lot of things were stirred up. And I think after, especially after World War II, the demographics in Cleveland started to change dramatically. People just left, moved out of their mansions and they began to fall into disrepair and just the infrastructure to support the wealth that had been in Cleveland just fell apart. So basically I think that if you look at the '40s and the '50s, you see the beginnings of pretty massive deterioration in that part of the city.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:23:14] That is despite the fact that Cleveland was once compared with like Chicago. And even though this, like you said, it was a blue collar city all through and through. And after World War II, with all the industry and everything, I mean there's no depression, Depression as such. Consumerism was on the rise and everything. Goods are being manufactured on the house. I mean with blue collar city, did the factories just go out of business or was it to do with the taxes or the economy just nose dived?
Elliot Gordon [00:23:43] Well, when you look at the mansions on Euclid, obviously those are not blue collar people. I think that during the Depression And World War II, some of these people just took their companies and their business elsewhere. And certainly the heyday of Cleveland was not during the '40s and the '50s. It was during the turn of the century, the '20s and the early '30s when it was called the Forest City. It was beautiful, everything was nice. You did not see a whole lot of poverty. So I think that's the big issue. Cleveland was still an important manufacturing center well into the 70s.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:24:28] Okay, like you said in the '20s and the '30s, what is like the ethnic breakup of the city? Do you have any idea as to like, was it essentially Caucasian or was it like mixed race? And is it the same today compared to what it was then?
Elliot Gordon [00:24:47] Well, I think- I think that- I don't- I'm assuming that during the Depression and during World War II and after World War II, there was a lot of migration from the South of workers looking for factory jobs, and so it all increased.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:25:08] Okay, now, do you- have you spent any time in the [Cultural] Gardens and stuff in Cleveland, like, in this area? Like, there are a number of gardens here, like, especially along. Like, the parks along MLK and all these places. You've never spent any time in the Gardens?
Elliot Gordon [00:25:24] No, no. You know, Martin Luther King is still pretty much where you drive, and I've seen some pretty nasty things happen in that area. So, you know, I just kind of, like. I'm not, I don't feel secure there.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:25:39] What about places like the Wade Oval?
Elliot Gordon [00:25:43] Yeah, during the day, it's fine. At night, again, unless you're with a large group of people, not so healthy.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:25:53] But do you think it's, like, a lot of people whenever you've driven past that place or when you've been there, have there been a lot of people there or is it just, like, a handful of people?
Elliot Gordon [00:26:03] No, there are not a lot of people there. There's not a lot of crowds of people there, especially, which is one of the reasons why it's not particularly that safe.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:26:13] So would it. But do you think. Should that park be left there the way it is, or should they, like, build something over it? What do you think?
Elliot Gordon [00:26:26] That's a difficult question. It's in the museum district, and potentially more people would go there. I don't think it needs any more attraction to draw people. It's just that people don't go there because they don't necessarily one see the need to go there or want to put their own safety at risk.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:26:46] So it basically boils down to crime. At the end of the day, it's the crime. That's the fear of crime, that's why people don't go there?
Elliot Gordon [00:26:54] Yeah. Later in the evening. Yeah, when the museums are closed. But during the day, I think there are usually quite a few people down at the lagoon.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:27:07] So what, according to you, should be done to revitalize the gardens and the parks in the city? I mean, there are quite a few, because even with the Metro parks and everything, I mean, what can be done to get the people out into the parks, meet each other, develop the neighborhood?
Elliot Gordon [00:27:25] Well, you know, again, that's an issue of the viability and the health of the neighborhoods and whether there's a lot of rundown houses and crime and so on or not. If you're talking about the Euclid-Chester corridor, you know, down by the clinic. It's not good. You know, you got your big houses having chain link fences around them to keep people out. It's just still the sign of the time. So do people feel safe down there? No, of course not.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:28:00] Which brings me to my next topic. This construction company has developed housing along near East 79, near the marketplace at Church Square, between Chester and Euclid Avenue. Now, this is more upper middle class housing. And are you familiar with the place? It's called Beacon Place.
Elliot Gordon [00:28:22] Yeah, I drive by there all the time. So I see it, I look at it. As far as I'm concerned, the large houses on Chester and that housing development that you're referring to as Beacon seemed to me just to be appearance. It's not substantial. It's a start, but it's done along major corridors to make people feel like this is a nice community. You go a couple blocks off and you're just something entirely different. [inaudible] not good.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:28:59] So this is just a start. Is it a step in the right direction? Do you think that if they develop more communities like this or more neighborhoods like the way they develop in the Beacon Place, do you think it'll help revitalize the city of Cleveland, the eastern parts of Cleveland, let's say, between East 55th and East 105th?
Elliot Gordon [00:29:22] Yeah, I'm not so sure about that because I think a lot of Americans think that if you put a housing development in a shopping center nearby, it's nirvana. To me, it's not. Number one, people have to feel safe in their community. Number two, there has to be entertainment. There has to be things that they can do right in their community. And if you look closely, what's there to do? Yeah, they can go to the theater, there are a couple of museums in the area. But by and large, it's an area that's been torn down and under development. So you end up at the end of the day, having to give people major concessions and tax concessions and abatements to get them to move in there. So would I say it's a step in the right direction? No, not necessarily. Because housing developments and shopping centers are not the answer to a fulfilling life.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:30:20] Yeah, but if the population increases in the neighborhood, if people have more money to sell spend, if a higher income bracket segment moves into the neighborhood, do you think that will promote opening up of entertainment centers like more theaters or pubs and nightclubs and things like that in the neighborhood?
Elliot Gordon [00:30:42] Yeah, certainly. I mean, certainly if you get a foothold going and you get a lot of people in that area. Are you going to have a Little Italy? No, probably not. It's not as close geographically, as protected as Little Italy is. But, you know, I think very global issues in that community have to be addressed for any sort of a plan to take a foothold.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:31:09] You mentioned global issues. Global issues. Such as. Global issues. What kind of global issues?
Elliot Gordon [00:31:17] The basic issues that have to be addressed for a community to really grow in this area of Cleveland is that you're going to have to take care of the have nots. More jobs are going to have to be provided and just gentrification or moving in of higher income people is, you know, it could work. Sure, it could work. But where are the have nots going to go, where do they go? I think this is an endemic problem in Cleveland that they're more and more put into ghettos or closed communities where they're not seen. And until that issue is addressed, Cleveland will probably continue to be the poorest city in the nation with a population of over 250,000. The other thing is that it's important in planning a community to have basics from the beginning and not put them out or project them out to when you have enough people to pay for because you're in a Catch-22 situation and you need some basic planning needs to be done there. I don't think developments and shopping centers are enough to really draw people to a place.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:32:34] You also mentioned a racial divide within the people. I mean, is it particularly bad or is it particularly different from other cities in the United States? Is there like major segregation in Cleveland or is it just like, is it something that the people have just created in their own minds?
Elliot Gordon [00:32:56] No, it's not. It's not in their own minds. It certainly is real. But there are two types of segregation. One is simply black and white, and the other is have and have not. So it runs along economic lines, which is colorblind, and then it runs along racial lines which are really prejudice oriented. So those two together create very powerful influences that cause problems really developing the city of Cleveland. These are long standing, deeply rooted problems that have not been addressed because they exist today.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:33:37] So do you feel that if we were to address, let's say, the economic situation, improve the economic situation of the people in the city, the have nots per se, would that make life better along both lines? Would that reduce the amount of segregation there is between people? Like, will people still be like, will there be segregation still? Will segregation still be there, a kind of color, or would it, like go down?
Elliot Gordon [00:34:04] No, I think when people have an opportunity and they're not as frustrated with their lives and they're not as disenfranchised, there's more of an opportunity for them to meet on an equal basis with other people, whether they're rich or whether they're middle income or what. So yeah, it dramatically improves the opportunity.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:34:27] Side A coming to an end. Flipping to side B continues on second side. Mention how the economy of the city is affecting the life of the people out here, how the lack of entertainment is affecting the life of the people out here. What about things like politics? I mean, like, you know, the elections, like the state government or the city government. How has that affected the life of the people out here, let's say in the past 20-odd years?
Elliot Gordon [00:35:32] I think politics obviously plays a big part in the planning phase of the things. And again, I don't see that there's been a lot of planning done until the politicians address that issue and until they include the people in the community in the process of developing their own communities, which is another big shortfall. There's usually a lot of heavy handedness here going behind the back of the people in the community. And it's mainly run by politicians and developers, the two parties who seem to be making the money. So by and large, planning is needed and participation of all of the people in the community is needed. And again, you know, just housing and shopping malls are not going to make a community.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:36:23] When you say people need to develop their own communities, could you be a little more specific as to what exactly you mean by developing?
Elliot Gordon [00:36:30] Well, people need to be involved in the decision making process. If they're not, then they're disenfranchised and a lot of things happen which are disadvantageous for them.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:36:45] So the politicians and the developers are doing their own thing just because the citizens of the city are not involved as to what's going on in the city?
Elliot Gordon [00:36:54] Well, yeah, the two go hand in hand. Because if you want to run through a project which, you know, the residents of an area are not going to like, you really don't make it public, keep it as secretive as possible, and especially where they're not really benefiting from the quote unquote enhancements to the community, then that's a real problem.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:37:18] Okay, and what about something education? Like it's pretty obvious that the schools in, let's say downtown and East Cleveland cannot be compared with schools in the suburbs of, let's say Strongsville or Parma. I mean, where does the problem lie? Why is it that there's such a difference between the two education systems in the city of Cleveland and the cities around Cleveland?
Elliot Gordon [00:37:45] Well, obviously the priorities of state, local and federal government in Cleveland have not been the right priorities. Consequently, education and the infrastructure for education has suffered greatly. And by and large, until that's corrected, you're not going to get a mass influx of people to Cleveland. That's been substantiated by the fact that population in Cleveland has dropped every year since World War II or consistently. So maybe not every year, but again, you're not going to get middle income, upper income people into the city unless they can actually put their kids through the schools. So that's a big problem.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:38:30] So if the school situation improves, the level of education in the city improves, then automatically everything else improves.
Elliot Gordon [00:38:37] Yeah, absolutely.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:38:39] Okay, and my last question is, you said you've been on the road, you travel a lot and everything, you're from Connecticut, you're not from Cleveland, you moved here like 20, 25 years ago. What brings you back to Cleveland again and again?
Elliot Gordon [00:38:57] Friends and friends and family, basically. Friends and family. I've always, since for the past 10 years, I haven't really been career based in Cleveland. I've had to go elsewhere to get work and to do work. And so even though I've lived in Cleveland, I've consulted and been part of organizations that were based elsewhere, so had to consequently do a lot of traveling. But mainly the things that have returned me to Cleveland are friends and family.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:39:34] So Cleveland is home at the end of the day.
Elliot Gordon [00:39:37] Yeah, exactly.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:39:39] And if there was one thing that you said, if you were asked the one thing that stands out the most about Cleveland, which you like the most about Cleveland, what would it be?
Elliot Gordon [00:40:00] That's a good question. Basically, it's the friends and the acquaintances that I've made over the years here that's been the most important thing. Also ties to organizations like, or institutions like Case and the Clinic. I know a lot of people in those organizations and you know, that brings me back to Cleveland. But it's mainly on a personal basis. It's not an organizational or business level.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:40:40] And the one thing that you dislike completely about this city, which you wish if you could change right now, you know, snap as a thing that you change that right now.
Elliot Gordon [00:40:54] Well, again, I think it's the commercial and consumer idea that people are going to have a great life if they just have a shopping mall nearby, 2,500-square-foot house and two point three cars in the garage and whatever. I think that people need more than that. And I think this town is certainly evidence of that. Perhaps maybe most major cities in the country are also evidence, but more so Cleveland because of the long standing problems the city has had.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:41:30] But isn't that the American dream as to have a big house, couple of cars, shop?
Elliot Gordon [00:41:37] Yeah, it's the American dream, but without education, it's going to be very hard to get to. So it's more like a carrot on the end of a stick than a reality. For people who've got the means, it's a reality for people who don't have the means, it's not. So saying that the American dream only exists for half or less of the population United States would make the American dream insignificant and unsubstantial.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:42:07] And finally, do you have any particular, like favorite spot in the city where, I mean, if you just wanted to maybe just hang out or chill or just be with yourself, connect with your inner self like a park or a neighborhood or any particular place which is like favorite location in the city?
Elliot Gordon [00:42:29] Yeah, Little Italy and in particular Murray Hill in Little Italy. Those are really the places that I gravitate to because I've worked here, I've been based here for quite some time and I consequently have a lot of friends here. And also Cleveland Heights, I gravitate towards that area because I know a lot of people in that town.
Dhruv Dhindsa [00:42:56] Thanks a lot for the time and your interview. Appreciate it.
History 304: Urban History
These course-based oral histories arose from the CSU Department of History collaboration with Greater Cleveland Regional Transit Authority, Cleveland Public Art, and WCPN/WVIZ (ideastream). Interviews in this collection were conducted by students in U.S. Urban History (HIS 304) at Cleveland State University Department of History, supervised by professors Mark Tebeau and Mark Souther. Originally intended to inform the creation of public art along the RTA’s Healthline BRT route, these interviews…