Duane Hatton interview, 04 May 2005

Duane Hatton of Hatton's Deli Restaurant describes the history and operations of the family business and changes in the midtown area along Euclid Avenue.

Participants: Hatton, Duane (interviewee) / Kakos, Max (interviewer) / Souther, Mark (facilitator)
Collection: History 304: Urban History
Institutional Repository: Cleveland Regional Oral History Collection

Interview Transcript

Transcripts may contain errors.

Duane Hatton [00:00:03] I'm Duane Hatton. We're at Hatton's deli restaurant, 3608 Euclid Avenue on the corner of East 36th and Euclid in Cleveland, Ohio.

Max Kakos [00:00:15] When did Hatton's Deli, when was it established and how did you come about doing this type of-

Duane Hatton [00:00:23] Well, this is a family business. My dad opened as a bar, Hatton's Arena Bar, back in 1952 and bought the building and made it a restaurant with a lounge in 1961. And I completed college in 1969. And after trying a few things, I went into business with my dad and I've been here ever since. 1970 I started here full time.

Max Kakos [00:00:56] [inaudible] Duane Hatton [00:01:01] Hatton's Arena Bar. There was actually two separate businesses at that time. There was a restaurant that was owned by someone else was called Temple Court Restaurant and the bar owned by my dad. When he bought the building, he made one business and combined the two and it became Hatton's Deli at that time.

Max Kakos [00:01:24] Second question. How has Euclid Avenue changed since you've been here?

Duane Hatton [00:01:30] Oh, tremendously. It started out with the Prospect Association, which was original group that worked in the area. And after that Midtown Corridor came in. And when Midtown Corridor came in, it was a big impact at that point. At that point we had Bearings across the street, which is now Applied Industrial Technology on the other corner. And we also had Premier up the street. And with the two heads of those two businesses and working closely with the mayor and the city at that time, they improved the area from what it was, which was in a very bad downturn back in the '70s. And since then we've been seeing growth. Bearings moved out from the buildings they had on Euclid, which was three separate buildings, and they built with the Port Authority. The building across the street from us on the northwest corner now we've got Myers College. And we've just seen some growth and a cleaned-up area.

Max Kakos [00:02:43] [inaudible] Duane Hatton [00:02:50] Well, it was difficult for people to come with families and now we've got people coming from different parts. Most of our business is comprised of people in the area with lunch business, but we also are in entertainment magazines and we get people in from other areas which at one time they didn't want to venture down this area. So it's the way people look at downtown in the area. Yeah.

Max Kakos [00:03:16] [inaudible] Duane Hatton [00:03:24] Without a doubt. We've always had the most diverse group. People used to come in just to see the different types of people. And by diverse groups, you're talking about working people, secretaries, people that are in blue-collar jobs and some people that aren't working in the area. And just people that come down. Maybe a lot of times we get a lot of people that are at Cleveland Clinic or they're from out of town because they've got patients, family members that are Cleveland Clinic. So between men and women, black and white and Asian, Cleveland's becoming quite an Asian area too. We get very diverse.

Max Kakos [00:04:14] [inaudible] Duane Hatton [00:04:18] Oh, yeah, yeah. They're across the street. They're on both sides of the street. Yeah, they've got the building over there and they have a building on this side directly across from them. And yeah, of course, I was here before that was a thought. When the Cleveland Arena was here. So I was here when that was built. And [Joseph M.] Bruening, which was head of Bearings, was a big contributor to that. [crosstalk] That's it.

Max Kakos [00:04:50] [inaudible] Duane Hatton [00:05:00] Well, when the Cleveland Arena left, it was a big- That was a big downer for this area. We used to have good nighttime activity because we had- Well, we had the Cleveland Barons and we had the wrestling and we had Ice Capades and everything. So it brought a lot of people down in the area. And when that was moved out to Richfield, to the Coliseum, and it was vacant, that was when things really were probably the lowest point at that point. That was in the early '70s.

Max Kakos [00:05:36] [inaudible] Duane Hatton [00:05:48] I never heard about that. Once they moved out, that was about the end of it. I know the owner of the building donated it to Bowen Green, and at that point they didn't do anything with it. And I don't know, of course, the buildings around it had to be sold so that they can make room for the- for the Red Cross.

Max Kakos [00:06:14] [inaudible] Duane Hatton [00:06:21] It affected us tremendously. Very good business before because we got a lot of business from that. And of course, when I started here with my dad, we were doing a terrific business. And when that happened, it was- It was a struggle for a bit.

Max Kakos [00:06:38] [inaudible] Duane Hatton [00:06:40] Oh, yeah, me too. [laughs] Max Kakos [00:06:44] Have you had any unusual or interesting stories? Things happen in the deli itself.

Duane Hatton [00:06:55] I'm sure we have over the years. I don't know what specifically you're looking for. I'd have to.

Max Kakos [00:07:01] [inaudible] Duane Hatton [00:07:13] Well, we used to be open at one time until- Well, back when business was booming, the deli used to be open at one time until 12:30 in the morning. I mean, 2:30 in the morning, then 12:30. And we slowly reduce the times. And of course, when you open at night, you've got a lot of crazy things that happen because you've got people from the bars coming in. Some of the stories you don't want for the project. But there was an interesting story that I had, that was me, that one time we were having a fellow came in he was causing a problem. And the waitress told me, you've got to get rid of that guy with the stocking cap on. He's causing a problem. And I went over and I told this guy with a stocking cap and made him leave. And he said, what'd I do? I said, just leave. I was pretty much in charge then. I told you to leave. You left. And he got out the door, and the waitress came back, says, you got to get that guy out of here. And I said, I did. He says, no, that guy with a stocking cap over there. I had thrown the wrong guy out. So I had to immediately go back and grab the guy that was walking down the street and make him come back and told him I threw the wrong guy in and have him sit down and eat. And he did. I brought him back and threw the other guy out. But if that's the type of story you're looking for, I can give you a bunch of those. Yeah.

Max Kakos [00:08:37] When you brought that guy back in, did you offer him a free meal?

Duane Hatton [00:08:38] As a matter of fact, I did. I bought his meal, and we were friends for a long time after that. His name was Mel, and he just was totally puzzled why he was being thrown out. But, yeah.

Max Kakos [00:08:50] [inaudible] Duane Hatton [00:08:55] Oh. [crosstalk] well, yeah, it's all got to do with me. You want stuff about me? In the restaurant business, sometimes you're shorthanded. Food doesn't come out as quickly as they'd like, and the owner has to go back and cook. And we felt we were busy at that time. Daria was doing pretty good at night, and I had a guy that was waiting for his breakfast, and they told me, he's waited a long time. He's getting anxious. He has to leave. I said, I'll go back and make it. And I ran back there and started making it. Just as I put it up, they told me, forget it. He left. I said, not after he made it, he didn't. So I ran out the door and I says, hey, I made your breakfast and it's ready. I said, you're coming back in. I brought him back in and he ate his breakfast. So other than that things, we've had a variety of people. No real trouble. The area hasn't really been. We've never had entertainment in here, so we've never had any trouble. It's not been a trouble spot. Of course, through the times, we went through different types of people. I don't know specifically what you're looking for, but I got an idea things have changed as I said back in the '70s with the- At that time, I think what you're looking for is when the area was pretty much in a prostitution area. And we did have that quite a bit here. You didn't know that? But there was a lot of that activity there, which with Midtown coming in, that got cleaned up. And that was one of the reasons we didn't have a- So you see, I've seen this area through every type of time there was. But with Midtown coming in- And at that time they actually, it was to the point where they brought the second district and the- Well, I think it was the second district and some other force down here to enforce the laws when they became emphatic that their area was going to be cleaned up and it was going to move forward. And from that time on, it did move forward.

Max Kakos [00:11:19] [inaudible] Duane Hatton [00:11:24] It was street prostitution. So it was on- Prospect was the main area. And so that's why a lot of people didn't come down this way unless they were looking for that. [crosstalk] So that's why I was here. I've worked pretty much all the time, as there are days, nights, and I still am now I'm an old guy and getting tired.

Max Kakos [00:11:59] Has it remained the same all the time or have you made any changes?

Duane Hatton [00:12:02] No, that's a real interesting question. When my dad started this business, this was daytime. We didn't. The prostitute situation was at night. Daytime was pretty good. We had the businesses around here and majority of white Jewish clientele. At that time we were so busy. We've added on to our building twice. My dad did. This is all an addition. Originally. It actually stopped before this entrance way here. As I said, the two were separate businesses. And then where this bearing wall is here, that's all a new addition on there because they used to be lined in the hallway at that time, taking numbers. That's how busy we were. And my dad started this as a Jewish delicatessen. He had all the Jewish specialties. He had the locks, the whole lox in the deli case and sliced it up to order. And we had the herring and the whitefish and the borscht. And we had the Jewish countermen here that were professional countermen. You don't see them too often anymore. If you go to Corking Lenny's, you do. They used to slice the corned beef, slice the bread by hand. And it was a much larger menu we had now. And it had, as I said, all the Jewish specialties on it. And my dad, for an interesting story, he was a very astute businessman. He led everyone to believe he was Jewish so that he didn't- We're Catholic. So he would greet people in Hebrew and he was Jewish. As far as- In fact, we're Catholic, Lebanese. One interesting story has nothing to do with the restaurant is when I was younger and before I was married, I met this girl and went out with her and she knew my dad owned Hatton's Deli. And when she found out I wasn't Jewish and she's Jewish and I'm Catholic, she says, it can't be. Your dad's Jewish. He owns Hatton's Deli. I says, no, he's not Jewish. And she says, oh, my God, my mother will kill me. So I never got to see her again. But he ran a circle as a Jewish deli and it slowly evolved. We reduced the menu and then he actually went- When it changed some, he hired a Hungarian chef and he ran it as deli restaurant with a lot of Hungarian specialties, which we no longer have a Hungarian chef, but we still run daily specials. And we still have chicken paprikash and different things on the menu.

Max Kakos [00:14:56] [inaudible] Duane Hatton [00:15:05] Well, corned beef is the most popular by far. We sell- Yeah. I mean, see, we just recently remodeled and the bar and the restaurant have been separated with just a doorway going to each side. We took those walls out. It used to be you walked into a hallway and you walked into the deli or walked into the bar side, which was a dining room. Now you're walking into the restaurant. That's how we've changed it. And it's all one. But we changed the other side. That used to be our deli side, which had the seating. Now that's our catering. Takeout and catering. And all the seating is over here. We do quite a bit of catering in deli trays, hot food, catering, whatever. And as far as the menu. The menu changing. Is that where we were?

Max Kakos [00:16:00] Yeah, I was asking.

Duane Hatton [00:16:02] Oh, popular items. So corned beef. And we sell a ton of chicken wings. Not the whole wings, but the wingettes. We go through a lot of those both in catering and in house. And sandwiches. Most of the sandwiches. And we have. Everything we do is homemade. We have our homemade soups, we have homemade meatloaf, and we have a good roast beef. So all that sells. Yeah.

Max Kakos [00:16:31] [inaudible] Duane Hatton [00:16:35] Which sign?

Max Kakos [00:16:37] [inaudible] Duane Hatton [00:16:39] That's- Yeah, that's in dire need of repair, as you can see. But that's been with the building since my dad. I think after the '60s, when my dad took over the restaurant and made it Hatton's Deli, he put up the flashing signs and that sign's worth fixing one day, but it's- It's been there forever. I'd say my dad, as I said in '61, took over the deli, and in the '60s, he had that sign erected.

Max Kakos [00:17:06] [inaudible] Duane Hatton [00:17:08] Yeah.

Max Kakos [00:17:09] [inaudible] Duane Hatton [00:17:11] And believe it or not, people coming up the street, they do see that sign, and it does bring people in.

Max Kakos [00:17:16] [Inaudible] Duane Hatton [00:17:23] That's how you determine to come here. Is that- Is that how you determined to call me?

Max Kakos [00:17:30] Yeah.

Duane Hatton [00:17:31] The sign does- Even without it being lit, it attracts people's attention.

Max Kakos [00:17:35] [inaudible] Duane Hatton [00:17:45] No, no. We did a- In fact, the city of Cleveland has money available to do frontage work, and we did at one time. That front has changed. My dad had it remodeled once. And the only. Anytime you're going to do anything with frontage work, you have to see the city of Cleveland. You have to get their approval. And some of the things that. If we're going to change something, I might not want to do it the way they want it, because what they would be looking for, I've already checked into that. Have they prevented me? Yeah, they haven't prevented me. I just changed my mind about doing it because they would want the front to be brought back to the way it was originally, because that's what they're doing in the area, bringing everything back to original. So they would want big storefront windows. This is the way it originally was. And since it's not something that I feel is appropriate yet, I would stick with the type of window treatment I have. As far as changing the brickwork or paint or anything like that, you don't need approval. Just if you're doing major restoration.

Max Kakos [00:19:01] [inaudible] Duane Hatton [00:19:05] Yeah. At that time, you just got a building permit and just put additions on. That's not a problem. The only thing that's only since they've started with Midtown and the restoration, they want everything. You have to go through approval from Midtown to do any major changes in the front. That's not- You know, if I were to decide I wanted different windows, different size windows or something like that, as far as changing my sign or anything, it's not a problem because it's already up there.

Max Kakos [00:19:41] [inaudible] Duane Hatton [00:19:45] Yeah, that I- That I don't know. And I'd like to know. Yeah, I mean, I've had people come in here and offer to buy it, but I've never- I've never found out what it was, and it's just different. Yeah.

Max Kakos [00:20:01] [inaudible]
Duane Hatton [00:20:06] Yeah, that was there from the before my dad owned the building.

Max Kakos [00:20:09] [inaudible] Duane Hatton [00:20:11] Well, my dad bought the building in '61, and this building's about 75 years old.

Max Kakos [00:20:21] [inaudible] Duane Hatton [00:20:27] Moving my store, I would consider retiring and letting someone else run the store. Yeah, I mean, I'm not about to move. Yeah. The deli was always a meeting place also where we had always a front table for breakfast and they hung around. And also, of course, back in the '70s, we were very big with salesmen. We had a lot of salesmen that came in here. It was a big draw because at that time, our hallway, believe it or not, had six pay phones. And the salesman would come in and while they were ordering their lunch or after their lunch, they can get on the payphones and make the calls. But with the invention of cell phones, the payphones went by the wayside. So people didn't. But that was. I would never let them take the payphones away because it was a big, big thing. And now we're down to one payphone because everyone's got a cell phone.

Max Kakos [00:21:42] I only have a couple more questions for you. Do you know how the building was used prior to seeing the box?

Duane Hatton [00:21:48] Prior to when my father purchased it, There was, as I said, the restaurant. It was called Temple Court Restaurant and that was on the corner. Of course, all the entrances were different. There was a small bar which was set up totally different, as I said. Just came halfway to where it is now. And we had an entrance to the basement from the bar because the bar was separate from the restaurant. And the hallway was only for the apartments and the upstairs for the building. So when you came in, the doors that you came in, that would have been just the hallway. The Temple Court Restaurant had its entrance on the corner of 36th and Euclid. And the Hatton's Arena bar had the entrance over here. Prior to when my dad owned the bar, it was still the Temple Court Restaurant and it was called. I don't know what the bar was called for sure. I think it was still called Arena Bar because Arena was a big thing. And prior to that, I don't know. I know that when we did do some remodeling, we found and tore the walls out. We did find stone as if there was at one time a home here and this was built around it. But I don't know any facts on that.

Max Kakos [00:23:14] [inaudible] Duane Hatton [00:23:22] Corridor?

Max Kakos [00:23:23] Or do you think there need to be changes?

Duane Hatton [00:23:27] The way it is right now?

Max Kakos [00:23:28] [inaudible] Duane Hatton [00:23:33] Well, it's still in a growth period, so things are still moving forward. Yeah, everything's fine. They did some planning and plantings and we have our own parking lot so we don't have to rely too much on parking on street parking. But it's going to change drastically with the Euclid Corridor project. I mean, I don't have a problem. You mean the area? Is that what you're asking? What's your question exactly?

Max Kakos [00:24:15] Do you feel like the Euclid Corridor project is a good thing?

Duane Hatton [00:24:20] Well, I think. I don't know how much it's going to change the. I don't know how much the transit itself will make a change in the area. I think that the fact that they're doing it and it'll be beautifying the area and planting trees and fixing the area up, it'll be a much nicer place. I'm in probably a minority of a lot of businesses because, as I said, I have my own parking lot. Businesses that don't have their own parking lot, they're not happy because there won't be street parking and be difficult to get people in. Everyone can't rely on the transit to get people in with the new corridor transit because they'll be reducing the size of the street and virtually eliminating parking in the area. So it's got its pros and cons. The fact that it will improve the area, it will make it nicer looking and allow people to come in on the transit, I think that might help. If it's going to bring more people, other people than what the current buses are doing, it would probably be the people from the hospitals that want to go from University Hospital, Cleveland Clinic and be able to come down here and eat.

Max Kakos [00:25:51] How do you feel about the city of Cleveland [inaudible]?

Duane Hatton [00:25:58] In someone else's hands. I don't know as far as menu changes are concerned, but it's hard to say what would happen in the future. Depending on what the Euclid Corridor project brings and the type of people it brings down, it could go into more takeout and more of a bar in the evening or maybe more different coffees, depending. Cleveland State has always stayed below the Innerbelt. That's always been their policy. So I wasn't able to drive much from Cleveland State, but as far as Myers College, now they've got pretty ambitious plans to build in the area. They took over the University Club and took over the Minnehaha Building at 40th and Chester. Tearing that out, putting classrooms in there. And my understanding from Dr. Finegold is that they're going to be looking for dorm space. I understand they also have dorm space at Viking Hall for some of their students. So it depends on how much of a college area it becomes and how much of a foot traffic area becomes. Things change in the restaurant business. You just have to watch how it changes and change with it as we did when we were from a Jewish deli down to a reduced menu now. And catering to the type of food that people like.

Max Kakos [00:27;36] Do you think- [inaudible]
Duane Hatton [00:27:39] No, no, no. My kids are too smart. [laughs] Yeah. I made that a point from the beginning because it's a lot of hard work. And I've told all my kids, I said, you better get an education. I got an education. But at that time, this was a good, profitable business. It's not as easy to today in business for yourself as it was in the '70s. And you don't have a retirement plan unless you plan your own. And you don't have vacation days and you don't have time off. So I work an average of 16 to 18 hours a day every day. And I don't think my son is way too smart for that. He's currently. He's a teacher. In fact, he's currently teaching in Brazil. He's taught in Beirut, Lebanon. He got out there before it was bad. And he taught in Cairo, Egypt. And he's just always been a traveler, so he likes teaching overseas. He's doing very well. And he told me , he said, Dad, you and everyone else works and works and works. Saves money to go on vacation. He says, I travel to make money and make money while I'm traveling. So I said, they're smarter. My two daughters are married, so they don't need to be here. So it wouldn't be a family member. No.

Max Kakos [00:29:11] All right, Duane, thank you for your time.

Duane Hatton [00:29:13] Sure. Anything to help. You'll have to look that up. That was well known. The machine that prepared the ice for the- It has special name and- Yeah, yeah, didn't turn it off. It-
History 304: Urban History

History 304: Urban History

These course-based oral histories arose from the CSU Department of History collaboration with Greater Cleveland Regional Transit Authority, Cleveland Public Art, and WCPN/WVIZ (ideastream). Interviews in this collection were conducted by students in U.S. Urban History (HIS 304) at Cleveland State University Department of History, supervised by professors Mark Tebeau and Mark Souther. Originally intended to inform the creation of public art along the RTA’s Healthline BRT route, these interviews…