Francis W. Chiappa interview, 2 July 2013
Abstract
Francis Chiappa describes his role in the Cleveland Heights Nuclear Freeze Campaign in the 1980s. He worked hard along with other members of Cleveland Heights to make Cleveland Heights a Nuclear Free zone. He describes his background that placed him on the path of activism. He also describes the challenges and triumphs in the process of designating Cleveland Heights nuclear free.
Metadata
Interview Transcript
Transcripts may contain errors.
Francis Chiappa [00:00:11] Yeah, you're welcome.
Mark Souther [00:00:12] Will you state for the record your full name?
Francis Chiappa [00:00:14] Yeah, Francis W. Chiappa, Francis William Chiappa.
Mark Souther [00:00:18] Thank you. Where and when were you born?
Francis Chiappa [00:00:22] I was born in Brooklyn, New York, [...] 1949.
Mark Souther [00:00:26] And how long have you lived in Cleveland Heights?
Francis Chiappa [00:00:30] I first moved to Cleveland Heights in 1972 and tried to move away twice. First, to do an internship, a psychology internship in California, and actually three times, and then, then to move to Southern Ohio for my first postdoc job, and then Then to travel around the world with my wife, Dorene Davis, and each time I came back. So I like it here. Yeah.
Mark Souther [00:01:05] Tell me a little bit about what your parents did when you were growing up for a living and your education. Just a little bit about that.
Francis Chiappa [00:01:15] My father died when I was three months old. So, I was raised by my mother, who was a church secretary and then an insurance company secretary, and my grandparents, who were— well, my grandmother was a stay-at-home housewife, and my grandfather was a salesman in Manhattan. And so, the three of them raised me. And I left New York City to go to undergraduate school at SUNY Buffalo, and then came here to Cleveland to go to graduate school at Case in clinical psychology. So, I got my BA in 1971 and my PhD in 1977.
Mark Souther [00:02:02] So, you were in college all through the most intense years of the Vietnam War.
Francis Chiappa [00:02:07] Yes.
Mark Souther [00:02:07] Can you share with me, you know, your perception of the war during that time from, say, about 1967 to '71 while you were an undergraduate? And as well as any involvement you had in the anti-war movement.
Francis Chiappa [00:02:22] Yeah. Yes, I was— I don't want to say peripherally involved, because everyone on campus was— you couldn't not be involved. But Buffalo was sometimes referred to itself, at least, as the Berkeley of the East. There was probably more— There was more student rebellion going on there than any place in New York State, certainly, and most than most places on the East Coast. In 1970, we were on strike for, I think, three months, and there was a whole lot of issues. You know, at some one point, I participated in occupying the administration building. It was pretty brief. you know, a couple of hours, but we were trying to pressure the administration to take a stronger stand on the war and on military, on investments in companies that profited from the war and doing research for the war and things like that. What was very frustrating about it was the group process that It was very difficult. I went to many meetings that eventually got kind of burned out, where the— we were trying to operate— I don't even think we knew what a consensus model was, but we were trying to operate and make decisions in a way that was agreeable to most people, except the people who held sway were the people with the biggest egos and the loudest voices. So, that got pretty frustrating. So, when I say I was peripherally involved, I was— I took part in it, but I was not in a leadership role because it was just too frustrating. And, you know, that part sort of left a bad taste. But the—
Francis Chiappa [00:04:31] When Kent State happened in May of 1970, at that point, out of concern for everyone's safety, the university shut down and canceled the last few days and finals, final exams for the semester. And that kind of rebooted the whole movement. It was very different coming back in the fall. It wasn't the same. I guess for any number of reasons. But yeah, so that was my experience then.
Mark Souther [00:05:03] Were there any occupations or efforts to burn down an ROTC building?
Francis Chiappa [00:05:09] No, no, no, no. The only violence was done by the Buffalo police against the students, you know, driving by the student union and firing birdshot at the student union, which could have killed somebody but didn't.
Mark Souther [00:05:24] You say that the mood changed, you know, in the following fall of '70. Can you describe that change in mood?
Francis Chiappa [00:05:32] Well, I think everyone came back and was kind of sick of, you know, we didn't want that to happen again. And at that point, I think there had been some shift. The public was much less in support of the war, and at that point, Nixon was trying to, so-called, as he said, Vietnamize the war. So, there wasn't the pressure. But what loomed over all this, of course, was the draft. I mean, what created the anti-war movement in Vietnam was the draft. If we had a draft now, there wouldn't be any wars because people would be— Up in arms about it, or nonviolently up in arms about it. So, in 1970, I think, the fall of 1970, I was a senior, and I was more worried then about being drafted. So, when I— and I was worried about what I was going to do after I graduated. So, I applied to graduate school. came here to Case, and my draft deferment having expired, because of my student deferment, at that point, I began to put together an application for conscientious objector status, and which was difficult because I'm not a churchgoer. I don't consider myself a— I consider myself a spiritual person, but not a follower of a religion. So, what I had to do was to put together my religious beliefs in a two- or three-page, four-page format that the draft board could read. And the idea was to get a hearing, and of course, they would deny it. I had to talk to a religious leaders who wrote letters of support, including someone from the Episcopal Diocese in Brooklyn where I grew up and connected with the church that I was involved with. He wrote a lovely letter of support. The draft board denied the request. I made an appeal. I don't think they Needed to deny the second request because at that point, I should say my lottery number was 95, so I was ready to be called that year, and my number came up in 1971. And then, in 1972, in the first three months of that year, they, the Selective Service System decided not, they didn't draft anyone in those 3 months, and the reason was because of Vietnamization, they were— they didn't need more soldiers in that period, and they wanted to basically clear out the backlog of people like me who were resisting. In the Brooklyn Selective Service system, the refusal rate was 50%. So, they— it was basically like a It was like an enema for the system. They just kind of get rid of all these people, and then the rule was that after the first three months, if your number came up in the previous year and you weren't called up, then you were free and clear. So, they cleared the books of all of us and then started again in 1972. So, that was how I avoided the draft. I never had to go to jail or do CO work, but I was prepared. I don't think I would have gone to jail. I'm not sure I would have gone to Canada, but I was going to cross that bridge when I came to it.
Mark Souther [00:09:29] With conscientious objector, well, in terms of applying for that status, to what degree was being a member of a church The litmus test for one's being able to—
Francis Chiappa [00:09:44] It pretty much was. Yeah, it pretty much was. If you were out on your own, the chances of getting that were slim. But the idea was that there was an appeal process where you could go through, you know, three or four appeals and you would extend it. And the hope at that point was that, you know, the war might be over by then and it would be a moot point. So, that was— I mean, the people counseling conscientious objectors were Quakers, and they had a good legal team, and they knew what they were doing, and they helped save my butt. Yeah.
Mark Souther [00:10:21] So, you came to Cleveland Heights then in '72, the following year.
Francis Chiappa [00:10:25] Right.
Mark Souther [00:10:26] To go to Case, you said. And by that time, I'm guessing that the atmosphere had changed pretty dramatically because the war was coming close to winding down.
Francis Chiappa [00:10:36] Right.
Mark Souther [00:10:37] Really, another year or so.
Francis Chiappa [00:10:39] Right.
Mark Souther [00:10:40] So, what was the climate like in terms of student activism from your perspective as a graduate student, or were you—
Francis Chiappa [00:10:47] Well, the activism took a very different form. I think Case was— I don't know that Case was particularly active during that time, although I'm sure there was. I know there was in 1969, '70, '71. But when I came to graduate school, the activism for me took the form of politics within the psychology department. So, I remember coming and my— because the student revolt was really a lot about sort of leveling the playing field as far as status. I know I refused to call professors by their— I called them by their first names, and others of us did too. And so, I became one of, you know, two or three kind of more strident folks who we wanted to— we petitioned to be part of faculty meetings. We were granted— Two of us were granted observer status. They didn't let us vote, which at the time we thought was not very fair, but, you know, we got something out of it. And I think at that— I think that, you know, most of the faculty I think were— they were affected by the antiwar movement as well, and I think they appreciated that things probably ought to be a little more democratic and a little less hierarchical. So, many of them kind of just went along with it. I mean, I was— I didn't— there were no negative consequences within the psychology department for what I did. If there had been, I don't know what I would have done. But I'm not sure I would have risked everything to be more strident. But we made some progress, and I think we were respected in some ways.
Mark Souther [00:12:59] You've mentioned, and I've read about, Dorene Davis and you both being really the instigators of the Nuclear Freeze in Cleveland Heights. Can you walk me through her background a little bit as well in terms of what— I'm just trying to get the backstory to—
Francis Chiappa [00:13:19] Right, right. [00:13:20] Well, after—
Francis Chiappa [00:13:27] in the 19— we were married in 1978 after I came back from California. And finished my doctorate. And we decided that we would— after I had been working for three years and Dorene for 9, she's a physical therapist. I met her at Buffalo, so we moved here. We moved here as a couple, as an unmarried couple, in 1971. And Actually, we moved to East Cleveland. That accounts for that year, that missing year there. So, she worked for nine years as a physical therapist, I for 3. We were married in 1978, and we decided we'd— because we couldn't do it later, we decided we'd Quit our jobs and travel around the world. So, we planned to be gone for a year. We were gone actually for 15 months overseas and another three months before we got back and settled in this house and back to working. And this was rather a transformative experience as far as perspective on world events and world affairs. We saw very clearly how the United States was viewed in other parts of the world, in pretty much all other parts of the world, especially outside of Europe, that people love Americans and they are not particularly pleased with our government. In many cases, they hate our government, and this was true then. It's probably even more true now. So, when we— and when we came back, the hot issue seemed to be nuclear weapons. So, we came back sort of ready to be committed to something in the way of activism, and we immediately fell into—
Francis Chiappa [00:15:45] into connection with the Cleveland Heights Nuclear Weapons Freeze Campaign. At that point, it was really a lot of very local groups who were organizing to put forward the nuclear freeze proposal, which was to ban or to halt the research development, testing, and deployment of nuclear weapons, and to just stop it right where it is and not make any further steps forward. Polling back then suggested 80% of the American people supported that proposal. It never took on the power of law anywhere, but we actually did, by the end of the '80s, we had a de facto nuclear freeze. Actually, when testing stopped in 1992, when the U.S. stopped testing. We were very committed to this, and we participated in the local group. At that point, we had a young child in 1982. and another in '85. Dorene was sort of the— she stayed more involved with the local group, and I became involved with the Greater Cleveland Nuclear Freeze campaign. Then with the nuclear freeze movement in 19— with the nuclear-free zone movement, and I don't remember when those things— when that idea was first floated, but I'm guessing it would be '84, maybe? '83, '84. Then by '87, the core of people from the Cleveland Heights Nuclear Freeze decided to— and it wasn't just the two of us. There was also Beth Keane and Paulette Sage, who both had been long— who we had known for all those years, those few years in the local group. And a woman named Joy Davis, who has now left town. The five of us were the committee, and we organized to circulate a petition for a ballot initiative to declare Cleveland Heights a nuclear-free zone, and to put signage at the entrances to the to the city that it was a nuclear-free zone. Dorene technically was the chairperson, I was the treasurer, but the five of us were all kind of equally involved in it.
Mark Souther [00:18:42] I wanted to walk back just a little bit. You mentioned the Greater Cleveland Nuclear Freeze Campaign. I had read that a Oberlin and Wooster became the first two cities in Ohio.
Francis Chiappa [00:18:53] Right, right.
Mark Souther [00:18:54] And then Cleveland Heights was the third. Do you know how early Oberlin and Wooster achieved that status?
Francis Chiappa [00:19:01] I don't know. I think it was at least a couple of years before we did. I think— I don't believe that either of them did it by ballot initiative. We were determined to do it by ballot initiative because we wanted people to be involved. We wanted to get the petitions out there, and I think, I don't recall how many signatures we had to collect. I think it was, do you know? You have it, right?
Mark Souther [00:19:25] I have it.
Francis Chiappa [00:19:26] What is it?
Mark Souther [00:19:26] Correct. This is from March 22nd, 1987, Plain Dealer. It said that 3,441 signatures were needed, and at that point, you were short by 929. That's as of March of that year.
Francis Chiappa [00:19:43] Okay.
Mark Souther [00:19:44] So, you're still collecting. I'm not sure what your deadline was. It seems to have stretched at least into June, because by— it's odd that by June 18th, three months later, only, well, fewer than 200 additional signatures had been obtained, because the petition stood around 3,600 signatures. Oh, wait a second. You were short? No. Okay. It went over, I'm sorry. Yeah. I wasn't thinking. You collected quite a few in that time.
Francis Chiappa [00:20:12] Yeah, we did. Yeah, we made a push at the end. But we covered, I would say we covered half the— we probably rang half the doorbells in Cleveland Heights to do this. And it was great. It was a lot of fun. And, you know, people were incredibly supportive. It was hard to find anyone who said no, that's— they didn't want to do that. And I think it was a statement about Cleveland Heights, as it is about Oberlin. Wooster was a little puzzling, but— because I don't necessarily associate Wooster with, you know, bastion of liberalism, but there is the college there, so maybe it is. But, you know, they did it the quicker way. through the City Council. It's the less public way, although the signage was still there in Wooster and Oberlin.
Mark Souther [00:21:18] One thing I'm interested in, too, is how, since there's this Greater Cleveland Nuclear Freeze campaign going on, Were there any efforts really to try to do this in all the communities and other places just didn't get a head of steam because they're— how would you characterize other places apart from Cleveland Heights?
Francis Chiappa [00:21:37] We were hoping, we were hoping it would gather steam. I think what we found was that this is, this is a unique community. I mean, in the last couple of presidential elections, Cleveland Heights Cleveland Heights has gone 80% Democrat, and that's been, it's been that way, you know, back through the '80s. I mean, it's always been a very liberal— no, it hasn't always been a very liberal community, but since I've lived here, it's been a pretty liberal community. And, yeah, so the— and we had a good core group of organizers. who were motivated to do it. So, those 2 ingredients, I don't think, came together in any other place. So, here we stand as the only nuclear-free zone in Cuyahoga County.
Mark Souther [00:22:28] Were the five of you all living in Cleveland Heights at the time?
Francis Chiappa [00:22:34] Yes.
Mark Souther [00:22:34] And out of curiosity, were all of you from— you mentioned you and your wife, but were the others from Cleveland or were they from somewhere else originally?
Francis Chiappa [00:22:45] Yeah, they were all from Northeast Ohio. I don't know, I don't remember, because Joy Davis was peripherally involved, was involved for a limited time. My wife is from Rochester, New York, by the way. And I should say for the record that there is another Doreen Davis in Cleveland Heights, who is a realtor and she's also Jewish. She and my wife had the same dentist, so at one point their bills got crossed. And so we actually met her once. It's kind of funny, but they have gotten mixed up. You know, we get calls, we've gotten calls for each other for decades. So this is, my wife is Dorene, D-O-R-E-N-E. And middle name Marie. So it's Dorene M. Davis. And the other Doreen Davis, I don't know what her middle initial is, but her spelling is the more traditional D-O-R-E-E-N. So don't get them mixed up.
Mark Souther [00:23:52] Okay. So—
Francis Chiappa [00:23:56] Oh, you were saying where they're from. Yeah. Beth, Beth Keane grew up in, I want to say, I'm not sure, Westlake, Bay Village, something like that. Her father was a minister of the Disciples of Christ, which is a pacifist group. She actually went to college at the College of Wooster. For what that's worth. She's a little younger than us. Paulette Sage is a little older. She grew up in Canton and wound up in Cleveland. Yeah, so they're Ohioans. They were the 2 native Ohioans that I'm sure of.
Mark Souther [00:24:42] I just think it's interesting that, to some extent, and this is all just sort of anecdotal, that a lot of people, not just this group, but a lot of people bringing the more liberal values to Cleveland Heights came from somewhere else. It seems that Cleveland Heights became a place that was a haven.
Francis Chiappa [00:25:00] Well, that's, yeah, that's right. I think you, yeah.
Mark Souther [00:25:02] Not necessarily the people who were native. Right.
Francis Chiappa [00:25:05] I mean, you could compare Cleveland Heights to, well, I mean, Berkeley is part of, kind of far off to the left. But it's that kind of place. It's like Ann Arbor, Michigan. And I think its proximity to universities is a big part of that. I mean, I think it attracts people who are educated and who tend to be politically liberal. I think every major metropolitan area probably has a city, has a suburb, or a section of the city like Cleveland Heights. So that's us here. You know, we're the, you know, we're sort of the Berkeley of Cleveland.
Mark Souther [00:25:56] Some other things I was reading lead to some other questions. One aspect of the ordinance would have, and ultimately did require, notifying both the U.S. President and the Soviet Premier on an annual basis.
Francis Chiappa [00:26:11] Right.
Mark Souther [00:26:13] Who stipulated that?
Francis Chiappa [00:26:16] Well, you know, we were working from a model initiative, and part of these initiatives, whether it's a ballot initiative or an action by the City Council, the idea in these in these initiatives that don't really have any practical implications for the city, because there's no nuclear facilities here. What they want the city to do is to go on record and to send messages to elected officials elsewhere, particularly in Washington, that this is where we stand. That's true today as well, with other resolutions of this type. The idea is to make the city kind of speak repetitively on, in this case, for nuclear disarmament. The other resolution that I think is worth mentioning One thing we had to be very careful about in this is, we had to stipulate that it accepted nuclear waste from medical research, especially because the universities are close by. I certainly think it's likely that nuclear waste from medical research has been transported through Cleveland Heights, but that is an exception. In terms of the ordinance.
Mark Souther [00:27:55] Yeah. It seems that, on some level, this is symbolic, but I think, you know, how would you characterize that? Because there's a fine line between, it seems, between what's symbolic and what is really substantive, because even the symbolic itself could arguably be construed as substantive. Because it wasn't just about, well, can you take hazard— it was not much about that, correct? There was not any real fear of nuclear waste being transported through the city. It was much more about saying, we don't want to live in a world with nuclear disaster.
Francis Chiappa [00:28:37] That's right. No, I don't think there was much chance of nuclear waste from-
Mar Souther [00:28:47] We have a cat visitor who wants to get in on the interview.
Francis Chiappa [00:28:50] Yeah, I think there was little chance that there would be waste from nuclear weapons or nuclear power plants transported through Cleveland Heights, because that would travel— there's not an interstate that goes through Cleveland Heights, and there's not a rail line that goes through Cleveland Heights. Although, there is one that goes close to Cleveland Heights, the one that runs through University Circle. So, technically, I mean, there could have been something traveled there. I think, I mean, you've perhaps read the, you know, some comment on, at the time, the, you know, Brent Larkin from the Plain Dealer had some nasty things to say about us. I'm not sure what to say about that. I will say that this is something that's very much rooted in its time. I don't have strong feelings at this point that there should be big, fat signage at all the entrances to the city that we're a nuclear-free zone, because it seems like it was a statement that needed to be made then. And I don't know that it needs to be made in that same way now. I'm not sure that the idea that city resources should be put towards maintaining this, but if— the law is still on the books. So, if we wanted to insist that they keep writing to the President and Vladimir Putin, I think we could legally ask them to do that, and they'd have to do it. But no one has checked up on that part of it since the ordinance was passed.
Mark Souther [00:30:40] It seems— I'm not from here originally, like so many people. I came here from somewhere else. When I first came here 10 years ago, I remember being very curious about those. But at the time, my head was in something else. I didn't really investigate it and I'm only now learning about it.
Francis Chiappa [00:30:58] Right.
Mark Souther [00:30:58] But I'll confess that when I first saw the signs, knowing what I knew about Cleveland Heights, I thought, well, this is in— at some point in time this had more, this probably had more teeth in it. And now it's maintained because it's part of Cleveland Heights' civic identity.
Francis Chiappa [00:31:16] Right.
Mark Souther [00:31:16] Maybe it's important to maintain it for that reason. I'm not sure if that's true, but there could be an argument to be made.
Francis Chiappa [00:31:23] Yeah, I think perhaps less so because no one really cares a whole lot about nuclear weapons at this point. Not that they shouldn't, but they don't. I'm still involved with Cleveland Peace Action. I'm the co-president of Cleveland Peace Action. It's very hard to get any traction on nuclear weapons issues at this point, because people don't see it as a problem. Certainly, relative to the problem it was in the 1980s, it's much less of a problem. You've had dramatic reductions. But we still do have nuclear weapons. Countries have nuclear weapons aimed at each other, and we're spending billions of dollars every year, tens of billions, to maintain them— money that is a waste. These are weapons we don't need. We should be abolishing nuclear weapons, as, of course, Obama says we should. But it's a hard sell because there's— well, it's part of the military-industrial complex. So, these things get funded year after year by Congress. Cut food stamps, build nuclear weapons. That's the policy.
Mark Souther [00:32:36] I read somewhere in the last, it seems like the last couple of months, that there's been, I don't know, I forget the state of it now, but an increase actually, or at least a proposed increase in funding for nuclear weapons research. Not just the maintenance, but retooling some of the nuclear weapons.
Francis Chiappa [00:32:59] Right, right.
Mark Souther [00:33:00] Extending the technology research. for the technology. So, it seems that even though the President has that agenda, the agenda, the opposite agenda, he's not pressing it too hard.
Francis Chiappa [00:33:16] Right, right. Yeah, and no, you're right about that. I mean, and those proposals, they usually get pared down in Congress, but they're very persistent. And, of course, people aren't interested a whole lot in it, so they don't They don't care about that item in the budget. Nuclear weapons? Fine. Keeps us safe. I mean, that's the— I think the average American now might say something like that. Even independent voters would say that. It's frustrating. So now, you know, I mean, as far as peace work goes, we're looking at other issues. We're looking at reducing the military budget, and frankly, the other issue is Israel and Palestine. And that's really the hottest issue right now.
Mark Souther [00:34:02] Is any involvement— I do want to go back to a couple of other things about the nuclear-free zone, but while I'm thinking about it, does Cleveland Peace Action have any focus on the environmental aspect, the environmental connection for federal policy and federal— for federal for— or foreign policy, to some extent, is bound up with the concerns about the environment.
Francis Chiappa [00:34:32] Mm-hmm.
Mark Souther [00:34:33] So, just thinking about, you know, production of materials all over the world on which we depend. Fossil fuel for fossil fuel, and so on. Of course, we produce a lot more of it natively than we used to, but I'm just wondering the extent to which concerns about the environment are—
Francis Chiappa [00:35:00] I think there— I mean, certainly there are concerns. I think they tend to be a little bit peripheral. It's been very hard to— it's been hard for the peace movement to build bridges to other kind of progressive constituencies, because everyone's sort of working in their own little area. And the— I mean, I may see the big picture, and I know you do, but it's a different matter to get the average person to see the big picture, see that everything is connected. But then you go back to working on your issue, and we can support environmentalists. I mean, if they say, well, war is bad for the environment, obviously, we're there. It is bad for the environment. But will that become our core issue? Probably not. I mean, we have to go where people have some energy and some real concerns, just like I mean, that was the beauty of the nuclear freeze movement in the '80s, is that in a way, it spoiled us, because it was so easy to organize then. It hasn't been like that since. Now, it doesn't seem like there's anything that makes— people are not organizing right now.
Mark Souther [00:36:31] It doesn't go past Facebook.
Francis Chiappa [00:36:32] No, it doesn't. No. Yeah, if you put a petition, circulate a petition on Facebook, and you get 100,000 signatures, I've done my job. That's the world we live in.
Mark Souther [00:36:50] Going back to the nuclear-free zone sign effort and ordinance effort, I read that some councilmen opposed it on different There was one mention in an article about concern about sign clutter. I wonder how serious that was. It seems like that's sort of minimal.
Francis Chiappa [00:37:09] The signage was incorporated on the Welcome to Cleveland Heights Nuclear-Free Zone. It really wasn't a signage issue. I think that it came down to the— I believe at that time, there were There were five Democrats and two Republicans on the City Council, and the two Republicans were the ones who opposed it.
Mark Souther [00:37:34] There was one also mentioned in a different article about some, it just said some city councilmen privately opposed it because they see it as an embarrassment for the city. That was the paraphrasing.
Francis Chiappa [00:37:45] Uh-huh. Yeah, well—
Mark Souther [00:37:50] Did you ever get wind of that, or was, I mean, I guess the
Francis Chiappa [00:37:54] Not really. I mean, certainly most people I talked to were proud of it. So, you know, I mean, maybe it marks Cleveland Heights as, well, as an Oberlin or something like that, that it's a liberal enclave. Well, it is, so yeah.
Mark Souther [00:38:13] Not knowing anything really about, you know, I've read Brent Larkin a little bit here and there, and I've just come across him in my research. He's written about lots of different things.
Francis Chiappa [00:38:23] Right.
Mark Souther [00:38:23] I wonder the extent to which that column about the nuclear-free zone that you're referring to was, having read it, whether he was really opposed to the idea, or if he was just sort of having, taking a cheap shot at Cleveland Heights. Because it was a, it almost came across to me as something that's like, haha, Cleveland Heights, well, we can, we can make fun of, you know, these liberals in Cleveland Heights. And know that it would resonate with a lot of people in Greater Cleveland who didn't necessarily share. Because I've seen Cleveland Heights depicted in such a way in different places in the paper where it just seems that some—
Francis Chiappa [00:39:04] Right.
Mark Souther [00:39:04] And just like other communities sometimes get treated in other ways because of stereotypes that people hold about them.
Francis Chiappa [00:39:13] Right.
Mark Souther [00:39:14] I wonder if that was the level at which he was just really operating, or if he had any bigger agenda. I mean, maybe the paper itself didn't really—
Francis Chiappa [00:39:24] I don't know. I really don't know. I mean, Brent Larkin has been— I mean, he's not a conservative. I mean, I've read enough of his things over the years to know that You know, he was talking about the state budget the other day, and it was really from a liberal perspective. So, I don't know. I don't know that there was that much thought put into it. It was just a, you know, he's got to come up with a column every, you know, every couple of days. So, that's what he wrote about that day.
Mark Souther [00:40:00] It's sort of catchy.
Francis Chiappa [00:40:03] Yeah, yeah. I mean, you know, I mean, and, you know, they've got to write things that are, that will, you know, be controversial a little bit and get people's attention. I'm sure it did.
Mark Souther [00:40:16] If you had to say what the biggest issues in Cleveland Heights are, you know, we've talked some about, a good bit about peace activism. What concerns do you have about Cleveland Heights What are the biggest social ills in the Heights now compared to when you moved here? How has it changed?
Francis Chiappa [00:40:33] Well, I mean, I think the biggest concern is poverty. And the— yeah, and of course that has many faces. It shows up in education, it shows up in housing, housing stock. It shows up in— I don't think— well, it's a racial issue because the poor people in Cleveland Heights tend to be Black. So, I mean, I think the threat is really, you know, how do we maintain some kind of a middle-class character and not have people flee for other places. And this is particularly true in education where you have a lot of people who live in Cleveland Heights because they like their neighborhood and they like their beautiful, inexpensive home, but they're sending their kid to a private school to be educated. My kids both went to Heights High, which at that time was 70% Black. It may be a little more than that now. And they had a wonderful experience there. They were girls, which helps. I've heard Black parents who don't want to send their son to Cleveland Heights High. They would go out of their way to send them to private school because they're afraid of the peer group that might influence them there. So, this is a real challenge. I think, you know, there's always been a little bit of crime in Cleveland Heights. I don't particularly see it as worse, except I know there are more handguns out there, which is disturbing. But, you know, there were homes being robbed, you know, back, you know, when we moved here. I mean, it's an inner-ring suburb. That's part of the picture.
Mark Souther [00:42:54] What do you think about the city's efforts to demolish homes as an answer to some of the problems? It seems that there's been a rash of demolition in the last couple of years. I've really started to see it and grow worried about it. We're starting to feel a little bit like the city of Cleveland.
Francis Chiappa [00:43:18] Well, you can't let— I mean, the city of Cleveland, the problem is it's a runaway problem. I don't think you can— if you have a house that is hopeless, you can't let it stand. I mean, an empty lot is not a blot on the neighborhood the way a boarded-up, falling-down home is. So I don't have a problem with that. I mean, the problems are what leads to that in the first place. So, yeah, I mean, there are sections of Cleveland where homes are ridiculously— or Cleveland Heights— that are ridiculously cheap. And, you know, that's— it's the, you know, decades of poverty in those areas where the houses get run down and the housing values in the neighborhood decrease. I mean, I don't know what the answer is to that, but I know letting the homes stand is not an answer.
Mark Souther [00:44:22] One other question I had about nuclear-free zone that I forgot to ask. I read that in 1989, Shaker Heights passed its own nuclear-free zone ordinance, which surprised me, since I've never seen signage there.
Francis Chiappa [00:44:36] Right. Well, they did it the quiet way. They got it through council, and there was no signage requirement. Yeah. I mean, I'm not sure. I mean, I think we achieved what we wanted to, because we made it a public issue, and that was the whole point.
Mark Souther [00:44:59] Who was Pauline Silverman?
Frances Chiappa [00:45:01] She was one of the co-chairs of the Shaker Heights Nuclear Freeze. She's still alive. She's about 90-something.
Mark Souther [00:45:14] Is there anything that we haven't covered that you'd like to add?
Francis Chiappa [00:45:18] I don't think so. Yeah, that about covers it.
Mark Souther [00:45:23] Okay.
Francis Chiappa [00:45:23] Yeah.
Mark Souther [00:45:24] Well, thanks very much for letting me interview you today.
Francis Chiappa [00:45:27] Good. It's been my pleasure.
Mark Souther [00:45:28] Thanks.
Francis Chiappa [00:45:29] I don't usually— I never get to talk about this. So, yeah.
Mark Souther [00:45:32] Great.
Francis Chiappa [00:45:33] Good.
Mark Souther [00:45:33] Okay. Thank you.
Francis Chiappa [00:45:34] Good. Thanks.
Racial Integration in the Heights
Interviews in this series were collected by undergraduate students at Cleveland State University under the supervision of Dr. Mark Souther, with funding from the Office of the Provost. The series contains interviews with pioneers of suburban residential integration and social activists who supported peaceful managed integration/desegregation and fair housing in Cleveland Heights and Shaker Heights in the 1950s to 1970s.