Brooke Nieves interview, 17 October 2015

Interview recorded during Prosperity Social Club 10 year anniversary event.
Ms Nieves lived in an apartment above Prosperity for three years and relates the story of a unique roommate. In her account, Stan, a previous resident, is now a friendly ghost who haunts the bar and especially the upstairs apartment.

Participants: Nieves, Brooke (interviewee) / Barkacs, Michael (interviewer)
Collection: Prosperity Social Club 10 Year Anniversary Event
Institutional Repository: Cleveland Regional Oral History Collection

Interview Transcript

Transcripts may contain errors.

Brooke Nieves [00:00:00] Yeah, for sure.

Michael Barkacs [00:00:01] Hey, I'm Mike Barkacs. I'm here at Prosperity Social Club for the 10th anniversary of the bar.

Brooke Nieves [00:00:09] So exciting.

Michael Barkacs [00:00:10] I'm here with Brooke Nieves. Brooke, would you like to introduce yourself?

Brooke Nieves [00:00:15] Sure. My name's Brooke, and I actually lived upstairs of Prosperity. Bonnie bought the bar in October, and I moved in at the end of November, so I was here at the very beginning, and I actually lived here for almost three years. So we lived upstairs and we got lots of fun stories. So, okay.

Michael Barkacs [00:00:39] Really?

Brooke Nieves [00:00:40] Yeah, for sure. So the first time I sort of found out that something funny was going on, I just noticed that things in the apartment were moving around. They weren't where I thought they were. Pots and pans moving in the cupboard or the doors opening, just really weird stuff. And I thought it was just me coming home, making snacks after a long night out. And so I remember coming downstairs one day and a glass just flew off the table. And I came down and I was like, Bonnie, something's going on. You have to tell me, are we haunted? And she looked at me and she said, no, I have no idea what you're talking about. And I was like, that is not true. You have to tell me. And she walked away from the bar and she brought me a beer and she came back and she said, I do have to tell you something. And that's when she told me that Stan lived upstairs and that she thought that he was still around. And that's when I found out. So, you know, just funny little things he would do constantly. If the radio was up too loud, he would turn it down, like, that's enough, kids, go to sleep, you know. Or we had an intercom system when we first moved in, and the only way to buzz the intercom to let anybody in downstairs was to buzz it in our apartment. And so I'd be laying in bed. And my roommate would be in bed and we would just hear it buzzing, like letting somebody in downstairs. So we quickly ended that and we had Bonnie take it out. We were like, we don't want that anymore. We would hear static and noise and sort of like weird frequency stuff all the time. And I remember just being home sometimes by myself and being like, all right, Stan, I'm gonna take a bath. Like, please don't freak me out. I'm home alone. Like, I'm totally on your side. We're cool. Don't scare me. And it was fine. I mean, it was never scary. It was super like a weird dad vibe. Like, I always felt safe upstairs and like protected. And so it was really cool.

Michael Barkacs [00:02:44] So it just came with an extra roommate?

Brooke Nieves [00:02:45] It just came with an extra roommate. And we actually had a lot of different roommate changes upstairs, and I never told anybody. And then when they moved in, they would come to me and be like, are we haunted? And I'd be like, yeah. And I was always like super scared of the paranormal and anything I didn't understand. But he was, he was cool. He was definitely cool.

Michael Barkacs [00:03:06] Was he there the whole time? Still there?

Brooke Nieves [00:03:08] Whole time, still there. I have lots of friends that lived there after me and still said that it was like definitely some sort of weird vibe up there, but not scary. I can't explain it. It was very like nurturing, sort of.

Michael Barkacs [00:03:20] Does he stay upstairs or does he come to the bar?

Brooke Nieves [00:03:24] I don't know that part. I, cause I don't know that part. But he definitely he wasn't upstairs like all of the time. Like there'd definitely be like lapses in like a week or a couple days or something that nothing weird would go on. And then we'd like kind of forget about it. But I hear that he used to come down here all the time. The bartenders used to tell me stories, so. Yeah, it was cool.

Michael Barkacs [00:03:50] So how was it living in a pet store?

Brooke Nieves [00:03:52] Awesome. Yeah, I gave them a run for their money for sure. There was one Christmas where I thought we were gonna get evicted because our Christmas tree flew out the window. But I flooded this place a couple times with my washer machine. But it's, I mean, it's my home away from home. I have my birthday party here every year. You know, one day when I get married, I'd have my rehearsal dinner here. Bonnie is one of my best friends. She says I have carte blanche here, so that's cool.

Michael Barkacs [00:04:18] But yeah. Have you always been in the neighborhood?

Brooke Nieves [00:04:21] Yeah, yeah, I actually, I was born and raised in Ohio City, but Tremont has been in my blood for a long time. My parents, well, my dad and his dad used to own a lot of property in the neighborhood in the '70s and '80s. My parents met in Tremont at a church down the street. They had their first kiss in Lincoln Park, and I've been here for 10 years now, so I'm not going anywhere. I actually just signed a lease to live in one of Bonnie's houses again, so she's gonna be my landlady landlord after all these years. But yeah, it's pretty cool.

Michael Barkacs [00:04:50] Do you like the changes in the neighborhood?

Brooke Nieves [00:04:54] I do, yeah. I actually, I owned a little dress shop here for a little while on 14th, and I loved it. Yeah, it's cool to see.

Michael Barkacs [00:05:05] Is it where the fruit shop was?

Brooke Nieves [00:05:07] It's actually, it's like, yeah, it's where the wedding bridal shop is next to Bach right now. Yeah, no, I think the changes are great. I mean, I think that it's still, you know, got that like old-world vibe. You still have families that have been here forever and ever, and I love that. People tend to think it's, you know, a little bubble or something, but you're still in the city. You have to watch out, you know, what's going on. And I love it. I'd never leave.

Michael Barkacs [00:05:35] Yeah.

Brooke Nieves [00:05:36] Do you live in the neighborhood?

Michael Barkacs [00:05:37] I live in Buck Island.

Brooke Nieves [00:05:38] Oh, perfect. Okay, cool. So that's it. Yeah, I don't think I have any other really stories. I'm trying to think, like, it was just more of like.

Michael Barkacs [00:05:49] Is there any ghost stories you'd like to tell us? Or the story behind the tree flying out the window?

Brooke Nieves [00:05:56] That was just a lot of booze and it was New Year's Eve. So yeah, I remember Bonnie came running upstairs and was just like, what is going on? And the next morning we had a note on our door That was just like, Brooke and Nate, report to the principal's office. So we came downstairs with our tail between our legs and we brought her like presents and we were just like, please don't kick us out. So, but it was, you know, it was awesome. This place is the best. So yeah. Yeah, well, thank you very much.
Prosperity Social Club 10 Year Anniversary Event

Prosperity Social Club 10 Year Anniversary Event

Interviews in this series were collected by students and staff at Cleveland State University’s Center for Public History and Digital Humanities during the ten year anniversary celebration at Prosperity Social Club in the Tremont neighborhood of Cleveland, Ohio. The event featured a gathering of the Dembowski family, who ran Dempsey’s Oasis – a neighborhood pub at 1109 Starkweather Avenue that later became Prosperity Social Club – from 1938-2000. The series includes interviews with members of the…