Shelbey Holmes-Reyes interview, 2006
Abstract
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes describes her childhood family life, including a period in the foster care system and living with the challenges of poverty and family mental health issues. Holmes-Reyes also relates her experiences as Dike College (Meyers College).
Metadata
Interview Transcript
Transcripts may contain errors.
Peter McDermott [00:00:01] All right, well, I'm- I'll start with the introduction. Are we recording? My name is Peter McDermott, and I'm interviewing Shelbey Reyes at Detroit or, sorry, the Gordon Square Arcade. And this is for a U.S. Urban History course at Cleveland State University. The reason I wanted to interview you is because I'm trying to get an idea of what Cogswell Hall was like during these different periods that through, you know, went through a number of transformations from being a home for young children to being a boarding house for adolescent girls who were going to school. And now it's, you know, houses. Elderly women. And so any. You know, don't be afraid to go into detail in terms of anything that you remember from your experience. Experiences during that time. So I just want to start out with some basic background questions.
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:01:00] Okay.
Peter McDermott [00:01:01] So when and where were you born?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:01:03] Cleveland, Ohio City Hospital.
Peter McDermott [00:01:07] And when was that?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:01:09] March 3, 1938.
Peter McDermott [00:01:14] Okay. And what was your family situation like at the time?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:01:22] My mother was unmarried, and she elected to keep me. I think the father, who was married, historically, my aunt says they didn't have children and they wanted to adopt me. And she wasn't having any of it. And yet I figured that long ago, that took some guts on her part.
Peter McDermott [00:01:48] And where were you living at the time, or where were we living with? So was it just you and your mother, or did you have other brothers and sisters?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:01:56] Well, I'm my mother's firstborn child, and as far as I know, at the time that I was born, they were living on West 98th. But beyond that, I don't know a lot. My mother would not talk about this. I have no pictures, no nothing. What I have found out came from my aunt, one of my aunts. And at some point, if I'm correct, probably when I was about 1 or 2, they lived on West 48th Street off of Denison, where I currently live, but not in the same house with Aunt Zella, my grandfather and my mother.
Peter McDermott [00:02:43] So there were four of you?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:02:45] Yes.
Peter McDermott [00:02:48] And do you have. Do you have any memories of your- of your early childhood, of those houses that you lived in? Do you have any memories of living with your relatives?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:03:00] I did not live with relatives per se at that time. During World War II, my mother had married, and I have two half brothers. And. I remember some of that. What I remember is not very, very nice. That situation did not work out. And my stepfather. Now, I have no idea where my mother was at this time. I've heard various things. One was that she was hospitalized, very ill. And at that time, my brother's father took the three of us over to Joan's home and said that we had been abandoned by her. My aunt says no, but that my mother was sick and didn't know where we were. Jones home was interesting. I have some memories of that. I think the fondest one I have is. And now I realized we were being abused, actually. You could put rags on your feet and skate around upstairs in the big room. In other words, we were polishing the floor and everybody had bowl. Every older child had bowl haircuts. I did not for a while until I cut my bangs too short because the older girls kept my long hair tidy. And on Sundays, when it was adoption day, because Terry and I were older children, we were told to stay inside and not be visible because people didn't want to adopt old folks. Other than that, I remember my brother shooting peas across the dining room table.
Peter McDermott [00:05:08] And how old were you when this-
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:05:10] That would have been about six and a half.
Peter McDermott [00:05:12] Where was the Jones Home?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:05:13] The Jones Home is still on West 25th Street.
Peter McDermott [00:05:16] Okay.
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:05:18] It's Applewood now or something.
Peter McDermott [00:05:19] Yeah, my roommate works there, actually.
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:05:21] Oh, okay. Well, maybe they could get me some early records. I've tried unsuccessfully to find out what the intake on that was.
Peter McDermott [00:05:30] So you were there with two of your half brothers?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:05:34] The two half brothers, yes. And then later, apparently. And again, this is from an aunt who is deceased. He took Ronnie and fostered him with some friends in Medina County. I don't remember that because I just don't, you know. Ronnie would have been a baby. I probably wouldn't have noticed if he was there or not noticed. I mean, I remember Terry a lot, but I don't remember Ronnie a lot. And then after he took us out of there, he- I remember a series, some fun and some not fun of quasi. Back in those days, there wasn't a licensing requirement, so anybody could put a sign out and say, I'll take in children. And so he farmed us out a lot. Some of them were long stays, some were short. The majority felt corporal punishment was the way to keep discipline. I can remember some beatings I didn't appreciate a whole lot. Terry was a bed wetter. And I know I used to get up and turn his mattress before she would- the one woman down in Tremont- so that he wouldn't get punished. But she did make him wear a diaper once out in the yard. Says, I'm a wet-a-bed.
Peter McDermott [00:07:14] Do you remember where that was?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:07:15] Oh, yes, I do, very well. Down in Tremont, where the baseball field is in Tremont, Clark Field, there used to be a road that went down like this and up like that, like a valley. And at the edge of. The. People lived there. Some had indoor facilities and some did not. We did, actually, but beyond that was the steel mills. There wasn't any Clark Field or anything like that. We slept in big beds, three or four of us to a bed. I remember eating oatmeal. Because one of her corporal punishments left a lot of open wounds. I was going to Tremont School. And the nurse wanted to know why I wouldn't take gym. And I showed her. And next thing I know, I wasn't living there anymore. So, I don't know. Somebody told me later that's when some licensing started to be. I have no idea. I mean, didn't mean anything to me.
Peter McDermott [00:08:27] Do you remember the name of that institution?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:08:29] No, it wasn't an institution, Some woman's house. Just some woman whose husband worked nights. So we had to be quiet. And your mouth got washed out with Fels-Naptha soap. And I cannot stand the smell of Fels-Naptha soap. Because I'm a mouthy person. And I guess that's never changed a whole lot. Because I remember getting my mouth washed out. Because to quote my mother, if somebody says up, I say down. So again, it's a lesson I've not quite conquered yet.
Peter McDermott [00:09:04] So when you do, you have an idea of how many places you were at? Until you came to- what was Cogswell Hall called?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:09:13] I think I tried to think about that when Diane became director. And it kind of came back into my life. My mother called it the Girls Training Home.
Peter McDermott [00:09:28] You went from the Home for Friendless Girls to the Training Home for Girls. To the Cleveland Training Home for Girls. [crosstalk] Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:09:41] From the Tremont- We went to East 105th to a boarding house. And I honestly don't remember anything in between that. And then we were on Detroit Avenue at a boarding house, the three of us. And I want to say it was 57th or 59th, I'm not sure. And it was at that point where my brother's father. See, at that point, I still thought he was my father. Although he wasn't nice to me. I woke up one morning and he was gone. He had taken his sons and left. And left me at the boarding house with a note to get in touch with my mother. And where to get in touch with her. So.
Peter McDermott [00:10:35] And what. Where did he say that she was?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:10:38] On Franklin Avenue in a rooming house, which she was. She was in a relationship. That eventually they did get married. And he was a good man. Once he and I stopped squaring off at each other. That was in 1947. And the story goes, according to my mother, that she was walking around trying to figure what on earth she was going to do, because the boarding house lady had said, uh, no kids, you know, they were. And she ran into Ms. Fedetto. Ms. Fedetto had been her English teacher at West Tech. And Ms. Fedetto at that time was the head honcho at Cogswell Hall. And I was young for the girls that they took there, but Ms. Fedetto said they would take me, and that was that. She was visually the epitome of a Boston spinster. I can picture her anytime I want to. She was a tall, slender lady with graying white hair on top of her head. And she wore like, like buttoned up, ankle length shoes and straight dresses. And she had a little accent and she was always very nice to me. There was another matron there who was Mrs. Link from Florida, who had an attitude problem, or maybe I had the attitude, I'm not sure. We didn't click. And the one thing again, you have to visualize, if you can visualize as a proper Bostonian spinster. I was crying and Ms. Fedetto wanted to know what was wrong. And I have a low voice. And as a child it was noticeably low. And Ms. Link had called me a foghorn. And Ms. Fedetto said, that's okay. Someday somebody will consider that when you grow up to be sexy. A. I didn't know what it meant, but when I got older and realized I thought out of her mouth, there must have been depths to her that I didn't know. It just tickles the hell out of me whenever I think about it, because it was. It was a comfort. So.
Peter McDermott [00:13:12] So you first. You first got there, you were. You were nine around.
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:13:16] Yeah.
Peter McDermott [00:13:20] I want to talk about school. How did you go to school? Changing your residence so many times.
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:13:33] Wherever I was, it must have been much easier to get kids into school then. It really must have been, because Gilbert schools. I remember them telling me that I hadn't been there long enough for them to even come. I haven't been there, but I was there about two weeks. And that was because on 65th Street by the post office, Aunt Zella was living upstairs over a bar because she was performing in the bar and her sister Lorraine was there. And we left via the fire escape one night because the landlord was coming to check that. The rumor that there was kids up there. And it was just situations like that, you know, I'd be at one place for a while. I didn't think a lot about it. You know, it was just, oh, okay. You know, if you don't know anything different, it doesn't occur to you that it's not exactly the way to be. I remember feeling for a long time until I found out that the boy's father was not mine, that there must have been really something horribly wrong with me. But I was very relieved to find out he wasn't.
Peter McDermott [00:14:58] So you mentioned your aunt was performing. What was she doing?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:15:03] She played the guitar. She was married to my mother's brother, who had been trained as a concert violinist, went to Tennessee and married a hillbilly and became a fiddler. Quote my great grandmother.
Peter McDermott [00:15:21] So how many schools did you say that you went to?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:15:24] 13 elementary schools. Thomas Jefferson Junior High and Lincoln High School.
Peter McDermott [00:15:32] And were you able to finish school on time or was there.
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:15:37] I quit school. When I did go back to live with my mother and new stepfather. She had three kids in pretty close to six succession. And I pretty much felt like I was there to take care of them. I was behind in school in terms of English usage and mathematics because I'd never stayed long enough anywhere to really learn because every school's at a different level. And my mother wasn't well, clearly, obviously, having three children so close together, so. And at that point, my sister's father and I were still squaring off a lot. At one point, we lived with his sister and her husband, and that was a charming memory. So, I just didn't do well at school. I cut. I hung out with the other ne' er do wells, I guess you could call them. When I left Lincoln, I had 100 and some odd detention opportunities, which was what you got when you cut class or something when I left. And I ran into Mr. Mancini once and he said, you still owe me. So.
Peter McDermott [00:17:24] So when your mother. When you eventually came back into contact with your mother, did you guys talk about where she had been? Did she mention what had happened to her?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:17:34] My mother would never discuss any of that. And again, you know, I look back now and wonder, well, why didn't I say, where the hell have you been? But I didn't, you know, it was like, okay, he's out of my life. She's back. That's good. The girls, the older girls at Cogswell Hall said, uncle John's gonna be your father and your mother's gonna have a baby. And I'm like, you're out of your mind. Of course she did. She had a baby on March 17th of 1948. Mickey, sister Michelle. And they Were still living at the boarding house so I could go visit, but I couldn't, couldn't be there.
Peter McDermott [00:18:16] So when you first came to Cogswell Hall, what were your initial impressions of?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:18:23] Oh my God, it was so big. It was really so big. And I don't remember anybody else being my age there. I don't remember any of the other girls. I guess they were younger girls, but not my age because I've been told they were there, but they weren't. I guess I didn't interact with them. You know, they must have. I thought they were working. When I thought about later, I thought, well, they must be going to school or work or college or something. I thought it was like, you know, when I grew up, I thought, well, maybe it was more like high end YWCA or something. I mean, I didn't give it a whole lot of thought. I was happy that my mother was around and she said that I wasn't going back to my brother's father. So, you know, it was nice.
Peter McDermott [00:19:28] How old do you think the other girls who were staying there were?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:19:32] You know, I have no idea. They seem like grown ups to me. Yeah, because the only time we'd be together would be at meal time and you know, the dining room would. There was like tables of four or six, I think, with placemats and napkins. And certain days there was the good crystal. And I don't know where they were the rest of the time. I really don't. After, I have to say, I think it was after Christmas of '47 that Joy came. Her name was Joy Prasnik. And I remember that only because she kept telling me Prasnik meant holiday in another language. And I don't remember what language. And she was there because her mother had died because they were Christian Scientists and her father needed to figure out what to do next. And then there was a girl who came because my bedroom was here, Joy was here. And then there was another bedroom here. And she was older than Joy and I and a little more rowdy. And her name was Helen. And I don't know if it was Farnsworth or Farmington. I've tried to think about that over the years. She was somebody who planned things for the three of us to do but didn't take the blame. She always talked herself out of it.
Peter McDermott [00:21:07] What were those things?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:21:09] Oh, I don't know. Like taking the housekeeper's key so you can go in the pantry at night and see what vanilla tasted like, which doesn't taste good at all. And on Scranton, on West 25th Street, where all the vacant lots are now, like, diagonally from Jones home. There used to be a confectioner, and that guy would make Easter baskets that were all chocolate. And my stepfather had bought a really big one, and it was in the pantry, and we'd go in it. We weren't supposed to, because they were going to dish it out. And we'd go in and break off pieces of that basket. A privilege was to be allowed to take. The margarine wasn't in sticks then. It was in a bag of lard with little orange peel. And if you're really good, you got to do it again. Child abuse, child labor. But that was a privilege. That was like, if you're really good, you got to do that.
Peter McDermott [00:22:14] When did you get caught?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:22:19] I got caught having done it before I was supposed to. You could do it if the cook let you, but if you went in the pantry and went in the little refrigerator and took it out, I don't know how they knew it was us, but they did. Probably because the older girls wouldn't have done something like that.
Peter McDermott [00:22:35] And do you remember where the third young lady you were talking about, do you remember how she came to the house?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:22:44] No. She was just there one day. And I feel like I've thought about this because a long time ago, maybe my kids were little. They're in their 40s. Long time ago, when we lived on 67th off of Detroit, we went down to where American Greetings was having an outdoor festival, and some of the artists were there. And there was an artist whose name was Joy Holiday. And I asked her, and she just never heard of me. Never heard of the home. I'm sure it was her. I really am. How many? I just. I just think so. But if she didn't want to go back there, that's fine. I can understand that.
Peter McDermott [00:23:35] Did you get the sense that girls were coming in and out of the home at a relatively fast pace? Was that.
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:23:46] I don't have any sense of that. Again, like I said, you know, it's weird, probably, but I. It was just Joy, Hellen and me and Ms. Fedetto and Mrs. Link, the cook, who. I can't picture. Mrs. Link, I can picture. I mean, I was just. I guess I was really happy to be. I guess safe might have been the word, because my brother's father was not a good person. And, you know, I knew where my mother was. I don't think I thought about if I was ever going to go live with her. But, I mean, I had my own bedroom. Something I'd never had. A bed that was all mine. I mean, what more could you ask?
Peter McDermott [00:24:41] And when you were- When you were at the home, where were you going to school? Were you going to school?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:24:46] Waterston.
Peter McDermott [00:24:48] Right around the corner?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:24:50] Yeah, down the 73rd. I think it's 73rd.
Peter McDermott [00:24:58] And so would you- Could you- Could you describe an average. An average day of what you do while you were living there?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:25:07] Oh, if I wasn't being punished, sure. I've thought about this, because Diana and I talked about it. When you got up, you know, there was a bell that was rung, and you got up and you washed your face and hands and you went down and you had breakfast and then you had to go upstairs and make your bed and you had chores. You had a chore to do, and then you would get dressed and go to school. My chore, because my bedroom was right by the front side steps. I usually wiped down the steps, you know, on Saturday morning, you changed your bed. And that meant that the bottom sheet got put in the wash, the top sheet became the bottom sheet, and you got a clean top sheet. Again, this is, you know, I don't have any prior memory of ever thinking about sheets or anything other than trying to find my space in a bed and not having somebody's foot in my mouth. I can remember that when people would sleep the wrong way, you know, in a big bed. Punishment, at least for me, was getting to iron placemats and getting to darn socks in the sewing room. They still have a sewing room, but I think it's somebody's apartment now. And that was where things were ironed, because in the basement there were mangles for, I guess, the sheets and things. But ironing, the placemats, and they all had to be without wrinkles. So if you had a wrinkle in the middle of them, you got to do the whole pile again. And I learned how to darn a sock there. Something I never did afterward, kind of ranks up there with ironing. I don't like to iron and I don't like to darn. I will, but I don't want to. I also don't like doing dishes. Done a lot of dishes.
Peter McDermott [00:27:12] Could you describe how the house looked to you from what you remember?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:27:19] Well, when you came in the front door, you could see the dining room, and it looks so formal. And then there was, at that time, I mean, I realized having gone back, it wasn't all that big. But to your right, there was this huge living room, you know, and then to your left, there was like a small parlor. There was on each side, there was a table in the window. And then there was on each side. They looked almost like church pews, but they were softer. And that's where. If you wanted to talk to Mrs. Fedetto, that would be where you would be. If you had guests, that's where they would be. And when I went back, it was at Cogswell Hall a couple years ago. The bathroom looks the same. You know, just think the third floor was off limits because it was. I think the older girls were up there, and we weren't to be. The three of us certainly weren't to go up there. And I can't remember where it was, but there was a room that if you were sick, you might be in isolation or, you know, somewhere. I don't remember where it was, though. I remember, believe it or not, looking at me. But somebody used to give me some grief about wanting second helpings on mashed potatoes. And I was so skinny. Ms. Fedetto said, we need to fatten her up. It must have been good. It was good, I think. I don't remember having to eat anything that I didn't like. I don't eat corn and I don't eat peanut butter. Because in one of the places I lived with a quasi foster parent. If you didn't eat it, it got shoved back in your mouth until you did eat it. So, like Fels-Naptha soap, I can't stand the smell of corn or peanut butter. I can eat peanut butter cookies and I can eat cornbread, but I cannot. I don't like the smell of it just- It triggers something. You know, it's. You know, my mind says it's not real, but the rest of me doesn't believe that.
Peter McDermott [00:30:09] Do you remember any, did the people who worked at Cogswell hall, did they ever take you guys out or, like, did you do anything for fun or entertainment other than sort of things around the house that you can remember.
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:30:22] You know, I thought about that. I don't remember that we did. I know at Jones Home there used to be orphans day out to Euclid Beach. But at Cogswell Hall, I don't remember that. I think we might have gone to a movie, but I really don't remember. It's just. I don't remember. But I have no negative feelings about my time there. It's the only place that I don't have negative feelings about.
Peter McDermott [00:31:05] And what was the situation that led up to you leaving there? How long were you there for?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:31:10] Well, Mickey was born in March of '48. And I think that I've looked through mom's papers when she died, and I couldn't. She must have been the shredder of all time. I think I was there close to three years because I remember us being on Clark Avenue when Mickey was a toddler and Kathleen was the one in the crib. And that was. They were living there before I went there to live with them, because I went to visit one Sunday, and up until, 1984, I've always worn my hair long, except for Jones Home, and I tried there, and I went to visit. Kathleen was like the new baby. I was given a Sunday to go visit, and I went there with very long braids, and I came back with a Dutch cut because my mother thought she could trim my hair. But instead of trimming it with the braids, she unbraided it. And Ms. Fedetto was not pleased. I have a gruesome picture of it, too. So.
Peter McDermott [00:32:49] And so after living there for possibly three years, where did you move to?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:32:56] Well, like I said, they were living over a beverage store, which is, probably about 50th and Clark. The building's still there. I'm not sure if it's a beverage store anymore. And while they were living there, I went to the sixth grade up at Clark School. So at some point during the time they were living there, I came to live with them. So. And then after that, we lived in just, you know, different places.
Peter McDermott [00:33:42] Were you happy to move back with your mother?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:33:46] I think I had mixed feelings because it was a small, cramped apartment. Here was this man that I really didn't know telling me what I could or could not do, And these two little girls who got into my stuff. I think at that point, I'd have preferred to stay where I'd go, Cogswell Hall. When I thought about it later, I thought, you know, I knew who I was with Ms. Fedetto. And despite the fact that eventually, and it took some time, my stepfather and I figured each other out. I think he told me once, he said, well, here you are, almost a teenager, and I was determined that you were not going to get in trouble so people could blame me. And he never had kids. He was, like, 38. And here's me saying, you're going to tell me what to do? I don't think so. So, Like I said, eventually we figured each other out.
Peter McDermott [00:35:11] And do you remember having to take care of your mother?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:35:14] Oh, yes. I took care of my- My mother didn't think I'd ever have children because I got saddled with hers. I would walk around with. Kathleen and Pamela are ten and a half months apart. Mickey and Kathleen are, I think, about two years apart. So I'd have one on. You know, they were mine. And, you know, it was. There were things I was supposed to do in the house when they went to market or when they went out dusting and taking care of the girls. And, no, you can't punish them, but I could. And they'll tell you, yes, you can't punish. But, oh, let me grab your arm or tell you the monsters coming out of the vacuum. I don't remember doing any of this stuff. I do remember leaving them up in the balcony of the theater while I was downstairs, but they didn't come to any harm.
Peter McDermott [00:36:17] What theater was that?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:36:19] Oh, where were we living then? It was probably Detroit Theater. And Franklin Avenue has changed a lot because between Cogswell Hall and 65th there used to be, like, several big funeral homes. They were big, in my opinion.
Peter McDermott [00:36:40] On the south side of the street?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:36:42] On the same side as Cogswell hall. Because that was, you know, that corner stuff was. It was all the way down to 65th Street. There wasn't. When they tore. They tore down houses there. I remember that because I used to go to Bethany for a while. Not in church, but because we were starting a group, community group. And I remember that when we would go for walks, there was one of the funeral homes they had Great Danes who would bark. You know, they were as tall as the fence. I mean, there was little things, snippets, you know, because when you called me, I said, you know, there's just pieces. You know, it's pieces. The boarding house on East 105th. I remember finding out that you could cook an animal's tongue and that it tasted okay, you know, because that's what the woman served. And I was like. I remember being horrified. And, you know, she told me to taste it, which is something I always told my kids. Taste it. If you don't like it, we'll go from there. They don't believe now that they ever had tripe or they ever had rabbit or they ever had tongue. I said, well, you ate what people gave us or what I could get. So, you know, when we lived on 73rd, there was a Fisher's at the head of the street. It's not there anymore. And so.
Peter McDermott [00:38:12] And when you look at the neighborhood now, what do you think? What do you think of how it was?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:38:18] I liked it the way it was. It was more comfortable looking. I'm not against new housing, but one of the things I found when I was on Wessom's crash board, when they first came into town and said, you know, we're going to come into your community. Ohio City. It's what became Ohio City. We will not displace anybody, but we will increase your tax base and you'll get better city services. And that's not what happened. And. I think some older housing stock can be saved. These newer housing, somebody like me is never going to be able to afford them, not if I work for the next 30 years. So where you're going to have, you know, you're going to change or, you know, if you've got a vacant lot and you put a house on needs to be truly mixed and nobody should be put out that they can't come back. And that's what I saw in Ohio cities. And I would rather see new housing look more like. But was there instead of being such a sore, sore, sore thumb. That's just me. My son for 16 years worked for Cleveland Housing Network as a director and he did, you know, they reclaim housing.
Peter McDermott [00:40:11] My father is actually the executive director of Cleveland Housing Network for about 10 years.
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:40:15] Oh, yeah? [crosstalk] Mark?
Peter McDermott [00:40:19] Yeah.
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:40:19] Oh, shit. He knows my son. You know, I kept thinking McDermott. Where do I know that name from? Well, then he knows Chris. I think he gave Chris the camper I use. Chris Holmes.
Peter McDermott [00:40:32] I know Chris Holmes.
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:40:33] That's my baby. One of my babies. It is a very small world. It is a very small world.
Peter McDermott [00:40:42] Yeah, I remember that camper used to be in the backyard.
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:40:47] It's in my garage because it leaks, but I still use it.
Peter McDermott [00:40:55] That's funny. So when did you, how long did you live with your mother for?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:41:03] Until I left and got married then.
Peter McDermott [00:41:05] And when was that?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:41:09] When did I get married? '56.
Peter McDermott [00:41:15] And who was your husband? How did you meet?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:41:18] We both went to Lincoln and both had home situations that made us part of the group that, you know, didn't really give a rat's behind. So. And I grew up and he didn't. So we aren't together.
Peter McDermott [00:41:43] And did you. When did you first have children?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:41:48] 1957.
Peter McDermott [00:41:50] And how many children did you have? So he was your.
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:41:54] Chris is my second child. I have three living children. I had a number of miscarriages and because I don't know anything about my father, I have no idea where the problem lies because my husband's mother had 10 children and only the last one had Rh factor. So it's probably somewhere in my biological father because I don't know where else it would be. Just like Chris has RA and there's nobody that I can figure out who would have contributed that. We all have arthritis and we all wear glasses. But one of my mother's brothers was really into looking up the family tree and all that stuff. And I asked him and he said, I don't see anything. So I think that's where that came from.
Peter McDermott [00:42:57] Could you explain what those conditions are?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:43:00] RA? it's rheumatoid arthritis and it's a degenerative disease and it's where your body's fighting itself and it's very painful and you can give in or you cannot, and Chris isn't giving in.
Peter McDermott [00:43:24] And so were you divorced from your first husband?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:43:27] Oh, yeah.
Peter McDermott [00:43:28] And when was that?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:43:37] Let me think about that. It's not like something I care about. Let's see, either January of '63 or '64. I really don't remember. I think '63. But you couldn't prove it by me.
Peter McDermott [00:44:03] And were all of your kids, did you have them with your first husband?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:44:07] Yes.
Peter McDermott [00:44:08] Were you ever remarried?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:44:09] I was in a common law relationship with Mr. Reyes, and that's also no longer existing.
Peter McDermott [00:44:18] And were you while you were married through this entire time, where have you been working.
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:44:29] While I was still married a couple of times I went to work because Mr. Holmes felt that I should and he was going to watch the kids. But then he found out he didn't really want to watch the kids. So those jobs didn't last long. So when I first got divorced, I was on welfare and I did ironing and cleaning and so forth. And then when the War on Poverty started, I got a position in the Opportunity Center and the War on Poverty in the '60s.
Peter McDermott [00:45:04] What did you do then?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:45:06] I was an outreach worker which meant that on the Lorain Avenue, by Lorain-Fulton Building, which were our office. Well, our first office was on Woodbine in 38th and then we moved to Lorain-Fulton Building and it was door knocking. And the first couple years was okay because if you wanted to spend the whole day with one person and take that person places they needed to go, and then the government said, you will spend 15 minutes with this person and refer them. But people in the community had had so many of these referrals that never went anywhere that was really going to defeat the purposes. And Ruby Pearce and myself asked if we could work a 38-hour week so that we could be home when our children got home. And they refused that. And I think that was about the time. So then I quit that. That Bruce Thomas came to town and started organizing what became welfare rights. The original I think they call it empowerment something or another now.
Peter McDermott [00:46:22] And who was Bruce Thomas?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:46:24] An organizer from out of town who came into town to organize people. And I was still living on 67th then. And. I was very angry at that time because welfare was like they would. When I first moved on to 73rd and went down to the welfare department and said, you know, I walked out - at that time I was actually pregnant, but I lost that baby - walked out with three kids and I need some help. And they said, well, your husband has to come with you. And I said, you're missing the point. He's not in the picture. Well, can't you get relatives to help you? No, somebody will come out to see you. And at that time, welfare, when they would come to see you, they would open your cupboard doors and make sure you really didn't have any food. If they came another time and you had a toaster, they'd want to know where that came from. Like, you know, if you have money for that, you. So I was very open to joining, you know, joining Bruce Thomas and organizing a group in Cleveland, and we did that at Bethany. And I was one of the first co chairmen citywide of welfare rights. And so I guess okay, that was my work then as an activist because Jenna was a sickly baby. And when she got- As years went by and, you know, we did all the things you do, you march, you do sit ins, you get arrested, and blah, blah, blah, a time came when I really needed to think about doing something else. And when I was an outreach worker, I was eligible for food stamps, but I had to jump through hoops, and it was $12 and it wasn't worth it. It was like, I don't think so. So, I did books for a body shop. And one of the programs that the War on Poverty had was opening up credit unions in the inner city. So Bay Dugan, we started All People's Federal Credit Union, and I was the assistant director there with Dorothy Miller and did that from '72 to '81, somewhere in there. And then the funding ran out. And then from there, my friend Gayle Long, who I met when she was a brand-new baby social worker, she was assistant director at Merrick House at that time. And she called me up one night and said, the bookkeeper's quitting. And you have to remember, I did not have my high school diploma and math is not my strong suit. And I said, yeah? You got to apply for it. Okay. So I applied. And Mr. Pittaway, who I knew from the community, also didn't think much of the idea because he said the board wanted persons with qualifications. I said, I can add and subtract and I'll wear sandals to get up to 20, not a problem. So I learned on the job and in '84 I decided to go get my GED and then I found out what was involved and I thought, nah, I don't need to do this. But I did want to do something. So I went to Tri-C and got a two-year degree. Did not get an accounting degree because geometry was beyond me and I couldn't see the point of it in what I was doing. After I did that secretly, I went back to Tri-C and got my GED and if I had failed, I wouldn't have told anybody. If I passed, I was going to tell them. So I passed.
Peter McDermott [00:50:43] And at one point were you first a single mother with your children?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:50:49] When Jenna was a baby. Jenna was born in December of '62. And you know, physically, Mr. Holmes was around, but he was not a provider. If our utilities were cut off, he would go home and live with his mother until, until we moved somewhere or I moved us somewhere. He ate. He didn't care if the kids ate because he was working. But he's a sociopath. It's what the psychiatrist said. He's a sociopath. He's not capable of getting beyond the 18-month stage in life where it's me. He does not conceive that. Why are you upset? I didn't do anything. And it's a real condition, apparently. So.
Peter McDermott [00:51:52] Do you remember any particular, do you have any particular memories of being essentially a single mother? Of how difficult that was?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:52:01] I thought it sucked, frankly. I think one of the things that there was a. When I lived on 73rd, there was a girl lived downstairs, her name was Tony and she said one time, God, and my nickname was Kitty. She said, God, Kitty, I envy you. You don't have to answer to anybody. And I thought about that and I thought, that's right, I don't. There is nobody. Even if I had, even if he was just sitting in a chair and going, uh huh huh. It's nice to have somebody to talk to, to bounce things off of. If every decision you make, is this the one that. Is this an okay decision, you know, is it okay to tell the boys they have to fight their own fights, to tell the gang. Because there was a gang of kids on 67th that would charge the little kids money to get off the street. And I would tell them, you know, if I go down there and interfere, it's going to be worse, you just tell them, hey, I'll take you one on one, but I'm not taking the whole group of you. And yes, you might get your ass beat, but I'll bet you they'll leave you alone afterward. And you know, it's hard to tell your kids stuff like that. It's hard to tell them to tell their principal, you can't put me out because my mother says so. You have to call my mother. But they did. They knew that if they were right, I'd back them up. If they're wrong, they better not have anybody call me. And I would tell them, hey, if my sons said they didn't do it or they're not responsible or that's not what happened, then that's not what happened. You cannot put them out. I don't want them on the street when I'm working. Keep them there, give them a toothbrush, let them scrub something. I don't think being a single parent is impossible, but it's not something I think people should, you know, run out and do. Do I regret it? No. I gave my children, I think a stable life. They would not have had that if I stayed with Mr. Holmes because that just wasn't going there.
Peter McDermott [00:54:26] And so you had two sons and one daughter?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:54:28] Yeah.
Peter McDermott [00:54:29] And what have they gone on to do?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:54:33] Well, you know about Chris. Jennifer has two two-year degrees from Tri-C. One is pre-nursing. She wanted to be a nurse but the grants were starting to fade and she just couldn't get biology so she switched over and got a two-year degree in early childhood education. She's been a nanny for a couple who- The guy taught at Berea and Naomi was a professor at some college and she wrote a book, wrote several books actually until Ben was old enough to go to preschool. She has since '92, been working in the MRDD field as a supported living person. She really enjoys that. That's where I work part-time. I work for a different agency but I'm a part-time supported living specialist with adult MRDD.
Peter McDermott [00:55:42] Where is that at?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:55:44] Where I work is Welcome House and their office is out in Rocky River. But I work in- I'm trained to work in seven different with seven different people who live on their own. Currently I'm just doing because I only want to work part-time. Now I work with one mom who lives in Parma Heights to enable her to remain independent and living on her own.
Peter McDermott [00:56:11] How long have you been doing that work you said?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:56:14] I've been doing that since '94 and I retired from Merrick House after 19 and a half years. Because the arthritis in my hands just got to the point where being the bookkeeper accountant just wasn't working. It was uncomfortable.
Peter McDermott [00:56:38] And so what else do you do with your time now, other than working?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:56:42] Well, like I said, Judy would like to have an animal. And even before I started with her, I used to go out to this no kill shelter. And then I found out they would have volunteers because every morning a crew comes in and cleans and feeds and so forth, because there's close to 100 loose cats in a ranch house, so you need that. And so Judy and I do that on Thursday morning. So I've had a garden with Gail and her husband and Rick Warner at the Urban Community Garden on the corner of 38th and Franklin for the last 20, about 25 years. I read. I love to read. I like to draw, but my hands don't always allow that. And I like to camp. That's pretty much it.
Peter McDermott [00:57:38] Not in the camper, though.
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:57:40] No, we use it. I use it. I can't use a tent anymore because I really. It's pretty ugly for me to get down on the ground and try to get up. It's like the beached whale. That's why when Chris wanted to give me the camper, I said, sure. I have a, what they call a skin that goes on the roof of a house before they put the shingles on. So when you jack this thing up, you just throw the skin on top so you don't get wet. It serves a purpose. All I'm doing is sleeping in it.
Peter McDermott [00:58:08] Oh. I was mad at my parents when they gave that thing away.
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:58:11] I'm sure you were. I was like, why would he give it to you? Because the one I had previously, I had bought it for $200, and it was one that was virtually a wooden box with metal. And you had to throw this canvas on it. Try doing that when it's real hot. And I turned around and sold it to somebody for $200. So I was like, why would anybody. What's wrong with it? No, I've had. It's lasted pretty well. Right now, Chris's boat and his camp are in my backyard. That's why I don't have a backyard.
Peter McDermott [00:58:45] I think I actually played golf with Chris at one point.
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:58:48] Good.
Peter McDermott [00:58:49] Me and my dad. Someone else from CHN, I don't know.
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:58:53] Well, I'm mad at them right now, so.
Peter McDermott [00:58:55] So, yeah.
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:58:59] I don't know if I've been helpful, because, like I said, it's just-
Peter McDermott [00:59:03] This has really been captivating. I guarantee you [crosstalk]
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:59:08] Not a lot of it's got to do with Cogswell Hall, though. Yeah.
Peter McDermott [00:59:11] But it's also I mean, it's also an issue, you know, what people did when they left there.
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [00:59:17] Yeah, I think, you know, you know, like Tremont School. I remember they had a dental clinic upstairs for the kids. I remember that. You know, I remember that the milk was delivered by a guy who had ice in the back with a horse. It was a horse. And the big kick was he would give you chips of ice, you know, so even though that particular woman was. I mean, she really beat the hell out of a lot of us for very minor infractions. There's always some, you know, but that was fun to get that, you know, he would let, give us ice. I mean, just those snippets that I think, gee, that was fun. And then, you know, my kids will never get to do that. My grandkids certainly won't do it. They wouldn't dream of doing it. They're princesses. But it was fun.
Peter McDermott [01:00:13] Well, is there anything that we haven't talked about or that particularly sticks out in your mind?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [01:00:23] Just, you know, that Cogswell Hall, you know, was one of the things that when things weren't going the way I thought they should go, I was sorry that I couldn't go back and talk to Ms. Fedetto, really. You know, there was. I went to, you know, at one point, Tom was acting out pretty badly, and Jennifer, they didn't expect her to live. Her brother died in the womb. And they kept telling me, you know, they didn't know what to do with her, that, you know, we just have her until we didn't have her. And I went to see, Child Guidance, I think it was called, on East 22nd. I wanted to talk to somebody. You know, I don't remember his name, but, you know, my mother's response to that was, you don't think you're crazy, do you? We never had anybody crazy in our family. It's like, no, but I'm having problems. Well, it's all. It's all. Mr. Kenny, his name is Ken, said, no, mom, it's not all his fault. You know, there's more to it. Everything that. Everything that you are comes from all the experiences. I said, you know, Terry and Ronnie's father, he, you know, he wasn't a good person. That's an experience. I said, sure, Ken has some bearing on all this, but he's not the whole thing, you know. But she simply, you know, just, just couldn't deal with things. I mean, I'm sorry that, you know, that was her, and I'm sorry that she couldn't deal with it. It had been. It would have been nice to be able to talk to her. I'm very glad that she had Ms. Fedetto in her life, and I'm glad that she kept me. One of the times when my rear end was on TV because I was being arrested, she said, well, I'm so glad that people couldn't recognize you and your name wasn't in the paper. I said, yes, mother, and I will defend to the death your right to your whatevers, but I certainly don't approve. So she didn't understand me.
Peter McDermott [01:03:02] When was the last time you saw her?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [01:03:05] When she died.
Peter McDermott [01:03:08] When was that?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [01:03:14] It's been a long time. Let's see, 18, maybe 18 years ago. It's been a while. '83, maybe '84. May she- My mother did not feel just like with me. She did not tell the doctors what she didn't think they needed to know. So when they opened her up, he said, it's too late. There's nothing I can do. She was full of cancer. So. And health care being what it is, at the point where the hospital says, we can no longer, you're not going to get any better. The hospital has to throw you out. So, you know, we went to see her on Memorial Day, Mickey and I did, anyways, and they said, you know, she's got to go. And we said, like, when? And they said, like, as soon as possible. And we made our rounds of nursing homes, which is a dispiriting thing to do. We did find a place. It was Manor Care on Lorain Avenue, which is under new management now, but at that time, cancer patients. And it was clean and everybody was nice. And because she was terminal, you could visit 24/7. And mainly she was in her coma, but she would come out. But she didn't know who we were anymore. So.
Peter McDermott [01:05:04] Are your stepfothers still alive?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [01:05:07] Terry is retired from the Navy. He lives in California. Ronnie is retired from the Navy, but Terry is more like me. Ronnie was. I can't say this, anyway, now he's had a stick up his butt, and he kept everything inside. And his- in Christmas of December of 1999, his whole department was pink slipped. And Washington State, where he was living, is like Ohio. It's an at will. You can be here today and you're gone tomorrow. No explanation. And. His wife can't balance a checkbook. So he pretty much kept everything to himself, told her everything would be fine. And within about five months, he had a massive heart attack. So he's deceased now, but my other three sisters and brother they're all around Ron, Ed, Jack is Tom's age. I think they're two weeks apart, much to my mother's unhappiness.
Peter McDermott [01:06:30] Have you had a chance to go back to Cogswell Hall?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [01:06:33] I went back when they had their first party here a couple years ago when Diane became director, when they were doing the search for a director. A woman I worked with at Welcome House I thought would be perfect. She'd had a lot of years with the group home, but she decided it wasn't something she really wanted. She went through the interview process because I think one of Mickey's husband's sister in laws was on the board. And I have no idea if she's still on the board because I don't know. But she had asked if I was interested. I was like, no, I have my own house. And. But Mardell wasn't interested. And then I just pretty much didn't think anything about it. And then at some point someone said, did I know Diane had become the director there? I was like, oh, wow. So it's been, I think three years now since they had the big party, the first big party. And I went back then.
Peter McDermott [01:07:39] What was it like coming back?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [01:07:42] You know, a lot has not changed. I mean, they made, you know, they got the elevator and the reception room is now an office, But basically it's the same. And it was like, wow. One of the few things that hasn't changed, you know, it was something else. It was a weird feeling too. I told my kids, I was like, wow. I've never been back to Jones Home. I've thought about it, but just never, you know, they've built the cottages. They didn't have cottages when I was there. That was all trees and there was a dairy dill in the corner and stuff like that. I can't remember five minutes ago, but I can remember some of this other stuff. It's amazing. But, yeah, I think, you know, all things being equal, it's okay. They say that that doesn't break you will make you stronger. I'm not sure about that. My mother used to say, adversity builds character.
Peter McDermott [01:09:03] Well, I have no more questions for you.
[unknown speaker] [01:09:10] I actually didn't really have any major questions. Could you just- how do you spell Mrs. Fedetto? Do you remember? You know?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [01:09:17] I never knew. I would never have had a reason to know. I remember. I remember seeing it, but I can't visualize it because it was a nameplate on her desk. Not a clue.
[unknown speaker] [01:09:42] But after you left, you never ran into her or, I mean, Other than maybe running into Joy or Helen. I mean, once you were with your mother, you were.
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [01:09:55] We ran into once when we were walking on Franklin and my mother asked me to stand back and she and Mrs. Fedetto, Ms. Fedetto had a conversation and I got a hug and I don't, you know, I don't know. Don't know anything beyond that.
[unknown speaker] [01:10:19] And just because I'm not sure. You said on the corner of 73rd there was a fishers store. Was that a grocery store?
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [01:10:25] Mm. Yeah. What is now Tops I think, it's been through a lot of names. That was the butcher there used to- see when I was there, when I was one of the first welfare mothers that live in this. This area. I mean, when I would go to the churches, I went to St. Luke's and it was like those people didn't have a clue. And then they came to church on Sunday because they'd always gone to church on Sunday. And then they went home and had their roast. And they were mainly an older congregation. And once we started welfare rights, we wanted to have activities in this, you know, the big gym, wanted to have a rummage sale. And they were really horrified to think that the building would open any other day but Sunday morning. They did eventually come around to having a pantry. Well, people ask for food, they don't really need it. It's like, well, maybe they have an emotional need for it. And if one out of ten asks for food and that one doesn't really physically need it, it's okay.
Peter McDermott [01:11:52] I'm wondering if, how your experiences growing up in a rather turbulent family situation, how that impacted, if at all, the way that you raised your children or at any point when you were sitting single one or with your children. Do you ever feel like you were like you would come back, not like repeating your mother's life, but in a way, did you feel like. I'm not sure how-
[unknown speaker] Or did you at any point feel like a conscious. Like, I need to make sure that I don't repeat. Like, was that.
Shelbey Holmes-Reyes [01:12:27] Well, there's two parts to that. My- the children's father of those 10 children that his mother had, most of them wound up at Parmadale one time or another. So there was two things that I was determined. Three things really. One, I would raise my children. And two, there would be no corporal punishment. And three, they weren't going to scuffle like I did. They would get an education. My mother in law would recount tales about the boys taking candy bars or doing this or doing that, and she thought it was cute. And I didn't. And when it would come to my attention sometimes that somebody had money or gum or something they had no way to have, I marched my kids back to wherever and pointed out to the storekeeper, the A and P guy across from Watterson at that time, because Tom and Lincoln and Mark and Chris, I think were taking pop bottles from behind A and P and bringing them in the front door and cashing them in. And a teacher at Watterson said, you know, they have way too much candy. And I'm like, no, they don't. So I marched them back and I pointed out to the guy, I guess the grocer, that if these kids ever come in here without a note from me with money, you better look at your pop bottles. Because it just, it wasn't going to happen. My mother in law thought I was overly strict, so. But one time when one of their uncles, when they lived where University Restaurant is, there used to be an apartment building there and a hot rodder garage next to the building and it was a four-suiter and Bert went in the next door suite, took the keys off the dresser and he was just a little kid, 14 maybe, took the keys off the dresser and stole the guy's car. Got as far as North Carolina. My mother in law's attitude about that was they shouldn't have the keys where he could get them. So I'm serious. I was at juvenile court when she said that. And the guy looked at me and he said, oh, so are you raising another generation to come through here? I said, my kids will never come through here. Those were things. So that's partly from them and partly from my life that, you know, their uncles went into service but then got themselves right back out. Mommy got them back out. So they've always been told that if you start it, you will finish it. So that makes me strict. I'm strict. That's it. Well, I hope that-
History 304: Urban History
These course-based oral histories arose from the CSU Department of History collaboration with Greater Cleveland Regional Transit Authority, Cleveland Public Art, and WCPN/WVIZ (ideastream). Interviews in this collection were conducted by students in U.S. Urban History (HIS 304) at Cleveland State University Department of History, supervised by professors Mark Tebeau and Mark Souther. Originally intended to inform the creation of public art along the RTA’s Healthline BRT route, these interviews…