Gerald Hughes interview, 21 June 2013
Abstract
Gerald Hughes is from Lancaster, Pennsylvania. He grew up in a town that was majority white. He went to a Mennonite school in Indiana and through a volunteer program gained his first experience in the city of Cleveland. He initially hoped to work in the steel mills but they were on strike when he arrived in the city. Hughes was not fond of his first trip to Cleveland as it was a cold, wet day in March. His wife worked at Standard Oil and when he first moved to the area he moved by the place he could continue to carry out his church volunteer program, in the Mt. Pleasant area. He was a music major, became an educator and an administrator in the Cleveland Public School System. He was around the Mt. Pleasant area to witness white flight, then moved to the Cleveland Heights area, only to watch his neighborhood go from integrated to predominantly black again. He remained in the public school system at Sowinski (no longer in existence) and Harvey Rice. He witnessed the Polish community change to black in around Sowinski and later went to the predominantly black school, Harvey Rice. He was an administrator during desegregation of the Public School System. He completed a follow-up interview due to equipment failure: see interview 990040.
Metadata
Interview Transcript
Transcripts may contain errors.
Gerald Hughes [00:00:02] Good afternoon.
Timothy Klypchak [00:00:05] Today is June 21st, 2013. My name is Timothy Klypchak, and I am interviewing Gerald Hughes. Could you please state your name for the record?
Gerald Hughes [00:00:18] Gerald, middle initial L, Hughes, H-U-G-H-E-S.
Timothy Klypchak [00:00:22] And where were you born?
Gerald Hughes [00:00:24] I was born in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.
Timothy Klypchak [00:00:27] How long did you stay in Philadelphia?
Gerald Hughes [00:00:30] Just about 10 years.
Timothy Klypchak [00:00:32] And from Philadelphia, where did you go?
Gerald Hughes [00:00:34] To a rural area near Lancaster, Pennsylvania.
Timothy Klypchak [00:00:38] And how long did you live in Lancaster?
Gerald Hughes [00:00:39] Lancaster?
Timothy Klypchak [00:00:40] Lancaster.
Gerald Hughes [00:00:41] Yeah, Lancaster. Actually, it wasn't in Lancaster City, it was out in the country, in Lancaster County, actually. I was there until I was 18 and went to college.
Timothy Klypchak [00:00:55] What school did you attend during, while living in Lancaster?
Gerald Hughes [00:01:01] It was called SLANCO, Southern Lancaster County High School.
Timothy Klypchak [00:01:09] What was it like going to high school?
Gerald Hughes [00:01:12] Well, I enjoyed it. It wasn't a big school. In fact, I graduated from there, but before that, I went to West Valleyfield High School, and I took 3 years, then they consolidated a number of districts there. West Valleyfield was very small, and they consolidated a number of districts. That was my first, the first year that it was consolidated, so it wasn't, it seemed to be large, but a bunch of us were strangers to the school. We didn't go there 4 years, actually graduated from there after 1 year.
Timothy Klypchak [00:01:41] What do you remember about living in Lancaster?
Gerald Hughes [00:01:46] Well, we were living with— my parents had separated, and we were actually living with some relatives. And I loved it. It was a rural area, rural living, Amish country, Pennsylvania Dutch country. I learned a lot there. I just loved it, this rural America. What was your favorite thing about living there? Eastern Pennsylvania.
Timothy Klypchak [00:02:14] What did you do for fun, or places— what were some places you hung out?
Gerald Hughes [00:02:19] Well, I guess in that area you didn't think much about hanging out. You— some of the things around work, some of them around church, some are just things that you did in school. I started working when I was about 14. Always had a job. Mainly with farmers. We just had friends. We walked a lot. We didn't have a car in our family. We were very poor, relatively poor anyhow. We had plenty of food and plenty of love, but not a lot of extra things like that. But I had friends who had cars and we would go places and do things together. Mainly just, I enjoyed, I took, I was actually a major, not major, but took an agricultural course in high school. It was available and it was an interesting, interesting thing to do, which meant that we got out a little past the classroom into projects and so on. But as I said, the school was small enough that you knew everybody and everybody knew you. Even the large school which I graduated from, with the last year— it wasn't my first year there, but my senior year, you still knew a lot of people. I rode 12 miles to school on the bus.
Timothy Klypchak [00:03:47] Where did you go to college?
Gerald Hughes [00:03:48] Goshen College in Indiana. A small denominational school, a Mennonite school. I went there 4 years, graduated in five years. I was a music major. So I graduated from there after 5 years at Goshen College.
Timothy Klypchak [00:04:11] From there, where did you go?
Gerald Hughes [00:04:13] I came to Cleveland. I came, I had come a couple of summers and worked under the denominational program, which was called Voluntary Service.
Timothy Klypchak [00:04:21] Right.
Gerald Hughes [00:04:22] And so I was acquainted with Kean. I worked downtown at what was then called the Gladstone area, around 55th and Woodland, 55th and Kinsman, in that corner there between— and mainly the area, which is not there anymore, was industrialized. So that's no longer there, but that was where I started. I came there and worked actually three summers total in voluntary service, although a couple years I had a little better voluntary service because I had to have a salary. I came to Cleveland originally to work in a steel mill, make some money, and contribute to that church's program. That summer I got here and there was a steel strike, so that took care of making money in the steel industry that summer, but I stayed and worked in that program. So I was there. During that time. That's what brought me to Cleveland actually.
Timothy Klypchak [00:05:20] The few summers that you came to Cleveland, around what year was that?
Gerald Hughes [00:05:24] I graduated in '54, so it was '53, '52, '51.
Timothy Klypchak [00:05:30] Can you tell me some of the experiences you had coming to Cleveland for the summers with people?
Gerald Hughes [00:05:36] Well, it was a different experience. When I first— the first time I came to Cleveland I came away, the college choir was on tour, one of the college choirs, and I sang in it. And we, our pastor, present pastor, was born out in Aurora, Ohio, and their church actually started the church down there, which I came associated with. And it was my first experience in, although I'd been born and raised for a number of years in the inner city in Philadelphia, my first experience in an inner city in a place like Cleveland. I have always told the story that the first time I was here, some people— there were some people from my college who were from Aurora, where the pastor was from, and they made a connection and wanted me to come. And I came in March. It was raining, it was kind of cold, wet March day in Cleveland, and I did not intend to come back. But I got convinced to come back, of course, enticed by a job. They also had a large, what they called a voluntary service unit, worked there in the summers. We worked in the community and did a lot of things. That's what got me into Cleveland and kept me here. We spent a lot of time in that, what was called the Gladstone community. It was kind of a, definitely a community, mainly predominantly black, most of them southern background. Just a very closely knit community of people who— you weren't a stranger after a while, you were there for a while. And I was very attracted to it, I kept coming back every summer.
Timothy Klypchak [00:07:25] Where was the community at?
Gerald Hughes [00:07:28] In the intersection on the southwest corner of East 55th and Woodland. East 55th and Kinsman. It stretched from Cleveland, from 55th to about 40— 42nd Street, or about 40th Street, perhaps. Mainly men, the people who we associated with were right there in that community, although we did get across the street on the other side to the projects, Hathaway Homes. CMHA area too. Mainly it was just community service-type kind of things.
Timothy Klypchak [00:08:06] Okay. So you yourself are what religion?
Gerald Hughes [00:08:13] Mennonite.
Timothy Klypchak [00:08:14] Mennonite? And so when did you ultimately decide that Cleveland was the place you wanted to live?
Gerald Hughes [00:08:21] Well, I stayed here and then I stayed a year beyond. I had a term of service. And I stayed a year beyond that. That church, which had been established there, it was kind of a mission church, moved because the area was going to be rezoned. And I agreed to stay there and kind of maintain the programs we had going there while the people who were— the pastor and so on— moved to a new location. So I was there for a year. I started substitute teaching just to add to my income, because by the time I was married then, Mm-hmm. Married in '54. Married in '54. And my wife worked at Standard Oil Company downtown, the main office. I started substitute teaching and I liked it. And actually, I was a music major. I was planning originally to teach high school music, but there I changed and I was substituting as an elementary school teacher. I went to Kent nights and got a certificate in one year, and then after that, I started teaching in Cleveland as an elementary schoolteacher.
Timothy Klypchak [00:09:33] Was the schoolteacher the only occupation you held, or was there other things that you did as well here?
Gerald Hughes [00:09:40] Well, mainly, I was a teacher. I was a teacher after I got out of the church program, which I had a salary— I was salaried there for about a year. But then I went to start substitute teaching and still worked in that church program. And then I started substitute— I started teaching was my only profession then, from then on.
Timothy Klypchak [00:10:05] So where did you move to when you moved to Cleveland initially?
Gerald Hughes [00:10:08] Initially, we lived right where the church program was. So we lived right there in that 55th Street area for the years, and then we were married there. I married there and lived there, too. Then after that, we moved to Mount Pleasant, 153rd Street first, then east to 154th Street, right off of Kinsman in a two-family house. In a two-family house, renting.
Timothy Klypchak [00:10:43] What was the neighborhood in Mount Pleasant like?
Gerald Hughes [00:10:47] When we moved there, it was a very fairly stable community. It would be— might be called the lower middle class. There were a number of white families still there, but it was predominantly increasingly Black-occupied. Two-family houses, a lot of them. When we first moved there, there were a lot of people who were working, and that diminished after over a period of time, relatively rapidly in some ways. The schools were, I guess I would call them relatively very good. As I said, it was a big city. Increasingly realized that white migration out was building up in momentum very rapidly, until it became almost solid Black community.
Timothy Klypchak [00:11:44] What year was it that you moved to the Mount Pleasant area?
Gerald Hughes [00:11:46] I'm trying to remember specifically what year it was. Must have been about— this is not accurate— In the '60s, early '60s.
Timothy Klypchak [00:12:05] How long did you stay in the Mount Pleasant area?
Gerald Hughes [00:12:07] That's what I'm trying to estimate. I think about 8 years, maybe.
Timothy Klypchak [00:12:14] And from there, where did you move to?
Gerald Hughes [00:12:16] We came to Cleveland Heights in 1969.
Timothy Klypchak [00:12:21] Was it this house that you moved to?
Gerald Hughes [00:12:22] Yeah. So we've been living in this house since 1969.
Timothy Klypchak [00:12:27] Can you— what was it like teaching in the Cleveland schools?
Gerald Hughes [00:12:33] Well, I was— I loved doing it. In that particular area, it was a challenge in some ways because of the poverty level, family— families, not stable families, and so on. At that time, it was different than it is now. We did have— the schools were not integrated in no way. The main young people on the east side were mostly in the black schools on the east side, and the white schools were on the west side. My school where I taught for eight years, nine years actually, was right in the middle of CMHA, Outhwaite Homes. In fact, the school was named Outhwaite. Near the Outhwaite Homes was on Outhwaite Avenue. It was later changed to Alfred A. Benesch School when they built a new school. It was an old building. Closely knit faculty. You got to know the community because you were right in the middle of it. And then this was with a high poverty level. CMHA project, almost all of our students came from— we were right next to East Tech High School and Kennard Junior High. It was a large school, but very well run. Part of the credit goes to a principal who was very effective and efficient, and part of the credit goes to the fact that we were in a close, closely knit community, which you had contacts with and had access to. And the way that we— I say we because that principal - his name was Elsie Brown - some way had us work together as a unit, and I enjoyed it. It was challenging, not always easy, large classrooms, uh, children who didn't have very much going for them when they came, good faculty, and I saw good faculty. integrated faculty. But it's an old building, but it was a very good experience. I enjoyed it.
Timothy Klypchak [00:14:49] Did you have any experiences with overcrowding in the school?
Gerald Hughes [00:14:55] That's an interesting question. Now, that school would have been very much overcrowded. I had as many as 40 kids in one class at one time when I was teaching 6th grade. That is overcrowding, no question about it, but it was manageable in that setting because of the way that it was handled. I'm trying to think, my classes, that's all, over those years I would imagine I taught 4th grade and 6th grade. Most of the time I was in 6th grade. In fact, I taught special ed class one year, which I, again, it was a challenge, but I enjoyed it. Yeah, there were classes, the school was overcrowded.
Timothy Klypchak [00:15:48] Were there any schools that were close to the area that weren't overcrowded that brought up the issue as to Was there a reason why the school was overcrowded?
Gerald Hughes [00:15:58] Not really in that immediate area, because our location was right in the middle of the projects. So the children could walk to school, and it was part of the community. As I said, East Tech High School was right there, within walking distance. Kennard Junior High was right there within walking distance. So these children, many of them who came to the projects as small children, would start and go through literally 12 years. of the same kind of environment in the same setting knew each other, which I used the word close-knit community as the strength of that area. So this carried over into the classroom. There were difficulties, there were all kinds of difficulties, hungry children, broken families, criminal activity around the area. But relatively, I guess you would say then, you considered it a safe place. Relatively safe in terms of, if you relate that to what goes on today, that school was relatively safe because they were seen as an integral part of the community, and the community was interested in keeping it safe.
Timothy Klypchak [00:17:12] Can you tell me some of the experiences that stick out to you as when you were a teacher there, either at the school, in the community, or anything like that?
Gerald Hughes [00:17:26] It's hard to think of a specific one because we had actually, we had a lot of access to homes. It wasn't unusual for us as teachers to visit homes in there, and you felt relatively safe because you were part of the community. Again, community was safe, but there are times when, when I've been threatened by adult individuals, by high school, high school-aged youngsters. The one thing we had going for us, everybody knew everybody, and so you— they knew you were threatening part of the community. It's hard to single out. I know one very positive thing was, we got tied up into a camping program one time, and I took my class out to Hiram House Camp for 10 days in the summer. No, during the school year. It was a funded program. That was the most positive program I think they had. Because you've got the children away from this environment completely. Their only contact— excuse me, pardon me— their only contact was me as a teacher. There were 4 different schools, two on the West Side, one of which was a Catholic school, and three other schools. The children were in a completely different environment and had to modify their first experience with the world. outside the community. Most of them didn't get out of the community very often, so sometimes we'd take our own initiative and arrange things, which we could, if possible, to enhance their experience and their learning.
Timothy Klypchak [00:19:13] How long did you teach there?
Gerald Hughes [00:19:15] Nine years. As I said, I taught for— I started as the 4th grade teacher, and then because they needed a male, I went to a special education class for two years, then I taught 6th grade for, I guess, about six years.
Timothy Klypchak [00:19:32] And where did you go to after that?
Gerald Hughes [00:19:35] I went to what was then called an intern program, but it was— I was an assistant principal without certification at Sowinski School, between 79th and Superior and Saint Clair. Sowinski Elementary School. I was there for a year, pardon me, as a— they call it intern, pardon me, intern program, sort of master teacher program. But in effect, the school was so large, that was a very crowded school, I ended up being the administrator. And that was one year, and then the next year I went to Crispus Attucks, which was right in the middle of the Hough area. That was during the Hough riot days and so on. I was there for a year, and then I received a grant to go to graduate school.
Timothy Klypchak [00:20:33] Can you tell me a little bit more about the school in the Hough area?
Gerald Hughes [00:20:42] Well, it wasn't, it wasn't in the Hough area, it was just outside of the Hough area.
Timothy Klypchak [00:20:45] Oh, okay.
Gerald Hughes [00:20:46] On the other side. The Hough area generally started with Superior going south. This was, this was Superior, between Superior and St. Clair. It was a Polish community basically, Sowinski, right, between Sowinski Avenue and Pulaski Avenue. And there was this tension, this racial tension was very high there because the school had been predominantly Polish. And because of the shifting of populations and so on, it was changing very rapidly. And there was a lot of volatility. There was what's called the Sowinski Riots. I can't even remember the name of the Sowinski Riots. There was a notable one incident there which happened. I can't think of the name of it. The Sowinsko Riots. You know, the one episode of rioting there, which was very, very violent, and you had to contend with the animosity between the two races while you were there. The Polish people felt their, the encroachment of the Black population from the Hough area was moving in, and they felt harassed. Sometimes they were literally— I found myself in a position of being between the two factions, right on the school grounds. So you spent a lot of time dealing with that.
Timothy Klypchak [00:22:12] So it impacted the lives of the children?
Gerald Hughes [00:22:15] Oh, actually, yes. There was fear, and yet at the same time there was defiance. Conflict, instances where I had to act as a reconciliator, as a go-between between two factions. And as I said, the crew was very crowded. The population was changing and all that goes along with that. What was the most difficult part of your job? And yet I think we did a relatively— classes were crowded— a relatively good job of educating at that level. Again, we had a mixed faculty, integrated faculty. Principal in all three of these schools was a white, and I was the black male presence, which made some difference in the community.
Timothy Klypchak [00:23:21] Was the population of the school integrated or slightly?
Gerald Hughes [00:23:26] It was, but it became increasingly, over a period of time, increasingly black. The Polish community and the white community was moving out or going to Catholic school, and the Black community was moving in, in numbers. So the school was changing to predominantly Black.
Timothy Klypchak [00:23:46] What was it like leading up to the riot that was in the neighborhood?
Gerald Hughes [00:23:53] Well, it was just, it was related to the Hough riots. Just a lot of tension, mainly among the young kids. A lot of fear. Sometimes you'd have to deal with rumors which were floating around about this is going to happen, that's going to happen, which sometimes did happen, sometimes did not happen, but you always had to be alert to it and aware of it. So you found yourself in the role of not only teaching the kids, but also protecting them. Even kids which liked you, dealt with each other very well in the classroom and in activities at school, had to go back to their district at home and live with fears and attitudes which were negative to that which was going on in the school. School had a very positive atmosphere.
Timothy Klypchak [00:24:41] What were some of the rumors that would become true, or some of the rumors that were completely false?
Gerald Hughes [00:24:50] Well, predictions of certain negative activities by one group or another. Either on the way home from school, there's going to be a riot, there's going to be a fight, or don't you dare come across here. And so sometimes I, myself personally, would walk, spend a lot of time at dismissal time walking the streets, just trying to maintain and keeping children going home and not confronting each other.
Timothy Klypchak [00:25:23] Did you ever encounter any issues while you were walking the streets yourself?
Gerald Hughes [00:25:30] Yes, it's hard to quantify them. Some were very minor incidents. Others could have escalated into major things. When I say major, just factions are fighting. There are a number— I remember certainly a couple occasions, literally, because of rumors, rumors had been generated in the community. Walked out into the schoolyard, and on one side of the south side of the street were parents and some adults from the Black community. And on the other side of the street, other side of the playground, parents and adults from the Polish community were there and taunting each other. So there's always a volatile setting, and not necessarily— didn't always come to fruition, but it was always there.
Timothy Klypchak [00:26:22] And were you still at the school after the riots happened?
Gerald Hughes [00:26:28] Well, the riots were— Hough riots were— I think it happened just before I got there. I think, I think that's true. The Hough riots were— happened before these Sowinski riots and so on. But we did go— It's difficult, my memory. Chronologically, sorry, I got mixed up a bit.
Timothy Klypchak [00:26:52] That's fine.
Gerald Hughes [00:27:03] I remember one incident which I'd heard about, and parents were coming to the school to take the children, calling the school, wanted to take the children home. They said there was going to be a big riot. So finally I called the city, the school board, the Board of Education security office. and also had some ties in with the police department. I called— I can't even remember his name or anything, a lieutenant, and he said that he'd heard these rumors too. And the one which could have been very volatile, which wasn't, as I left the school, I walked some of the kids who were going south about two blocks, a block and a half from the school, and here was a large group of of black males who were marching down the street. And about— I knew behind me were a large group of Polish males who were coming, high school-aged kids and so on. And I remember getting between them, and they knew me. I remember getting between them and asked the leaders, sort of who the leaders of both groups were. And talked to them and explained to them that I was going to stay there and I had already called the police. Detective, the one detective, a juvenile detective did show up, maybe two of them, and we didn't know what to do. So we just stood there in the street and we let them know that we were going to be here until everybody leaves. And they had— they didn't have to leave in the same direction. They both left in different directions. That was a scary moment. But some of these activities went on at night and we weren't there. Again, I saw it mainly as a challenge that needed to be addressed in service, and I was in a way pleased that I was able to be of service there, deal with, deal with the setting and get people talking to each other and relating to each other in a positive way, because it was happening in the schools, but outside of the school you always had to keep, keep everything contained.
Timothy Klypchak [00:29:20] And the other set of riots, were you there to witness them, or were they there— did they happen while you were at that school?
Gerald Hughes [00:29:31] We didn't have any very, very, very many. There were instances of fights and so on, but nothing of what we call the riot stage at the school during school hours. But it's always— potentially could have happened. We were always alert and aware of it. The people in the community who would call us once in a while and let us know that this, this was brewing or this was brewing, we would always follow up on it and I think that kind of kept the peace.
Timothy Klypchak [00:29:56] Were there ever any threats to the school specifically?
Gerald Hughes [00:30:01] Mainly from individuals. There was one firebombing. No, I take it back. That was not at UNC. That was at my last school. Yes, it was. I was promoted then after I went to graduate school. I went to University of Pittsburgh under a grant, and I came there. So I was actually— I commuted to— commuted to the same year I bought this house. I bought the house and, and got the grant in that order. I was going to rent the house and go there. My wife said, no, we gotta— finally got a house there, we're gonna stay here. So it was in '69. I went to Pitt, to Pitt, with two other individuals from the Cleveland school system who were assistant principals. We commuted, went on Monday and came back on Friday. Then the following year, I was part of the program out of Cleveland State University with the Department of Education. I was assistant principal at East High School, which was close to where our kids from St. Vincent de Paul School went. And then I was— came back to— that one year there, then I came back to Sowinski as a year as assistant principal, then I was promoted to principal there. So that was after '69.
Timothy Klypchak [00:31:37] I want to get this question out of the way before I come back to all: Did you ever substitute on the West Side?
Gerald Hughes [00:31:46] I'm trying to— not much. I substituted for a year while I, when I was studying at Kent and still working the church program, I substituted that year. Most of the schools were on the East Side because it's closed.
Timothy Klypchak [00:32:02] So did you go to the Did you go to the West Side often, or any?
Gerald Hughes [00:32:11] Yes, I went to the West Side. In fact, Paul Briggs, who was superintendent at one point, when I was introduced to him, he asked me if I would go to a school on the West Side. That was when the desegregation program was going on, and they were desperately filling courts. And I told him, yeah, I didn't want to go, but I would. I remember he laughed about it. But he didn't assign me. So I told him I was willing to go.
Timothy Klypchak [00:32:43] After you did your graduate program in Pitt and then Cleveland State, what was it like at East High School?
Gerald Hughes [00:32:55] Again, East High School was a very large school, predominantly black. Well governed. Leon Pryor was the principal at the time. It was, as far as with the sociological problems which dealt with the community, it was a difficult setting. But again, I had a faculty by and large who was committed to accepting the challenge and working with it. So we dealt with poverty, we dealt with anger, we dealt with violence, pregnancies on the part of girls, young girls, hostile parents once in a while.
Racial Integration in the Heights
Interviews in this series were collected by undergraduate students at Cleveland State University under the supervision of Dr. Mark Souther, with funding from the Office of the Provost. The series contains interviews with pioneers of suburban residential integration and social activists who supported peaceful managed integration/desegregation and fair housing in Cleveland Heights and Shaker Heights in the 1950s to 1970s.