Bonnie Flinner interview, 17 October 2015

Interview recorded during Prosperity Social Club 10 year anniversary event.
Bonnie Flinner talks about her acquisition of the pub in 2005, her growing relationship with the Dembowski family and the Tremont neighborhood, and what she’s learned (and come to love) about managing a restaurant.

Participants: Flinner, Bonnie (interviewee) / Roy, Christopher (interviewer)
Collection: Prosperity Social Club 10 Year Anniversary Event
Institutional Repository: Cleveland Regional Oral History Collection

Interview Transcript

Transcripts may contain errors.

Bonnie Flinner [00:00:00] Okay.

Chris Roy [00:00:01] All right, we are headed into the third interview of this afternoon. This is Chris Roy. I am a volunteer for Cleveland State University's Department of Public History and Digital Humanities. It's October 17th, and we are proud to be interviewing, interviewing with a, Bonnie Flinner, who has for the last 10 years been the owner of the self named Prosperity Social Club.

Bonnie Flinner [00:00:33] Yes.

Chris Roy [00:00:33] And I guess as we were talking about just before the mic went live, you were explaining to us in lucid detail why are we here.

Bonnie Flinner [00:00:43] Well, Chris, my name is Bonnie Flinner, and we are here today to celebrate my anniversary of Prosperity Social Club being 10 years old. And we're also combining our celebration with a tribute to the history of the building and the neighborhood by welcoming the Dembowski family, who ran Dempsey's Oasis in this building prior to it becoming Prosperity Social Club under my ownership. The Dembowskis ran owned and ran Dempsey's Oasis from 1938 It's not necessarily the most relevant part of the interview, but the Dembowskis were not clear on the name of the people who owned it for the interim period between 2000 and 2005.

Chris Roy [00:01:20] Can you fill us in on that?

Bonnie Flinner [00:01:46] The Dembowskis sold their business in 2000 to the Gillespie brothers. And they are local brothers and they are property owners throughout Cleveland. They have some very significant property in Ohio City and downtown. And they owned Dempsey's Oasis from 2000 until 2005 when I purchased it from them. Their intent of the business was basically to keep it sort of as their own private clubhouse. They had limited hours, limited staff. They did a lot of fundraising for politicians and things like that. So it was a location of convenience for them. It really wasn't run like a serious business. And one of the three brothers wanted his portion of the financial benefit out of the property so that he could purchase and run his own business on his own, which he ended up creating the Map Room in downtown Cleveland. And so that was the motivation for them to sell this. There was some tension between the brothers, and because they had a buyer on the line, which was me, They went through with the process and I ended up with the property and the business in 2005.

Chris Roy [00:03:21] Okay, so let's set the stage now. It's 2005. If I'm remembering correctly, Bonnie is happy working for Brendan Ring at Nighttown.

Bonnie Flinner [00:03:30] Good memory.

Chris Roy [00:03:31] Everybody knows Brendan.

Bonnie Flinner [00:03:34] Yes.

Chris Roy [00:03:35] Somewhere Bonnie evolved from working at Nighttown to be- You ended up becoming the proud owner of a at that time, 75-year-old Polish bar in the heart of Tremont.

Bonnie Flinner [00:03:52] Correct.

Chris Roy [00:03:53] How did that evolution?

Bonnie Flinner [00:03:55] Well, I think it was kind of meant to be. Destiny. Destiny. It was my destiny. I grew up in a Hungarian restaurant. My Polish aunt married a Hungarian chef named Johnny Tar. They opened the Bitter Budapest in Parma Heights from 1962 to 1986. I grew up there. I went to college. I had a real job that didn't pay a lot after college, and I started working for Brendan at Nighttown, which ended up supposedly being a part-time job, and I spent 12 years there. So after 12 years working for a really great Irish barman. There was really nothing else I knew how to do, so I had to find my own place. And I had actually— the first time I was ever in the Dempsey's Oasis building was when the Gillespie brothers were buying it from the Dembowskis. The Dembowskis were having an estate sale on the second floor in the apartment selling the items that were left here, and I attended the estate sale and bought some items, and that was the first time I was ever in the barroom and thought what a great place it was. And 5 years later, I ended up purchasing it.

Chris Roy [00:05:19] Do you recall a little pang?

Bonnie Flinner [00:05:22] Yes.

Chris Roy [00:05:23] An awful lot of people who work in restaurants somehow have this deep seated hunger to try it themselves. Do you think of yourself as one of those people?

Bonnie Flinner [00:05:35] Yes, I it was a vision that I had for a really long time. I very much love this type of bar, the camaraderie, the old-school feel, the neighborhood feel where everything happens at your local pub, you know. You laugh, you cry, you come there to celebrate, you come here to get courage, you celebrate weddings, funerals, you know, bar mitzvahs, whatever. Everybody comes to the local spot. And I've always had an affinity for that growing up in the Hungarian restaurant that I did grow up in. And when I came into this building, I knew immediately that it had a soul. And that's something that you can't fabricate, you can't recreate that, and it just comes with all the layers of history that has happened here. And when you walk in, you immediately feel that this place is different, and that's what attracted me to it because the building itself has a soul, and you can feel the energy that's left here.

Chris Roy [00:06:49] I know what you mean, and I find myself wondering, well, what is that soul? Can you, how do you put your finger on what it is that provides that kind of attraction? We know it's real, but it's very difficult to say what that means. It's almost visceral.

Bonnie Flinner [00:07:08] It is. I don't know. It's something that the atmosphere or the building itself, the space sparks a memory, an emotion, something inside of you, and you just feel comfortable, okay, at ease.

Chris Roy [00:07:29] What were your first impressions? Well, you talked a little bit about how you were here for the sale, the second floor sale, and that would have been in 2000. In 2005, when you finally made the decision to do it, what do you recall going through your mind? Were you scared out of your wits? [00:07:56] Were you thinking, what the heck have I done? Or were you pumped to the point where no negative What feelings were allowed in?

Bonnie Flinner [00:08:07] I think it would be the last statement that you said. There was no room for any negative feelings or what-ifs or contemplations of if it didn't work. I had invested so much, everything I'd worked for. It was a very substantial sum of money that I had to come up with. Everything that I had worked for prior to that point, I had to collateralize. [00:08:37] I had no money left for myself, so it had only one option, and that option was to work. So there were no negative thoughts or obstacles. Every day was an obstacle, but you had to keep your eye on the prize and the path to get there. And so it had no choice. It had to work.

Chris Roy [00:09:03] What surprised you about owning a restaurant? Were there things that you discovered later that you had been either unrealistic about or had not thought about? Where were the surprises?

Bonnie Flinner [00:09:17] The surprises really came in the administration aspect, the paperwork, the legalities.

Chris Roy [00:09:26] The taxes.

Bonnie Flinner [00:09:28] The expenses that you don't see being a patron or being an employee. That was the most shocking part of it, and all the paperwork and the time that was needed in the office to really establish yourself as a real business and making policies and procedures. procedures, when really I just wanted to tend bar. [00:09:58] Right, right. And there's so much more work to that.

Chris Roy [00:10:03] Is it hard to have a life outside of the bar?

Bonnie Flinner [00:10:06] It's extremely hard. The people that come into your bar and your employees become your life. They become your family because everything revolves around opening and closing of the establishment.

Chris Roy [00:10:20] That's not necessarily a bad thing though, is it? When your work becomes your life, if it also includes a social component and a good friends and peers component.

Bonnie Flinner [00:10:34] Right, right.

Chris Roy [00:10:35] It's not like being an accountant who works 80 hours a week and that becomes his life. This is simply a blend of all of the good things that make up a life.

Bonnie Flinner [00:10:44] Right. No, I very much agree with that. I've been very blessed with having what I think are the best customers in Cleveland. I have the nicest people that I've met throughout the years that I've made connections with. And that, that when I look back over 10 years, I think that's, that's what makes all the paperwork worthwhile is, you know, the stories and the memories and the people you meet along the way.

Chris Roy [00:11:12] Alters your sleep patterns. So on balance then, how different has the overall experience been compared to what you may have expected when you first opened your doors?

Bonnie Flinner [00:11:26] It's definitely a lot harder than I expected, but the longer you do it, the easier it becomes. So there's an old saying, if you need something done, give it to the busiest person you know. And I feel that as You own a restaurant or a bar and you just keep rolling. You can handle more and more every day and your output is just— you have to act so quickly and you have dead— your deadlines come so fast that you have to just get things done as soon as they happen.

Chris Roy [00:12:02] You get good at it.

Bonnie Flinner [00:12:03] You get good at it, right.

Chris Roy [00:12:05] Even things that you didn't know you were going to have to get good at.

Bonnie Flinner [00:12:10] Exactly.

Chris Roy [00:12:10] You have an exceptionally good relationship with the Tremont community. You are known probably more than you even know you are known.

Bonnie Flinner [00:12:19] Okay. Bye, John. Nice to meet you. Thank you. Thanks for bringing your pictures.

Chris Roy [00:12:27] What does that connection with the community? I'm sure the community, that community connection means a lot to you. That would be kind of This is kind of a dumb question, but what has all what have all of those interactions helped you learn about Tremont as a community? What do you see as, you know, unique about it or special or how it blends with what's important to you?

Bonnie Flinner [00:12:50] I see 2 things about this neighborhood. I understand what a neighborhood is. Growing up in Strongsville on the outskirts of town, I did not live in a neighborhood. Currently I live in Fairview Park and that is not a neighborhood. Tremont is really a neighborhood. I, I know all the neighbors. I know their kids. I know their animals, their pets. They support each other. And they talk to each other. When I first opened, I had immediate support from other business owners, particularly women bar owners, and I had a lot of support from the immediate neighbors. They were very interested in what I was going to do here because this was their neighborhood. They wanted to check me out and make sure that I was okay. And if I wasn't okay, they were gonna let me know. And sometimes they did. They would let me know if they didn't like something I was doing, you know. And I had to respect that and maybe alter some things that I was doing because I came into their space and they had been here a long time. And they bond together and they support each other and they care about what goes on and they care about all the details happening around them. So learning about a neighborhood, not having grown up in one, I learned quickly about making everybody happy and making things work together. to please the over good, but keep please the overall good, but keep my vision going. So it had to be tempered sort of that way.

Chris Roy [00:14:55] When you started here in 2005, Tremont's momentum as a Renaissance community was pretty much underway. Still, I would imagine, I imagine you've observed a lot of changes in the neighborhood. Are there things that stand out for you both as a business owner and just as somebody who's involved in the community? What type of changes do you see? Are there ones you're concerned about versus positive about?

Bonnie Flinner [00:15:25] There's not many changes I'm concerned about. It's unfortunate as a community, you know, We change and we lose our interest in the past, and we lose our elders and the ethnic people that created this neighborhood. In the past year, I lost 2 of my neighbors who were in their late 70s and had lived here all their lives. And so as they leave, and their properties get renovated and people move in and pay $2,000 a month in rent, you know, that's kind of sad.

Chris Roy [00:16:12] Yes.

Bonnie Flinner [00:16:12] Because that, that's gone and that's never going to come back. Those people and their stories are not going to come back. But it's inevitable. That's the way the neighborhood has to progress.

Chris Roy [00:16:27] Okay.

Bonnie Flinner [00:16:27] There's only it's been that kind of progression that's been the success of Tremont, and I guess that's the best direction to go in. You don't want to see properties deteriorate. And then the growth of our neighboring communities, Ohio City and Detroit Shoreway, that was A little scary because there was a lot of new businesses going in and I didn't know how that was going to factor into my existence, if it was going to be competition or if it was going to be complementary. And it's turned out complementary to have successful neighborhoods bordering Tremont. And it just brings more people to all of our neighborhoods. And that makes it sustainable. Successful for each of our businesses to coexist together.

Chris Roy [00:17:27] Without filibustering, I think it's always been my opinion that Cleveland has always had somewhat of a rob Peter to pay Paul problem because the city itself has not been growing. Every time a neighborhood. Ahead, another neighborhood suffers. Look at the Flats versus the West District, for example. It's seemed to me in about the last 5 years that that paradigm is changing. A lot of it has to do with repatriation of people from the suburbs, and that folks are discovering the importance of neighborhoods. And this is a national trend, it's not just a local trend. City neighborhoods are hot right now. So I would imagine that you kind of feel like even though you've been here for 10 years that you may be on the cusp of a real change in how America looks at its residential preferences and patterns.

Bonnie Flinner [00:18:25] Yes.

Chris Roy [00:18:26] It has to be exciting for you.

Bonnie Flinner [00:18:29] It is exciting. And, you know, I would like to see Slavic Village you know, come back to life. And I'm very curious to see how all of the residential development in the Flats pans out. You know, those are big ideas and a lot of units to fill, and I hope that it works.

Chris Roy [00:18:57] Demographically speaking, it's interesting to note that We do have kind of a rising tide lifting all boats here, and that no longer is Tremont rising— that in order for Tremont to rise, Ohio City has to fall, or for the Warehouse District to stay stable, the Flats has to suffer.

Bonnie Flinner [00:19:16] Right, we're supporting each other. Exactly.

Chris Roy [00:19:19] So there's this level of mutual benefit and mutual optimism that I think is somewhat new, which creates Yeah, yeah, I can see that.

Bonnie Flinner [00:19:28] I haven't thought about that before, but I can, I can see that. I like that viewpoint.

Chris Roy [00:19:35] Cities are in a different stage of life from what they were 20 or 30 years ago, and you're part of that in a very unique and enviable way.

Bonnie Flinner [00:19:46] Well, that's great. I'm glad you think so.

Chris Roy [00:19:52] I would imagine you do, even if perhaps you're inclined to be hesitant. This is a good time to be where you are, where we are. I live in Tremont too.

Bonnie Flinner [00:20:01] Definitely, definitely. I'm, I'm very lucky to be here at this time and to have gotten to buy the property at the time that I did. Like I said, it was destiny, you know, and here I am. I never would have I never thought that really it's been 10 years and I've had the experiences and, you know, gratefully the success that I have, and I've enjoyed it, you know, so that's, that's a good part.

Chris Roy [00:20:32] You've done an exceptional job of honoring history in a modern establishment.

Bonnie Flinner [00:20:39] Thank you.

Chris Roy [00:20:40] And a lot of Tremont restaurateurs don't really have that opportunity. You can't take Lolita and give it the look of a dry cleaner.

Bonnie Flinner [00:20:55] Right.

Chris Roy [00:20:55] Or God knows, there's lots of examples. I don't even know what they are. You can't turn Parallax back to how it looked in 1940.

Bonnie Flinner [00:21:05] Right.

Chris Roy [00:21:05] Or whatever. But you've been faithful and You can say it's a theme, but it's not even really fair to call it a theme, is it?

Bonnie Flinner [00:21:12] It's simply what it is. What it is, right. Well, I do have to give the Gillespie brothers credit for not changing anything inside the barroom and the building. For whatever reason, they didn't do it. From when they bought it from the Dembowskis and then I bought it from them, it was still very much untouched. I guess you could say that they didn't ruin anything in that aspect. Yes, thank you for not ruining anything. Okay, a couple final things.

Chris Roy [00:21:43] Where do you? When you're tired of your own food, where do you go in Tremont?

Bonnie Flinner [00:21:47] Oh boy, I love Bock. That'll be number one. Um, I love the South Side. Uh, I love Sherman. I think he's a great bar owner. Um, and that, that's probably it. If I want to go for a drink, I'll go to Hotz's down the street. And those are my, those are my top. I wish I could go to Dante more often, but I don't think anybody can afford to go to Dante too often. No. And there's Sokolowski's too, so.

Chris Roy [00:22:17] Sure, when you want to get a taste of more or less your own food.

Bonnie Flinner [00:22:19] Right. But Bock right around the corner is, is a good little go to hideaway for me.

Chris Roy [00:22:25] As it is for us as well. Okay, final question. What would you be doing if you weren't doing this?

Bonnie Flinner [00:22:33] Boy, I don't know. That's a crazy question. I probably should have gone to law school, and if I would have gone to law school instead of art school, I probably wouldn't be even interviewing with you if I wasn't doing this.

Chris Roy [00:22:47] Is there a hidden passion somewhere, or have you discovered it?

Bonnie Flinner [00:22:50] Oh gosh, I think, I think I discovered it. I don't think there's anything I would want to I really, I wish I could bartend more, and if I ever didn't have the place to run, I would probably bartend for somebody else. I enjoy that. That is, to me, a lot of fun. It's social. I make money. And how, what better job to have than a job you go to, you have fun at, you're social, you meet people, and you walk home with, you know, some Benjamins in your pocket. your pocket. So this is really my passion. I love the restaurant business. And I love, in particular, this business. It turned out exactly how I wanted it to be, and that tickles me to no end that it became such a loved local place by the customers themselves. The customers are very protective of Prosperity Social Club. They're they want to know who the new employee is. They want to question them. They want to know, what did you do with my favorite dinner? You know, they're -it is- it's their place, and I love the fact that they come in and they take over.
Prosperity Social Club 10 Year Anniversary Event

Prosperity Social Club 10 Year Anniversary Event

Interviews in this series were collected by students and staff at Cleveland State University’s Center for Public History and Digital Humanities during the ten year anniversary celebration at Prosperity Social Club in the Tremont neighborhood of Cleveland, Ohio. The event featured a gathering of the Dembowski family, who ran Dempsey’s Oasis – a neighborhood pub at 1109 Starkweather Avenue that later became Prosperity Social Club – from 1938-2000. The series includes interviews with members of the…