James Duncan interview, 17 October 2015
Abstract
Interview recorded during Prosperity Social Club 10 year anniversary event.
Jim Duncan recounts his youth growing up in the Tremont projects, the changes he has witnessed in the neighborhood over the past half century, and working as a shoe shine at Dempsey's Oasis.
Metadata
Interview Transcript
Transcripts may contain errors.
James Duncan [00:00:13] Jim Duncan.
Rich Raponi [00:00:14] How long have you been in the neighborhood?
James Duncan [00:00:17] My family moved in the neighborhood in December of 1955. I was 4 months 4 years and 2 months, 3 months old. I could actually tell the address because we stayed in the same place until 1971. Moved into 623 Houston, Apartment I. That was in the Valley View Estates, they called them. We called them the projects.
Rich Raponi [00:00:48] Is that street still there?
James Duncan [00:00:53] No, no, it ran off of West 7th Hill. You know anything about West 7th?
Rich Raponi [00:00:58] I do not.
James Duncan [00:00:59] Okay, Starkweather, this street right here, that ends at West 7th. And from St. Olga going south, you're now entering the world of the projects. And West 7th, you made a right, and on the left-hand side of the street were the projects, all the way down the hill.
Rich Raponi [00:01:18] And could you describe the neighborhood?
James Duncan [00:01:20] It was ethnic. It was, well, it supported how many grade schools? It supported St. John Cantius, which was majority Polish, Our Lady of Mercy, which was Slovak, St. Augustine's, which was everybody, and St. Michael's, which was, I might, some kind of Slovenian also, Slovenian, Eastern European also.
Rich Raponi [00:01:42] But the neighborhood was mixed itself?
James Duncan [00:01:43] Oh, yes. It was our we lived in the projects. In 623 Apartment J, when we moved in, were the Lopez family, which were Mexicans. And this is 1955, okay? So it was easily integrated. The Meneses moved in in '58, George and Ada. And they were just— I mean, we just had some of the finest neighbors. They were African American. They moved— they were probably the second or third African American family who moved into the projects. And what kind of work was available? Like, what drew people to the area? Well, the steel mills were running big, but most of it see, that's why they were built for the people who worked in the mills. They built in '39, I think, '29 or '39, I don't remember. And that was for the people who worked in the steel mills. It was Jones and Laughlin Republic Steel. It didn't become until the '50s someplace where The men of the era could dump their children, wizened children, and run off. And that's basically what it was. It was just an emptying out of World War II vets cleaning out and then just emptying their families. I mean, when we moved in there in '54, '55, by '58, there weren't any males, adult males living with their families in that neighborhood.
Rich Raponi [00:03:06] Was it crowded?
James Duncan [00:03:07] Oh, well, there were seven of us in one apartment. I mean, it was a three-bedroom apartment. My brothers, my three brothers and I slept together for many, many years. It was a— do you know anything about the projects? They were long buildings. They were buildings that went 10 apartments in length from A to J, and others were from A to F. And they would have two-bedroom or three-bedroom apartments in each one of the buildings. Each building had a number of each. And we had one that had 3 bedrooms. I can probably still remember most of my neighbors all the way down, back and forth, because you saw them all the time. But you're talking about work. When my father deserted in 1958, there were seven of us. And there was no welfare system or anything to feed the children. My older brother, older sister, and I, we went out and found work. And in them days, you could redeem pop bottles for money. That's how we kept the younger ones alive, by getting bread and milk by redeeming pop bottles. And then we were real lucky. I got a job at the West Side Market. I was 8. What was it? It was some Italians owned it. It was vegetables. They weren't very nice because I didn't speak Italian and they were— I was You know, a young punk kid. And he paid me 35 cents a day and all the vegetables I could carry. And I got a paper route. I delivered the press, my older brother and I. Started doing a lot of jobs. You worked hard. I mean, I started working every day. I mean, every day from the time I was 8, just to support my brothers and sisters.
Rich Raponi [00:04:50] Did you attend school?
James Duncan [00:04:51] Oh yeah, I went to St. Augustine's. Yeah, it was great. My mother went to high school with the assistant pastor over there, so she had seven little Catholic kids that needed a school, and that's where we went.
Rich Raponi [00:05:05] Could you tell me maybe a little about St. Augustine?
James Duncan [00:05:08] Oh, it was in Mal. Don't leave.
Speaker C [00:05:11] I'm going home to get the ball.
James Duncan [00:05:13] Okay, I'll be right here. I'm going to finish this one and probably never drink again. Yeah, I know. St. Augustine's was, we like to say, compared to Our Lady of Mercy, there were 32 or 33 kids in each class at St. Augustine's. There were Irish, Italian, Hispanics, and Blacks. Okay? It was a microcosm. There was even a couple Polacks in there. I don't know how they got there. I'm just joking. That's a joke, okay? Sternowskis and the Kolinkowskis and people like that. And, you know, then there were the Marsicolas and the Duncans and the Carlins, you know, the Clipjacks. Hundreds of kids. Majority of the kids in the school came out of the projects. And that was, you know, we had a camaraderie there. We would, you know, everybody hung out together. We knew each other. The people you didn't like and the people you did like, you know. It was an interesting time. That was a great school. The nuns were outstanding educators. The one teacher that— second most influential grade school teacher I had was Sister Alberta over at St. Augustine's. Outstanding, oh, outstanding educator and just human being.
Rich Raponi [00:06:23] Why do you remember her so well?
James Duncan [00:06:25] Well, because she really was a great teacher. You learned how to learn, and that's very important. You know, you didn't learn how to do a test, you learned how to learn. You learned everything. And she had some miserable experiences in World War II in which she was able to relate. And she was the first person ever to say to us, say to me as a child, and she said it to like the whole class, There's a pope who will never get to heaven. And she was talking about Pius XII because he was dealing with the Nazis. And she said, shh, don't tell anybody I told you. It was a good, fine thing, you know. But, you know, going to school was interesting because all the schools started at the same time and ended at the same time. So as we came down Starkweather headed for the projects, we ran into the kids from Tremont, you know, and they were public school kids, so they thought they were badasses.
Rich Raponi [00:07:15] Was it fairly isolated by neighborhood at that time?
James Duncan [00:07:20] No, everybody lived everybody oh yeah, there were we had, as we called them, Republicans in the projects, kids who went to public schools, and there were kids who went to different Catholic schools, you know. And they closed down Our Lady of Mercy after my 7th grade year, and I went over to Our Lady of Mercy. And that's what they— and it was fortunate for us they brought in a new principal because the nuns there hated us, hated the kids from St. Augustine. Cause we were rabble rousers, as it were. It was an interesting fight and counterfight. And you know, the most interesting part about living in the projects was the people who lived in the projects, we all were in the same boat. We were very poor, and most of us had the same goal: never going back. And if we were out, we were not going back, just to visit maybe. And it was that was all racial. I mean, white, Black, Latino, everybody had the same idea. The problems we had were these white people who lived in this neighborhood would come down to the projects and start trouble, you know? And it was really, really insane, absolutely insane. I mean, it forced me to understand quickly that there are a lot of dumb white people. You know, that sort of you gotta wake up your head and shake. What? What did he say? No, I meant it. You know, they said stupid things. Yeah.
Rich Raponi [00:08:47] And as far as, what was your first interaction? Well, what was your first, for this building itself?
James Duncan [00:08:53] Dempsey's?
Rich Raponi [00:08:54] Yes.
James Duncan [00:08:55] I was out shining shoes. I was 7, maybe 8 years old. Could have been 9. But that was a way that, another way that kids could make money in the summer because, you know, we didn't have school anymore, so you could stay out trying to earn all night. My mother was mortified when she found out that jumping out the window with our shoeshine kits and going. I was lucky I got this place. Yeah, Mr. Rich's brother was not a good guy. Rich's father, I mean. Stash, he was not a friendly man, we like to say. But I was able to shine some shoes for people in here and make some extra money. Did here, Tim Ox[?], which that was crazy. That was full of hillbillies. You want to stay out of there.
Rich Raponi [00:09:39] How did that work? Did you?
James Duncan [00:09:40] You carried your sh-. Well, he didn't throw you out, then he was in de facto agreement with you, you know, because normally first they're, now get out of here, kid, you know. That was if you know, we used to work all the way up Scranton Avenue, the Pony on Auburn and Scranton, and Lincoln Heights Inn, which was over on Starkweather and Scranton. And it was Tim Ox and the two Hotzes, Hotz's over here and Hotz's, didn't go in the Hotz's over here, didn't- I'm crazy about them people.
Rich Raponi [00:10:10] So what was the clientele?
James Duncan [00:10:14] They were all the steelworkers. They didn't go right home. Well, the Hotz's, there was two Hotz's Cafe, one over here, right here on Starkweather and West 10th, and one on Professor a little bit east of Starkweather. That one was for the mailmen. That's where the mailmen, all the people, all the guys that delivered the mail, in this neighborhood, they would go there after they were done. Nobody bothered them. The steelworkers, you know, they went here, here, there. You know, it was basically a working man's area, you know? Yeah, and this was an absolute gorgeous joint.
Rich Raponi [00:10:49] Can you describe it?
James Duncan [00:10:50] This place, this phony ceiling wasn't here. This tremendous woodwork goes all the way up and into the ceiling. It is just laid out beautifully. You know, this was like the upper class of the neighborhood. Right here, right there, there was a bar right there in the middle of the bar for a waitress stand. And when the guys were in there drinking on Saturday morning, they didn't want any waitress around. So I would just go up and down and Mr. Stache would say, right there, don't you move. And as soon as he turned his back, I'd say, hey, anybody need a shine? Well, I called him Mr. Dempsey. I didn't know his last name was Dembowski until I got up close and they had a bunch of plaques over and I started reading them and, oh man, I've been calling them the wrong name. I'm giving them Irish names. No wonder he wants to kill me. You know, everything was all the men who hung out in the neighborhood were World War II vets, okay? They were the most miserable son of a guns. They were mean to kids that, you know, first they thought we all had to smoke cigarettes. So we did. You know, you're 8, 9, 10, 11 years old, they're giving you a cigarette and they're lighting it for you and you're standing there, sitting there talking to them. I started smoking cigarettes daily when I was 11. You know, yeah, it caused me to have a triple bypass when I was 50, but, you know, I haven't had a cigarette since. But, you know, it was just how they were. Everything, you know, you had to do it, you know, straight up and down, you know. In the '60s, when it became evident that most of them were also bigots, I had a very, very difficult time just even walking down the street because one of them they knew I was not, and I wasn't going to take any crap, you know. They'd start yelling, hey, hey, hey, you little and they'd use the N-word, lover, and I'd pick up a rock and hit them in the head with it, you know. Yeah, I am. I can throw good too. You know, it was fun. Lincoln Bathhouse was a bathhouse. That was a that's where people went and showered who didn't have baths or showers in their houses. Hell, there were houses on these streets that didn't have furnaces in them. These people were I mean, it was really cold.
Rich Raponi [00:12:50] For the Lincoln Bathhouse, do you know about when that opened?
James Duncan [00:12:54] I don't know. All I know is I started going there in the '50s, you know, '50s and '60s.
Rich Raponi [00:12:59] Duck Island.
James Duncan [00:13:01] Duck Island.
Rich Raponi [00:13:03] How much money could you make with shoeshining in the nights?
James Duncan [00:13:10] A couple. If I made $2, I was like the happiest guy in the world because I fed my family, my brothers and sisters, for 3, 4 days. 19 cents a loaf of bread. About 19 cents a half gallon of milk and a dime for a loaf of bread. You know, you could, you know, and once you get the staple meat was the big thing that we never had. It was really, it was expensive, you know, and it was very difficult. It was, you know, it was a strange time. I thought a few times that my mother became very ill in like '60 and '61, right after my father left. She got pneumonia. And my oldest sister and my older brother and I, we had and my younger sister was exactly 1 year younger than me we had 3 kids in diapers. We really didn't know what to do with them, you know. But we were able to do it. We were able to take care of them, you know, and get them going, get their lives rolling. It was probably '59 that she got sick.
Rich Raponi [00:14:04] So it was around '59 when you were shining shoes here?
James Duncan [00:14:07] Oh yeah, everywhere. Here, every bar around, working at the West Side Market. Got a real good job when I was 10. working at the Eagle Market. It was right on the corner of Thurman and Starkweather. There was an Eagle Market. It was a if you came up from West 7th heading, I guess it would be north, up Starkweather, there was a couple houses, a little candy store, Andy's. Cool, great people, treated everybody equally. Another house, a dry cleaners, Thurman Alley, then there was the Eagle Market. I got to work there. I was such a little short in stature kid that when I put my apron on, I had to roll it up like 5 times and it started at my breast and worked its way down. It was hilarious. And I was the produce guy. I could weigh it up and tell you how much it cost. One banana, 7 cents. And put my official line on it. You know, you had to put a little line on it. That was a great little gig. That's when I knew I was a leader. I knew for sure I was a leader. And I went on and just got a better job and helped take care of my brothers and sisters and got them all fed and in school. And I made a point to go to a different high school than every one of them, just to get away from them. You know, I mean, in '64, maybe '64, -5 or -6 of my buddies and I would get together and we'd build a treehouse.
Rich Raponi [00:15:35] On Quigley Avenue.
James Duncan [00:15:35] On Quigley Avenue. 4 trees. This treehouse was so exact that they were starting to build, they were just tearing down houses. It might have been '65, '66. And we would take the concrete forms for all the high from the highway, and we'd build a floor and then the walls. And then we, uh, trucks that hauled steel would cover them with canvas. Well, we found one of those on the back of a truck and we insulated our walls. And then we put a roof on it. And one of our guys was an electrical genius. We had electric lights, an alarm system, a bathroom, because we stole the piping right down the side of the tree, and a sofa and two chairs. It was a quite nice place. Quite nice. And I'll tell you what, my mother was the most happy then, because she didn't see me for an entire summer. She knew I was home because I'd come home to shower— or I mean shower— to take a bath. We didn't have showers on our projects. Take a bath and then grab my baseball glove and get out, you know. But she always knew that I was there because there'd be a pile of money on the table, you know. I went out and hung drapes. I worked for a drapery company when I was like 10 on the East Side. One of the few people, one of the few families that had a male in it, a man who was related to the woman and the father of the children, he was a he installed draperies and curtains. He was working for a company on the East Side called Gill Drapery on Lee Road, and he was such a lazy son of a gun, he needed help, and I got the job. I'll tell you what a great job this was. $3 a day plus two meals. I had breakfast and lunch. I hadn't had 2 meals on the same day ever, and it was just outstanding, you know? And I just didn't plus the money. We were able to start having beef. That was a big deal. You know, and pork and real meat and stuff for everybody. Because, I mean, come on, I'm working during the summer, worked every day, 6 days a week. That's $18. That was some big ass money, you know. And then they found our father and he was ordered to start paying child support, which showed up 2 or 3 times a year, you know. But it was incredible how just that and my sister started working babysitting my older sister, and between the two of us, we really did a fine job keeping food on the table.
Rich Raponi [00:17:57] Have you been in the neighborhood your whole life?
James Duncan [00:18:01] Oh yeah. Oh, well, I didn't live here. I moved out in 1971. We moved out of the projects, moved to West 6th Street. There was a guy over here with a picture of his great grandfather's bar. It was like two houses, three houses away from The Alley, West 6th. And we lived right down the street from it. And that was, uh, my older sister got married. I graduated high school, going off to college. Yeah, Cuyahoga Community College, going off to college, you know. But I was doing it, you know. And then I had an epiphany and I did something crazy in the South with some friends of mine. We went to get people registered to vote and stuff. That was, uh, it was just what we wanted to do. And, uh, but my family, you know, was able to— when they got in, it was serious. When we got out of the projects, we never went back. Never. It was, uh, not one of us. We all own our own homes. All 7 of us have our own home, you know, and did well considering like some of the people that we grew up with didn't. They didn't even survive their teen years. See, guns weren't as prevalent as they are now. If you had a disagreement with somebody, you fought. And you fought hard, you know. And I wore a corduroy coat in a neighborhood where if you didn't wear a leather, it was time to fight every day. Of course, you know, I was 4'1. I was a badass, you know. I wrestled 103 pounds my sophomore year in high school. That's how big I was. It was funny as hell. But learning how to manipulate myself through my childhood really, really came to pay later in life. Just understanding how to give people an idea that something needs to be done and make them believe they thought of it is real important.
Rich Raponi [00:19:58] After the When you were growing up, did you still continue to come to Dempsey's as a whole?
James Duncan [00:20:09] After I worked for the May Company downtown, and I was an executive there, and I was drinking in the downtown bars, and I said, why would I do that when I could come here? And a few of my really good friends still lived around, so I said, hey, why don't we meet over at Dempsey's? Oh man, that ought to be great. So I bring my wife, would meet us here, You know, we'd have dinner, and then when we had kids, we'd bring the kids in for Saturday afternoon, a little socializing. But Rich really it was good to see the family again. And see, when Rich took over, it lightened up a little bit, you know. You know, Stash wasn't as mean, didn't have as many mean things to say about us, you know. It was a good place. I loved this place. We came here for years. Yeah, it brought people, other executives, and we, a couple people that, one of my doc supervisors, a guy who worked for me, I got him in a bowling league down here, and that was just.
Rich Raponi [00:21:11] Now at that time, who was actually coming here?
James Duncan [00:21:15] Oh, a tremendous eclectic crowd. Father McNulty from St. Augustine was here a couple times a week, you know, talking to people and trying to get us all to get back in the church. My mother and him were best friends. And so whenever she was here, he was sitting there and he's pointing his finger at me, you know. Not everything's about making sure life is easier. Oh yeah, it is, Father. Good man. Great man, Father Joe.
Rich Raponi [00:21:46] Yeah.
James Duncan [00:21:48] Him and Rich had a little thing. Whenever he got people who Father Joe would get people over at St. Augustine's who hadn't had a meal. Going over to Dempsey's, here's a little note, hand this to Rich. You know, please feed them, I'll pay you later. And he'd. Rich would feed them. You know, sit down and have a nice dinner, and Father Joe come in, what's the tab? Here you go, bang bang, you know. And if one of us saw it, we'd always try to take care of it. When you were given every stitch of clothing on your back— here's, here's a really crazy thing about growing up real poor. I never got a Christmas present until I was like 12 that had my name on it. It was from some organization that said, boy, you know, 4 to 6. You know, hell, we didn't have I'll never forget not having a Christmas tree. We're sitting there, it's Christmas Eve, and there's no presents, no food, not a thing to eat, and nothing. All of a sudden there's a knock on the door, and it's real dark, and it's on the door that people who live in the neighborhood don't knock on. And I go and I open up the flap, and I see a tree out there, and I Open the door and there's just people, here's your tree, here's some food. And, you know, it actually saved the entire year because there was enough food to last through the cold winter. You know, that was some really vivid memories of being super hungry and smiling about it, saying, well, tomorrow I won't be. You know, it's just how life was.
Rich Raponi [00:23:14] Interesting place.
James Duncan [00:23:16] The South Side.
Rich Raponi [00:23:17] So you've seen the South Side change?
James Duncan [00:23:20] Oh, completely. When I left in the '70s, the projects there were riots in Cleveland in '64 and in '68, and the people who were displaced during the riots were sent to the projects down on the South Side. They'd never lived with white people before. White people only lived with the 30 families that already lived in the projects. It had never been a dominant Black and white neighborhood. So there were some problems making people understand there are certain ways— everybody has their own ways, you know. This is how I do things and this is how you do things. And it became, as my African American friends used to say, it's time for the white people not to come back in here anymore, only because I'm trying to keep you safe. You know, I mean, there was a basketball court which I was always on, and it was, don't come back anymore, man. These guys from the east side are crazy. They just want to kill you. You know, I said, thank you for the warning. You know, and the neighborhood became, um, white flight from Tremont. It's amazing. I never thought I would— I would say this is, um, '68 through '75, '76. Yeah, it was like what happened on the west side of Cleveland when they built I-90. You know, if you go down I-90, those were all neighborhoods. You know, I mean, there were 30,000 families that took off for the suburbs. That's, you know, and this is what happened in Tremont. Everybody said, oh my God, my goodness gracious. We were gonna and everybody, it was white flight. They just ran away because they saw overwhelming number of African Americans.
Rich Raponi [00:25:11] Yeah.
James Duncan [00:25:13] You know, I kept coming back because, hey, I don't care, it's my neighborhood, you know? And I've been living with Black people my entire life, you know? I didn't care. I wasn't gonna be intimidated out, and I wasn't gonna be I'm not a bigot, so I wasn't gonna be nothing was gonna change.
Rich Raponi [00:25:31] And in that transition, were most of the businesses Folding up, closing down?
James Duncan [00:25:34] You go up and down Prospect, Professor Avenue out here, where all these restaurants, they were all empty buildings. Yeah, and it was Michael Simon, when he opened Lola, he opened up the— and it started first Lola was right over here on Literary and Professor. Okay, he changed it to Lolita when he built Lola down on East 4th Street. But when he opened that restaurant and people found out how good it was, it just, like, the neighborhood just all these restaurateurs going, wow, what a great building for a restaurant, or a bar. And they just went right up and down and they did a fine job. Did a really fine job. My older brother, I think I neglected to tell you this, My older brother went to Lincoln High. In '67, he's at Lincoln High and they were assigning locker partners, and so him and a Black guy named Moses Jarvis became locker partners. Best friends. And the white people that were supposedly my brother's friends beat him with a tire iron because he wouldn't say, get this guy out of my locker. I went to West Tech. I went to a totally different school. We came down and paid them a visit, my old friends, and informed them that that kind of behavior will not be tolerated.
Rich Raponi [00:26:59] That's right.
James Duncan [00:27:00] In our own way. But that was the first time that the white kids in the neighborhood got an idea that it wasn't going to be a racial thing. It was going to be, you know, you're just stupid. And stupid people aren't allowed, so why don't you get out of the neighborhood? Inform them our way.
Rich Raponi [00:27:21] Thank you very much for your time. We definitely appreciate it.
James Duncan [00:27:27] No problem. No problem. I gotta go talk to my, that guy right there in the Rasta pullover, that's Eric Hooper. He grew up in the projects also. He did all right for himself. He was the. He's in the Lincoln West Hall of Fame for football.
Rich Raponi [00:27:46] Thank you again.
Prosperity Social Club 10 Year Anniversary Event
Interviews in this series were collected by students and staff at Cleveland State University’s Center for Public History and Digital Humanities during the ten year anniversary celebration at Prosperity Social Club in the Tremont neighborhood of Cleveland, Ohio. The event featured a gathering of the Dembowski family, who ran Dempsey’s Oasis – a neighborhood pub at 1109 Starkweather Avenue that later became Prosperity Social Club – from 1938-2000. The series includes interviews with members of the…